Kiki or Molly?

[vvindows98]

okay so, i already have Molly in my town. I really like her design and she was a dreamie, but I had an idea recently - have all the 'mythical' villagers such as Drago the dragon, Hans the yeti, etc. Kiki fits with this theme better (lucky black cat) but I'm kinda attached to Molly? what do

 

[Moon Witch]

kiki
1000x kiki
molly is cute and everything but kiki is the best villager ever don’t @ me you all know it’s true

 

[Flare]

If you seem really attached to Molly then i'd say keep her. I personally feel villagers shouldn't really matter when it comes to themed towns.

 

[doodle]

Oooh that sounds like a really cool theme and I think Kiki fits too! I love Molly myself (I had to replace her in Astoria because I just had too many Normals), but I think your idea sounds pretty neat. ^^ So, Kiki perhaps?

 

[Bluebellie]

I think kiki fits better and she is super adorable! Ive had her in all My towns. She definetly fits the mystical theme better though.

 

[-Blue-]

Kiki is my favorite little kitty, so I have to go with her.

Spoiler

 

[Nunnafinga]

I have both of them but I would pick Kiki over Molly.Kiki was in my Gamecube town and she popped up in my campsite not long after I started playing New Leaf so I snapped her up again.She's been one of my favorites for a long time.

 

[AngelBunny]

keep molly as a villager i mean u have mystical animals but what about normal villagers?

 

[Anactoria]

I voted for Kiki without having read your question lmao, but since you like Molly, just keep her. I used to want Molly as well--still kind of do--but I always get a little sick of the purely cute villagers (her house is FANTASTIC though). I've had Kiki every time I've restarted, just can't get enough of her little red mouth and weird ass western house

 

[Haskell]

I say Kiki because she's in my (2 day old) town and she's great.

 

[toonafeesh]

I would've voted for Kiki since she's adorable and would fit nicely with your town theme, but if you love Molly I'd say make an exception for her and keep her!

 

[FantasticHaxorus]

If Molly was a dreamie, then I'd say keep her. I also personally like her design better, but that might just be me.

 

[idiotdoomspiral]

i'm quite attached to molly too, but kiki definitely suits your theme.

 

[ShinyFinderNoah]

Molly 100%

 

[OLoveLy]

the black cat kiki ! ? v ?

 

[Halloqueen]

I greatly prefer Molly's design over Kiki's, but I'm leaning toward Kiki for the sake of the town's theme. I have three themed towns and feel like having any villagers that don't fit the theme would eventually prove to bother me enough that I'd end up replacing them anyway. I'm actually facing that issue at the moment, though in my case I'm just planning to move the villager in question to one of the other towns where I feel he'll fit better.

 

[Garrett]

I voted for best girl Kiki.

 

[duckykate]

i have kiki in my town right now and i hate her. she's super ugly and her house is weird

 

[Sloom Lagoon]

Molly! Shes my fave villager! I love her so much, she's so cute and nice