Mafia TBT Scummies Awards 2019: Game Thread - Endgame

[Byngo]

posting the obligatory jacob is sus because i csnt read him so it’s always my assumption that he’s scum

 

[Jacob]

Important Questions to Answer Stage:

1. Name the scum team Well let's look at what we know objectively:

List of those who have posted a notable amount of times:

- Dolby
- Dad
- Damniel
- Chele (scum probably)
- Trundle
- Heyden
- Mog
- Kallie
- Justin
- Sensai
- Byngo


List of those who are have not really substantially active: From my experience around 2 mafia members are very active in the beginning while the rest lay relatively low for majority of day 1.

- Unravel
- Bianca
- Tina
- Toadsworthy
- Dedenne2



Posts containing AtE or some kind of personal excuse: These are not always scummy, individual analysis needed. Posts about new playstyles or reasons for inactive more often than not are sincere. Posts trying to gain sympathy or respect from other players is usually scummy.

Please forgive my sins

I think Mog is a good lynch candidate. I will do an ISO when I get the chance

Also I've only gotten one message and it's kallie calling me a *****, I feel left out already.

I never realised curiosity about something I have never heard of before would be taken so seriously : (

Posts with pocketing-like energies:

Toads oked me telling y'all this, he claims that he's post-restricted to one post per day phase

i for one agree

Natty is my biggest townread tbh along with trundle

OMGUS:

dolby told me he's scum yikes

dolby: i'm scum lol don't tell anyone lol (16:56)
me: lol (01:61)

This is exactly why I was mixed on Mog/Dan

Considering Dan jester Mog ???? maybe maf

"1:61" real time guys

At least I KNOW for sure at this point that Mog is acting different from last game

Oh **** you've caught me!

Yeah this is the Damniel that I don't think is town

Uhhhhh

No I am with the town. I support the town. I love the town.

We should shoot Mog

- - - Post Merge - - -

Natty Mog Justin scum team?

Opportunistic Posts and Posts awkwardly pushing forth the game:

I am already reading Sensai as scum so few posts in lol, I know it's a meme game but D1 lynch ez

Alright, Dan's behavior so far this game seems somewhat atypical from what I remember him being in that there just isn't the content but it's early game so I'm not willing to pursue it hard yet. His vote is the only thing I take issue with so far

Are you scum?

Why is Juche superior to communism?


To be blunt

What
The
************************************************






Ok, reading into these more deeper, I'm just admit that I put a mental block around anything that's less than two lines on a computer screen in the early game. But tbh I can def see Damniel's viewpoint as far more legitimate after seeing these in more depth (in b4 Mog have to put a question mark in every post and I'm actually the only person not post-restricted). Keeping in mind that his joke did start out as a joke but evolved into something serious



The circumstances around Dad's claim to be is townish

I really don't see Toads faking one post per day, like, he's just better that to be blunt



This is something that I like seeing tbh. On a gut level


Are you third party?


And now I remember why I didn't like Dan earlier


Chele puts NY first! I'm voting for her

The only solild reads that I have is that Toads and Dad are town I don't think that either of them go this route as scum. Post restriction just doesn't seem like something either are inclined to do as it somewhat restricts they're ability to form relationships. Especially since Dad said he got a warning

Also as a ftr Toads disagrees with me on Dad

I want everyone lurking right now to provide one serious, solid read

Wait what are you being serious?

Intelligent Posts:

My case on Dolby

TDRL I want dolby lynched

Players who have dynamic interactions
Daniel x Natty
Dolby x Daniel
Dolby x Dad
Dolby x Toadsworthy
Trundle x Sensai
Mog x Daniel



And finally- Improbably pairings based off of interactions AND my guts feelings (Teams that WOULDN?T make sense):
Dolby x Dad
Dolby x Toads
Daniel x Natty
Chele x Mog
Daniel x Mog
Dolby x Chele
Kallie x Dad
Mog x Justin

Cross referencing everything makes = Dolby / (Trundle or Kallie) / Sensai / (Bianca/Dedenne/Tina) as the most probable scum team !



Jk, I don?t actually know who could be mafia !!!!!


