One of my friends who has a 360, of which I'll hopefulky be getting one soon, has BioShock and Halo 3.
I played both, Halo more, never-the-less I highly enjoyed both.
And both greatly deserve to be up for GotY.
No offense, but Halo 3 doesn't stand a chance/deserve it. But do tot he entire gaming population that owns it. It will definitely get a nominee. I think Bioshock deserves it though. Bioshock is a great game overall. But I still want FE to win.