I'd definitely say Kiki, but that's more because she was my all time favorite in Wild World and I adored her. I still kinda think she's super cute, but those eyes can be rather off-putting. =u=
Lucky is my favourite Halloween-themed villager.
I have no idea what Kiki, Cherry or Cobb's house themes are, or what Kiki or Cherry even look like, so I don't know why they're on the list. I can see why Gyroid Bunny is on there, and why Roscoe is on there (because he has red eyes), but I don't know about those three.
I think Cherry has a great Halloween theme going, Kiki and Roscoe are good too, black cat and black horse^^
Muffy the uchi gothic lolita sheep is my secret favourite though, should have been included in the poll
O dang! I actually had her in mind but somehow completely forgot that I was considering her as an option...
Aah, luckily we can talk about her in the thread