I do not have a list of which games are indie, so I don't know. Definitely
Contradiction, Pathologic 2, Minecraft, The Council, Shapeshifting Detective, and Point and Click adventure games. I can't really stand games like Hollow Knight, Celeste, Cuphead, that one popular dungeon game (forgot the name) that tries to be a new Zelda. They feel so unimmersive and the gameplay is a bit repetitive or shallow--combat stuff. Same probably goes for the overly anime-story type games.
I really prefer creative gameplay and deep immersive worlds, often gameplay that relates somewhat to solving stories and exploring around to do so, talking to people and finding things, unless the story's already part of everything you're making, like Banjo-Tooie and Mario Odyssey's explorations, so like
A Hat in Time. Those are my favorite of all, but Tooie's just on a different level.
However the light but pervasive story-involvement of
New Leaf is why I consider it a top tier game (exactly the same thing with A Link to the Past). It's a perfect pervasiveness. New Horizons is just creating and that's not good enough, when in Minecraft you can create rich online campaign worlds and fun games with friends.
New Leaf is where it's at, an alive-feeling purpose and world that feels like you're part of some story. Like ALttP, almost exactly the same ratio
. Games like these I want recommended to me, where you're exploring your sandbox and doing creative things, whether planning visualizations and relationships (New Leaf) or solving these concepts and relationships (ALttP and adventure games).
They're "sandbox" open worlds, but sandboxes aren't huge kingdoms, they're sandboxes--a place or lair to make your home, and focus in on actually doing stuff instead of roaming everywhere killing things (like new Zelda).
It's Classic Nintendo magic.
The
little stories and creative solvings. Banjo-Tooie my favorite game has all that too but it's different, and just like Animal Crossing, you backtrack and revisit the places you've been creatively engaging with, thus there's a history and sentimentality to your world.