• The New Horizons 3.0 update is here and we're hosting an eShop gift card giveaway! Each participant will also earn up to 60 forum bells. To participate, visit the event thread in the New Horizons board here. Good luck!

Mafia The Franchise Wars- Town & TP Win!

Haven't read through the thread thoroughly but there are a few things I didn't like:

- Town read on Karen by Dolby, I feel like it's too early but it's just like Dolby to town read someone THIS early. :p

- Ayaya's mafia guesses had three of the most experienced players and while yes, sure, you may have just looked at the player list and went like "hey, they might be all scum together tee-hee" but those three people specifically out of everyone else is weird. You've also mentioned that you go after/ read into more experienced players more than other players which is another reason why I'm wary of you and then you blamed it on your subconscious or something, lol? Eh, idk.

My thoughts are basically the same as everyone else's about Ayaya right now, I'm not scum leaning her right now but the post Ness made about Ayaya's other RQS in SU is making me think why she isn't like that in this game? It seemed less chill and more silly, if I'm going to be honest. Sorry. :(


Dolby can you explain the sus on Kirby, I understand your sus on Ayayayayayayayayaya though?
 
KermitTea said:
I'm flattered that y'all townreading me but it's lowkey sus
Click to expand...
*war flashbacks to Bowie in Smash maf*

Also disagreed entirely on why experienced players were pushed last game. It wasn't for the sake of experience: all 3 experienced pllayers who were scummy made plays that warrented questioning. Dolby/Endless with their terrible cases against eachother, and Cleb with his Jester Playstyle (Cleb, I get why you did it, but its bound to be looked at as sus lol). I really dont like that its being used as an excuse to not scrutinize experienced players

@biscuit senpai notice me

Still reading up atm

- - - Post Merge - - -

@Ayaya's RQS While I think her 3 choices were odd, I don't think it's a scumtell. Pretty sure she's answered that question seriously before, and it seems really out of the blue to put in 3 experienced people like that. I think she knows better than to bring attention to herself like that as maf.
 
Arstotzkan said:
*war flashbacks to Bowie in Smash maf*

Also disagreed entirely on why experienced players were pushed last game. It wasn't for the sake of experience: all 3 experienced pllayers who were scummy made plays that warrented questioning. Dolby/Endless with their terrible cases against eachother, and Cleb with his Jester Playstyle (Cleb, I get why you did it, but its bound to be looked at as sus lol). I really dont like that its being used as an excuse to not scrutinize experienced players

@biscuit senpai notice me

Still reading up atm

- - - Post Merge - - -

@Ayaya's RQS While I think her 3 choices were odd, I don't think it's a scumtell. Pretty sure she's answered that question seriously before, and it seems really out of the blue to put in 3 experienced people like that. I think she knows better than to bring attention to herself like that as maf.
Click to expand...

Thank you for the first paragraph!

---

And that's a fair point, she probably wouldn't do that as maf but I've never seen her as maf so I wouldn't know, people have patterns in every game so I would appreciate some links to your previous games @Ayaya. :) Just so I can see what you're like.
 
ya, what Dolby said about me combined about f11's note on him "pocketing" makes me envision a possible Dolby + f11 team but meh it's weak

- - - Post Merge - - -

combined with**

- - - Post Merge - - -

but then like we were scummates last game so he knows I freak out and think a lot when I'm maf so maybe he just noticed that change

- - - Post Merge - - -

Zendel said:
Thank you for the first paragraph!

---

And that's a fair point, she probably wouldn't do that as maf but I've never seen her as maf so I wouldn't know, people have patterns in every game so I would appreciate some links to your previous games @Ayaya. :) Just so I can see what you're like.
Click to expand...

she played in SU mafia (the one where you were scum) & got replaced d2 or something
 
atm my biggest FOS is Dolby. Felt like he just kinda jumped onto Cleb's train of thought when he knew that there was a damn good reason why he was getting pushed, plus all the pocketing.

Slight townread of Biscuit, Fireninja, and Karen. Kirby putting focus on only answering Dolby's RQSs felt sketchy, and Kit's RQSs rubbed me the wrong way.
 
KermitTea said:
ya, what Dolby said about me combined about f11's note on him "pocketing" makes me envision a possible Dolby + f11 team but meh it's weak

- - - Post Merge - - -

combined with**

- - - Post Merge - - -

but then like we were scummates last game so he knows I freak out and think a lot when I'm maf so maybe he just noticed that change

- - - Post Merge - - -



she played in SU mafia (the one where you were scum) & got replaced d2 or something
Click to expand...

I want a variety of games and that game in specific isn't much to go by, she was inactive for a lot of it and like you sad she got replaced day 2.

