I started typing up a much bigger reads list last night but I had to work until 8pm (like 5 minutes ago) and I don't feel like finishing it so I'm making a more concise one right now. This is ordered from most townie to least townie. Tbh my stances are pretty similar to Evan's.
Cal/Evan - I totally sussed Cal at the beginning of D1 for his conflicting stances on Punchy, but then he started changing his mind about everyone (which I don't think scum would do), asking good questions, being aggressive and overall acting very towny and reflecting his meta from last game. He was also against the Kate lynch, points for that. Evan's reads list is pretty solid as well. So Calevanity is my strongest townlean for sure.
Bianca - Calling everyone scummy, wanting to lynch inactives (which I'm pretty sure she said earlier this game) and speculating on the setup are all things I have seen town Bianca do in past games. Scum Bianca (in my first game, which I can't recall the name of at the moment, the one where the whole #vanessaislying meme originated) literally just showed up, dropped a vote and left. She also had a different tone overall which she doesn't have here (she would start her posts like "Hi everyone!") So for these reasons I think she is town, however I would definitely like to see some reads from her assuming she is alive tomorrow.
Dad - Ok so originally I thought Dad choosing to vote Locket over Ghost, who he had been actively questioning, was very weird, but now that I think of it, why would Scum Dad vote for someone who nobody else was voting for? If he wanted to push a mislynch, wouldn't he just vote for Kate or Cal? Unless he is partners with Locket and trying to distance himself? Or just trying to confuse everyone? The last two are possible, but I've liked the rest of Dad's content overall so he is a townlean.
Punchy - I don't like his vote on Cal but at least he had reasoning for it. He's reflecting his town tone. Tbh I don't have much else to say about him which is why he's middle-of-the road in my list.
Locket - Cal vote is very sheepy and bandwagon-y. Reads list was all towns and nulls, however it reminds me of another game (American politics? maybe?) where her she was town and her reads list was like almost all nulls. That itself is definitely not scum indicative, however I've never seem scum Locket before so I don't really know what to look for. So I'm going to have to put her as third most suspicious for the Cal vote and lack of content.
Antonio - tbh I don't know what to make of his posts and this is mostly PoE and he just seems compatible with my top scumlean.
Ghostkid - ok. ok. ok. Did I just do a complete 180? Yes. Does that look suspicious as kracko? Yes. But hear me out. The only reason I really townleaned him before was because of the emotion in his posts, and how I didn't think he could fake it. But looking at posts and actions, he's definitely the most suspicious one here. The weird Cal sus/surprise reaction test, the sudden vote on Kate, the tone change....regardless of your alignment Gavin, you've definitely improved a lot this game and should be proud, but I'm gonna have to go with my gut and accept the fact that you could still use emotion in your posts as mafia. If he isn't scum, I really don't know who is.
" seems like a very fake reaction
