Nah. I keep seeing people talk about how calm and nice things were when New Leaf came out, and I've come to the conclusion that we must have been playing two different games haha.
I played New Leaf basically religiously from when I got it (around Black Friday 2013) until 2019. It was the same thing. People were still paying crazy prices for villagers. People like me (I'm not innocent and I'll be the first to admit it!) with good villager luck took advantage of that to make serious bells to pay crazy prices for furniture. If you thought Gracie Grace sets were expensive, wait until you see the prices I paid just for the convenience of not having to customize the whole Rococo set or to earn Mermaid furniture on my own.
There were still lots and lots of scammers, as there always have been and always will be. I remember having to google everyone's 3DS friend code before letting them into my town. It's a lot nicer now since you don't really lose anything. You're just mildly inconvenienced if someone plucks your flowers, for example.
The insane love/hate people have for villagers now? Also still a thing back when New Leaf was out. You're forgetting the meltdowns people would have over getting a voided StreetPass villager they didn't want or how people would show up to your town to buy an item and try to get you to cycle out a villager that was their dreamie (sorry friend, I ain't got time for that). Same thing with the racing for perfect towns. At least now things are in your control more or less. New Leaf had people doing some impressive reset magic to get their towns all nice and pretty, and don't even get me started on the cycling resets. Speaking of resets, I see people stress resetting their islands now and all of these comments about how it's so easy to feel bad about your island compared to other people's, but that was also still a thing in New Leaf. I think it was actually more of a thing in New Leaf since you couldn't just terraform, move buildings, or island hop for new villagers. I think most people held someone's stuff for them while they reset on New Leaf, had their items held by another player, or both.
I think people are just being nostalgic, especially people who haven't played New Leaf in years. New Leaf was just as crazy as New Horizons is. Being less popular wouldn't do anything about that other than make it less visible. Casual games have a way of evolving into something more intense than games that were designed to be intense in the first place- hope that makes sense. It's not limited to Animal Crossing. Look at how intense Pokemon breeding gets. :d
I'm really happy the community is so big now. Towards the end of New Leaf's life cycle, it got pretty lonesome when it came to things like trading or even just visiting others. I'm like 99% sure I was just hanging out with kids young enough to be
my kids on Club Tortimer at the end there.
