Lolly or Raymond?

[eeveelovee]

I don't have room for two gray cats on my island unfortunately, but I can't decide which one! HELP!

 

[Croconaw]

I’m biased but I like Lolly. You can’t go wrong with either cat.

 

[rocketspruggs]

Both cats have good designs, even though Lolly is better.

 

[CylieDanny]

Raymond is a cute smug boy, though all the smug are adorable. Raymond is a cutie. Appearance wise, I love his mismatched colored eyes, they look really cool. He's got cute grey/white stalkings, and a cute face. Alot of people have him as the office cat. He's a previous perfume comercial cat for me, just cause he looks like that kinda boy with that hair do going on. I'd call him Bishi cat, but thats what I call Marshal lol,

I've had my own Raymond for years, he even came to my own island from my first. Hes also the only one who gives me nick names.
--
Part of me thinks I just don't like Lolly because all I see of her on YouTube, and idk maybe I should invite her to my side. Have a nice cup of tea and talk, with the other girls xD I can see the good sides of her. She just doesn't really interested me as of right now.

So, big surprise.. I'm team Raymond here You should absolutely keep him.

 

[ShawnFuzz]

I have Raymond on my island, but between those two side by side pictures, I prefer Lolly because of the quirky smile, instead of Raymond's frown.

I prefer a happy cat!

 

[Nunnafinga]

Geez,this is kind of a tough decision.I have both of these cats(on different islands).With two good villagers like this I'd go for the one that has the personality I prefer.In this case it would probably be Raymond.

 

[KittenNoir]

I love cats haha and both are cute I have only had lolly before on my island and she was very cute

 

[Muna]

Cats are great and Raymond is great, but when I had him on my island I didn't like him as much as I thought I would. So Lolly it is, so cute and pretty

 

[ribbitribbon]

i have both of them on my island haha, but i’d say i’m more attached to lolly since i had/got attached to marshal way before i had raymond. tbh it’s more of a personal preference, but personally i’d keep both :>

 

[PacV]

Lolly for sure! Never had her, but i still think she would be a nice addition!

 

[Xara]

Which one you decide to keep is ultimately up to you. Something that helps me when I can’t choose between two villagers is I’ll put both of their names in a random name picker, and if I feel disappointed or sad with the villager that it picks, then that’s the villager I keep. Raymond and Lolly are both very cute, but it might be more helpful to think about which one you have more of an attachment to; which one you can’t imagine your island without.

Keeping them both if you like them equally is also an option ofc! I know you said that you don’t have room for 2 grey cats, but it’s okay to decide to keep both if you like them both too much to move one of them out.

I’ve had both of them on my island at different times, and if I had to choose between the two of them, I would go with Lolly. I like normal villagers more than smug ones, and I like Lolly’s design more than Raymond’s. I also have special memories of Lolly from New Leaf, and while the Lolly I had in New Horizons wasn’t the same as the Lolly I had in New Leaf, those memories would still influence my decision a bit.

But your decision is entirely your own, and whatever you decide to do is valid!

 

[Torts McGorts]

Lolly’s an underrated sweetie pie (or maybe not so underrated, at least based on this poll). I would go with her, but nothing against Raymond. I’m not big on smugs, but do usually keep one on my island for variety.

 

[Asarena]

I prefer Raymond, but Lolly is cute as well!

 

[Tylerhelt14]

I love them both.You should keep both of them.

 

[Sheando]

I tend to be drawn toward villagers who are less "classically cute," but I have a huge weak spot for Lolly. She was a permanent resident of my New Leaf town and is my favorite cat of all time.

 

[TN4U]

I shall share with you something I found on Pinterest:

I've guilted you into making your decision. You're welcome.

 

[ellienoise]

I chose lolly because she is one of my favorite villagers BUT if your signature is right and you already have Kiki, I would say get Raymond. I feel like his personality-species combo is really good. I do agree with xara, best way is to flip a coin or something and if you feel disappointed by the result that means you should pick the other one. Or you can try one and then if you don't like it, you can switch later! I would say try Raymond first as it is easy to find him online, since he is still a novelty.

 

[VernalLapin]

i like raymond but lolly takes the cake. team 6w6 for the win!

 

[QueenCobra]

I prefer Lolly, since I find her design cuter than Raymond’s. I also think the “normal” villagers are very sweet.

 

[Skeeve]

Lolly is one of the best kitty's paws downnnn