Although, I am confident there probably is a hostile 3rd party and 4 mafia. If you?re 3rd party or mafia, please message me and test your acting skills. =) x

2. Are you mafia? No thank god I can't be maf after last game ever again
3. What?s your favorite breakfast food ? I do not eat breakfast
4. Do you believe Mog is scum ? Omg Always of course
5. How do you deal with pressure? So poorly, I was just hospitalized for my anxiety a couple weeks ago. BRUH lollll D;
6. Do you feel pressured with my questions? YES!!!



------

I believe that there could be a role that curses people with some random filter. Dan said he?s cursed for a certain amount of time so idk. Maybe the curser could probably curse once a phase or something

Chele is Mafia Curser confirmed.

 

[Byngo]

lol he posted right i mentioned him

are we connected?

 

[Jacob]

posting the obligatory jacob is sus because i csnt read him so it’s always my assumption that he’s scum

Every game

 

[Byngo]

after i*

 

[Damniel]

Natty who do you wanna see ded today (◕‿◕)

 

[EpicGamer12]

Natty who do you wanna see ded today (◕‿◕)

honestly with how you're posting i wouldn't be surprised if you were like oath2order or Ashtot

 

[Jacob]

honestly with how you're posting i wouldn't be surprised if you were like oath2order or Ashtot

Ohhh this is also probably why Justin is writing in that font


(was this an already assumed thing)

- - - Post Merge - - -

i wouldn't be surprised if you were like oath2order or Ashtot

Or Oswaldies

 

[Heyden]

I think justin has an actual post restiction to write in multicoloured comic sans but daniels one is just to be annoying imo lmao
Dads is probably real but toads is probably faking it tbh

 

[EpicGamer12]

Ohhh this is also probably why Justin is writing in that font


(was this an already assumed thing)

- - - Post Merge - - -



Or Oswaldies

Jacob is town

 

[Byngo]

Natty who do you wanna see ded today (◕‿◕)

trundle

- - - Post Merge - - -

for no particular reason, maybe

 

[EpicGamer12]

trundle

- - - Post Merge - - -

for no particular reason, maybe

That's funny, because I don't want to see myself dead

 

[Jacob]

If you?re 3rd party or mafia, please message me and test your acting skills. =) x

Brazen Today at 10:03 PM
Why the hell you sus me for inactivity when I can?t talk
Seen
Weeb*


Your fate is sealed Toads. Please use your 1 post to say goodbye, scum. Sad.

 

[Dolby]

I think justin has an actual post restiction to write in multicoloured comic sans but daniels one is just to be annoying imo lmao
Dads is probably real but toads is probably faking it tbh

Tbh just from the way Dad went about things I trust him more than Toads, but why would you say Toads is likely faking it?

 

[Chele]

I think justin has an actual post restiction to write in multicoloured comic sans but daniels one is just to be annoying imo lmao
Dads is probably real but toads is probably faking it tbh

Justin has been using the post restriction since he started posting.
Daniel states that he has reviewed a curse after D1 had started.
And Dad is writing in poems because he?s most likely Toads.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Recieved* hell me

 

[radical6]

Important Questions to Answer Stage:

And finally- Improbably pairings based off of interactions AND my guts feelings (Teams that WOULDN?T make sense):
Kallie x Dad

before we even got our role pms dylan wanted us to both be scum smh

 

[Geoni]

Jacob's post is very convoluted
but I think it's town for the approach alone
my dog just pooted
but don't put too much stock in this read cause it's just tone

- - - Post Merge - - -

Heyden that 'case' is a bunch of quotes
tell me why you think Dolby's post read as red
I'm really into boats
poetry makes me wish I was dead

 

[Heyden]

Heyden that 'case' is a bunch of quotes
tell me why you think Dolby's post read as red
I'm really into boats
poetry makes me wish I was dead

dear dad, please read my case again
all the information is there
and thanks to my role
this poem doesnt have to rhyme

- - - Post Merge - - -

I'm going to sheep trundles vote because he is kind and caring

 

[dedenne]

1. Name the scum team

me
2. Are you mafia?
yes

3. What’s your favorite breakfast food ?
PANCAKES I JUST HAD SOME

4. Do you believe Mog is scum ?
no bc im scum

5. How do you deal with pressure?
by eating

6. Do you feel pressured with my questions
yes ur making me very sad dont do this to me

 

[Chele]

-

What are your thoughts on everything that has happened so far? (Sensai, Waffles’ doctor claim, etc)