I want some scum games from her and now that I think about it I think her previous games where provided in that game, I'll check now. :)

- - - Post Merge - - -

where = were
 
Arstotzkan said:
atm my biggest FOS is Dolby. Felt like he just kinda jumped onto Cleb's train of thought when he knew that there was a damn good reason why he was getting pushed, plus all the pocketing.

Slight townread of Biscuit, Fireninja, and Karen. Kirby putting focus on only answering Dolby's RQSs felt sketchy, and Kit's RQSs rubbed me the wrong way.
Click to expand...
any reasons for slight town lean the 3? Or is it just a gut feeling?
 
Kirbystarship said:
any reasons for slight town lean the 3? Or is it just a gut feeling?
Click to expand...
really liked Biscuit's RQSs, especially the "I want to be noticed" part. Don't think noob scum would say that.

I like Fireninja's and Karen's tone, feels confident and relaxed.
 
I hate myself for bringing this up again but like there's got to be one maf in kat dolby Cleb right ~for balance~

and rn it's pointing to Dolby
 
KermitTea said:
I hate myself for bringing this up again but like there's got to be one maf in kat dolby Cleb right ~for balance~

and rn it's pointing to Dolby
Click to expand...
I'd add Ayaya and yourself to that list (bc if you didn't prove yourself last game god damn). But ye agreed about Dolby.
 
Arstotzkan said:
atm my biggest FOS is Dolby. Felt like he just kinda jumped onto Cleb's train of thought when he knew that there was a damn good reason why he was getting pushed, plus all the pocketing.

Slight townread of Biscuit, Fireninja, and Karen. Kirby putting focus on only answering Dolby's RQSs felt sketchy, and Kit's RQSs rubbed me the wrong way.
Click to expand...
How so?
 
@Zendal, Kirby was for ignoring the fact that Ayaya went radio silent for 25 minutes and shifting fos onto Kat for ignoring the RQS

Also smh Kat, only my first case on Endless was terrible, the next two were good

Also @Kat, where did Kirby shift focus into my RQS? Or did you mean my random questions vs Zendals? Tbf, I felt like three of my questions had worth, vs two of Zendals

- - - Post Merge - - -

Actually, I don't like Ness's tone while addressing Ayaya, or his reasoning. Will look for into that when I get home at 1 PST

- - - Post Merge - - -

Kit said:
How so?
Click to expand...

Thoughts on the current situation?
 
Dunno. Haven't played in awhile and everyones talking about things that would require prior knowledge of how certain players act.
I think we should be overall wary of who we townread at this point and ensure we don't let any one player take the lead as the "decider of all things."
Going off the current RQ's I'm not really getting anything from anyone. I was suprised when people scumread me before I had even posted, so I don't think that they're an incredibly reliable tool for anything but getting conversation started. Other people's analysis of those RQ's though, that's probably where all the real tells lie.
 
@Kit "I'll tell you what I'll be known for at the end, kappa"

Feels really non-committal

@Dolby You were sus for more than just the first case tho. EOD on Day 1 was pretty shady on your part.

But regarding the RQS, while yours may have had more useful info, that isn't the reason Kirby gave. Yours "came first". Which felt like a really weak reason to favor one RQS over another. Glad everyone's answering both, though.
 
Oh yeah, I know I was sussed for more than that. I'm just very sensitive about my scumplay. Forgot Kirby said that last night, but it's something that he'd say as a reason as both alignments imo

- - - Post Merge - - -

Sensitive about my scumplay referring to the terrible cases comment

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also gonna say that looking back at his past play, pressuring people over not answering the RQS is normal behavior for Kirby(over post amount between RQS and entrance), so rescinding that idea
 
Kat what was the last game you were scum in? Can you give me the link?

- - - Post Merge - - -

Smh Kat I've been waiting 10 minutes

- - - Post Merge - - -

Smh Kat I've been waiting 10 minutes
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Damniel
Mafia Among Us Mafia Game Thread (Town Win!)
139 140 141
Replies
3K
Views
187K
unravel
unravel
Damniel
Mafia Monster Mash Mafia Game Thread (Town Win!)
47 48 49
Replies
979
Views
52K
Totally_RandomYT
Totally_RandomYT
Damniel
Mafia August 2021 Mafia Game- Town Win!
25 26 27
Replies
536
Views
27K
N e s s
N e s s
Damniel
Mafia A Prolonged Signups: The Game (Mafia Win)
10 11 12
Replies
239
Views
12K
Jacob
Jacob
Damniel
Mafia Into the MarioVerse Kingmaker- Mafia Win!
109 110 111
Replies
2K
Views
103K
N e s s
N e s s
Back
Top