This personality is one that I have a hard time picking out who will end up as the permanent Peppy of the island simply cause I find something unappealing in just about every single one of them.
S Tier
Audie is incredible, love her design all over. Sadly, my friend got her before me and locked that out from my island's choices.
Peanut was a tier or two lower before I adopted her in November right after Filbert thinking they looked cute together. She grew on me a lot, and I truly bonded with my little gamer squirrel. I let her go very recently though as I'm trying to shake up my island, and it was a difficult choice.
A Tier
Tammi was my DIY auto fill. I wasn't too happy with her initially, but she was a pretty solid villager with great reactions. Miss her sometimes.
Cookie is pretty darn cute.
Sprinkle may be the best penguin to me, may hunt for her come winter as I don't really like the Penguins outside of that season.
Flora borders on adorable and a little odd looking. Her home interior is a tragedy though.
Pinky is a big, joyous girl and I appreciate her for that. She was actually the Bear I planned on taking in before I ran into and ended up really enjoying Groucho.
Bangle and Bianca are pretty solid Tigers that I was typically tempted to take but always passed up. One day one of these ladies will likely come to my island.
Cheri was considered back in my more picky days for my island, but I didn't like how she always looked like she was looking out of the corner of her eye.
B Tier - I'll not go through all of those cause that's a lot, just some stand outs.
Ruby intrigues me, but her closed eyes expressions make her look like she has four eyes. There's been times when I'm thinking I will adopt her, but then I talk to her and get weirded out by her expressions.
I can't decide if Carmen is adorable or hideous. Same applies to Bunnie.
Patty's name is tragedy, kind of wish I took her in for my Cow instead of Tipper though.
Rosie is moving onto my island from the campsite, we'll see if she soars or sinks. Not really that excited for her, but I never had a cat villager yet.
Piper is easily the most tame looking Peppy, looks more like a Snooty to be honest.
C Tier
I never got the Merry hype, don't like her ugly fringe and always looking up eyes. She looks ridiculous. My hate for her has lessened though.
Gabi, Pippy, and Bonbon are all major flops for me for Rabbits even though they have noses simply cause I find them that unappealing.
Pate and Pango's colors are not pretty.
Bella and Cheri got some weird face things going on.
D Tier
Not a fan of the ear bows. You either are or aren't. And I am easily not a fan of it. No.
Tabby is an acquired taste that I have not acquired. I think I could see her moving up a tier to be honest, but I don't think she will ever be one of my tops.
Freckles, the fish faced duck, is a no.
Truffles is a disgrace to the other Pigs.
