which peppy villager should i take?

[pochy]

i'm thinking of buying an amiibo card for my acnl town, but i'm unsure which of these three cuties to take... since my town has a lot of different animal types, except for a peppy and a dog or cat, i'm thinking of getting either cookie, rosie or merry!!

i wanted to hear others opinions, and idk if i'm on the right forum for this, but who should i get?

 

[lucylucy27]

All of these are cute!! I think you should go with whichever you like the most, which I understand is hard to choose because they’re all cute!! My personal favourite is Merry though

 

[FishHead]

Im gonna have to go with cookie, just because of my personal preference. My second choice would be merry though because I don't see a lot of people having her in their towns.

 

[pochy]

All of these are cute!! I think you should go with whichever you like the most, which I understand is hard to choose because they’re all cute!! My personal favourite is Merry though

i like merry too, and she's also a lot less popular than rosie (who lots more ppl have)

Im gonna have to go with cookie, just because of my personal preference. My second choice would be merry though because I don't see a lot of people having her in their towns.

yea, cookies design is adorable imo!

 

[Seastar]

It's a really hard decision, but I'm voting for Rosie. Plus her Amiibo card comes with Amiibo Festival, so maybe it won't be too hard to get?

 

[aloherna]

I like Cookie because I love her eyes and pink style! She’s currently my favorite villager in my island

 

[LadyDestani]

They're all cute, but I think Merry would be my favorite of the three.

 

[Mayor Ng]

Merry all the way! I'm bias towards cats so I'm going for Merry over Cookie. Between Merry and Rosie, definitely Merry as white cat is more natural than blue cat I've always liked Merry and Punchy as my preferred cat villagers.

 

[Xara]

they’re all adorable but i personally would choose merry! she’s such a cutie

 

[Clock]

Rosie, she is cute.

 

[katfromaramist]

I love Rosie but I got a little tired of her design after a while. I'd still pick her out of the three because I love the outside of her house! Which of the three's houses best matches your town?

 

[mangoseason]

I like Cookie who looks super soft Then again it depends on how she fits in with the other villagers in terms of aesthetics & personality. It's just she's a huge pink puppy!

 

[pochy]

I love Rosie but I got a little tired of her design after a while. I'd still pick her out of the three because I love the outside of her house! Which of the three's houses best matches your town?

aaaa i hadnt even considered the exteriors! thanks for the reminder. i really like rosies house too (the blue roof and pink facade + door are so cute), but i think the blue fence clashes a bit and i dont know how it would fit into my town ;-; maybe it’ll look good in my town if she’s moved in tho? idk,,

 

[memeshack]

I have Merry in my town, she moved in towards the beginning of my game and I love her so much! She’s adorable with her lil double chin and the absolute sweetest

 

[Koi Fishe]

I used to have Rosie, she was such a sweetheart and I loved her in the movie!

 

[pochy]

I used to have Rosie, she was such a sweetheart and I loved her in the movie!

omg i literally watched the movie yesterday rosie was adorable!!

 

[AntiJupiter]

Definitely Cookie! She's such a cutieee

 

[letisbloom]

Cookie