Firstly, I LOVE the Peppies! Their energy matches mine so well
Since I like their personality regardless it pretty much boils down to designs, and unfortunately a lot of them I just don't jive with
Top tier are Audie and Chrissy, no surprises for me there lol They're both my favorite of the Peppy types and I currently have both on my island. Audie is just insanely well designed and adorable and fits the Peppy personality well, and Chrissy is equally adorable and is pink, my favorite color
Not quite top tier but still pretty damn cute are Carmen and Sprinkle. Adorable designs again and Sprinkle's catchphrase "frappe" is way too cute
Cute/not bad tier are Dotty, Apple, Pinky, Bianca, Bonbon, Bunnie, Cheri, and Chai. Most in this tier are still very cute to me but fall just a little bit short of being the next level up. I'd still gladly take any of them onto my island though
Meh.... as it says, Peppies that I look at and just think "meh". They're just there to me
These would not be my first choice in most cases, but if I had no other options I'd take them. The most meh to me is Ketchup; it might be because of the food theme that she's so popular, but I just don't get it other than that
Other. The rest, only here due to strange, unappealing, or plain designs (to me at least, if you love anyone here more power to you). Though I think I'd move Peanut up to Meh tier in hindsight, her .w. face is kind of cute lol