My town isnt full yet, but Im supposedly going to get Zell and Blaire really soon so, once thats done... Im not sure if Id like to have an 11th villager (I like having an equal ammount of girls and guys in my town.). But if could have up to 12 id probably pick Zucker-Punchy-Rolf and Lolly-Flurry-Skye.
Since I've only got 9 villagers in town right now, #10 would be Kidd, and #11 would be Mira. I miss them both from my original village, and would love to have them back.