Help me pick my smug? 🥹

[misstayleigh]

hii all!! I recently decided to let Raymond move on, because I have three permanent cat dreamies and wanted to diversify a bit haha

my current line-up includes:
Bob the lazy cat
Kiki the normal cat
Olivia the snooty cat
Sylvana the normal squirrel
Dotty the peppy rabbit
Agnes the sisterly pig
Hamlet the jock hamster
Frett the cranky dog
and most recently, Dobie the cranky wolf!

I also have Tangy the peppy cat, but she will be getting the cat boot next lol. because I replaced Raymond with Dobie, I’m missing a smug, and can’t pick who to hunt for! my island Koriko doesn’t really have a theme; I’m going for colorful and whimsical across the island~

 

[nymble]

maybe marshall or henry? i don't have any smug villagers at the moment on my island but those two would be the ones i considered

 

[misstayleigh]

maybe marshall or henry? i don't have any smug villagers at the moment on my island but those two would be the ones i considered

I also love Marshall!! I think I excluded him since I already have Sylvana as a squirrel, but I’m not yet as attached to her so could possibly swap her for him if I wanted?

 

[rrenaa]

Julian is one of my favorites and I think he fits perfectly into a colorful, whimsical island!

 

[Roxxy]

Julian always no question.

 

[S.J.]

I'm partial to Henry and Roswell, but I think for a colourful and whimiscal theme, Julian or Henry would be good choices!

 

[Dim]

Kiki and Bob, a real one I see.

ANYWAYS, if you're going for that "colorful and whimsical" theme definitely Julian. I am going for a whimsical/fantasy theme for my island myself and I chose both Julian and Ken.

 

[UpFalls]

I don't generally like the alligators but I've run into Roswell multiple times on villager hunts and every time I want to take him back but for reasons have to keep looking. If I run into him again I'll most likely grab him.

 

[Grishiu]

If you wanted to stay away from cats I'd say Shep, but I see you already have a dog! If you want something different my votes are for Eugene or Zell!

EDIT: Oh my I missed the part about wanting someone colourful/whimsical my bad. In that case I think the most colourful smug is Pietro but I don't really like him Some people adore him though