ive had an eye on Octavian for a while after seeing some people's screenshots of him in game. after getting the first 6 villagers on my island, i decided id hunt for a snooty and cranky specifically to have one of every personality while my island's still in the early stages of development. he was the first cranky i came across after a looong search (the game kept giving me jocks!!) and man, i really like him. his house exterior isn't what i was rly looking for but?? he's just so lovely??? he seems like a mean old dude but he's rly nice. i think i'll let him go at some point; i want to experience as many villagers as the game has to offer. but i will definitely get his amiibo card and invite him again once im through with my goal (or whenever i get tired of it). though this is my plan now, i may end up just keeping him around forever once i start trying to get new villagers on my island.
villagers that you will never ever kick out?
- Thread starter ekcomyth
- Start date
I guess this is kinda personal to me, one of the first villagers I got in NH was Tia and I only got her because I knew she was a unique and harder to find villager.
I had actually just moved out for the first-time this year around the time I got NH, living on your own can make you pretty homesick at first it turns out, cause I really bonded with Tia as she really reminds me of my mum. My mum loves tea, and is really innocent just like Tia, if she was any villager in the whole franchise she would be Tia for sure, and now I can't bring myself to get rid of her even though she doesn't fit my aesthetic at all
Whenever I feel a bit homesick Tia cheers me up a little bit.
I had actually just moved out for the first-time this year around the time I got NH, living on your own can make you pretty homesick at first it turns out, cause I really bonded with Tia as she really reminds me of my mum. My mum loves tea, and is really innocent just like Tia, if she was any villager in the whole franchise she would be Tia for sure, and now I can't bring myself to get rid of her even though she doesn't fit my aesthetic at all
Whenever I feel a bit homesick Tia cheers me up a little bit.
Jinglefruit
The black-nosed Reindeer
My intention with NH was to not get my dreamies in my town, as in NL I got several of my favourites in my first 10 and didn't see much villager rotation after that. However, I ended up way way too attached to several villagers and now I refuse to let the following leave:
Pango - One of my first 5, and honestly the one villager/personality I have never gotten tired of talking to. I wasn't huge on the peppy villagers in other games but she has made me laugh out loud so often. We are best friends and the town just wouldn't feel right without her.
Judy - I liked her design originally and wanted to experience the new villagers early on, and replace with favs later. But Judy has become my favourite snooty villager now. (and there are a lot I like!) I don't feel she fits 'snooty' though, she's just chaotic. If something weird is happening, or there's a glitch, or something sinister like trading for skeletons, it is always Judy. She cute on the outside and corruption on the inside. 10/10 character.
Kidd - Zell will always be king of smugs to me, but Kidd came mincing into to town and immediately became the gbf to me and Pango. I feel like the 3 of us became the weird kids clique of town and the rest of the villagers see us and are like; 'alone they are fun, but all 3 together they're too much.'
Reneigh - Was never a huge fan of the uchi villagers in NL other than Muffy, and I didn't want Muffy again. I debated foregoing the personality entirely, but thought I'd give Reneigh a try, and I now love her. I see her as the villager who doesn't care what she wears, but whatever you give her she looks fabulous. Cause honestly her colour scheme matches everything and I'm jealous.
I also have Biff, Spike and Kiki, who I am not as attached to, but I don't think I'd trade them for anyone else in their personality group, so they're probably going to be around for the long haul. And Flora, even though that makes 2 peppies, I just love flamingos too much to let her leave.
Pango - One of my first 5, and honestly the one villager/personality I have never gotten tired of talking to. I wasn't huge on the peppy villagers in other games but she has made me laugh out loud so often. We are best friends and the town just wouldn't feel right without her.
Judy - I liked her design originally and wanted to experience the new villagers early on, and replace with favs later. But Judy has become my favourite snooty villager now. (and there are a lot I like!) I don't feel she fits 'snooty' though, she's just chaotic. If something weird is happening, or there's a glitch, or something sinister like trading for skeletons, it is always Judy. She cute on the outside and corruption on the inside. 10/10 character.
Kidd - Zell will always be king of smugs to me, but Kidd came mincing into to town and immediately became the gbf to me and Pango. I feel like the 3 of us became the weird kids clique of town and the rest of the villagers see us and are like; 'alone they are fun, but all 3 together they're too much.'
Reneigh - Was never a huge fan of the uchi villagers in NL other than Muffy, and I didn't want Muffy again. I debated foregoing the personality entirely, but thought I'd give Reneigh a try, and I now love her. I see her as the villager who doesn't care what she wears, but whatever you give her she looks fabulous. Cause honestly her colour scheme matches everything and I'm jealous.
I also have Biff, Spike and Kiki, who I am not as attached to, but I don't think I'd trade them for anyone else in their personality group, so they're probably going to be around for the long haul. And Flora, even though that makes 2 peppies, I just love flamingos too much to let her leave.
tolisamarie
Senior Member
All my bear cubs are permanent! I can't imagine my island without them - any one of them!
elphieluvr
Wave-Tossed Mermaid ~ she/her
Bianca is my favorite villager of all time, I haven't had a town without her in years. I also can't kick out Marina bc (very long story short) she's in a romantic relationship with my favorite stuffed octopus and he'd be upset. (Don't ask.)
Right now I'm really attached to Punchy and Julian too, but I don't know if that's a never ever kick out scenario. Although I did just spend 45 minutes designing a star-based yard outside Julian's house, so he's not going anywhere any time soon lol.
Right now I'm really attached to Punchy and Julian too, but I don't know if that's a never ever kick out scenario. Although I did just spend 45 minutes designing a star-based yard outside Julian's house, so he's not going anywhere any time soon lol.
Dreamcloud
Senior Member
Pietro, Tia and Erik are definitely staying.
Pietro was my first campsite villager. I hated his design until he actually moved in and I fell for him completely!
Tia was one of my first five but I wanted her proper interior so I let her go and brought her back with amiibo. I regretted it and got rid of her again but then missed her so much I brought her back with amiibo again a few weeks back. I just can't get rid of her for a third time!
Erik's just lovely.
I'll probably be keeping Rudy, Static and Muffy too.
The other four (Plucky, Patty, Blanche and Greta) I'm undecided on at the moment.
Pietro was my first campsite villager. I hated his design until he actually moved in and I fell for him completely!
Tia was one of my first five but I wanted her proper interior so I let her go and brought her back with amiibo. I regretted it and got rid of her again but then missed her so much I brought her back with amiibo again a few weeks back. I just can't get rid of her for a third time!
Erik's just lovely.
I'll probably be keeping Rudy, Static and Muffy too.
The other four (Plucky, Patty, Blanche and Greta) I'm undecided on at the moment.
Marshmallows
chocoholic ☕🍫
Fauna. 
I wanted to replace almost all villagers with the seasons, but can't bring myself to kick out Twiggy or Zucker, either.
I wanted to replace almost all villagers with the seasons, but can't bring myself to kick out Twiggy or Zucker, either.
Bones and Lucky are definitely eternal villagers for me. Bones was my first dreamie hunt which ended right around 60 or 70 tickets. Lucky on the other hand... took me around 2000 - 2100 NMTs to finally find. Multiple months of hunting on and off he finally came home. 
The only other villager I don't think I'd ever kick out would be Ankha. She became one of my favorites in NH for sure.
The only other villager I don't think I'd ever kick out would be Ankha. She became one of my favorites in NH for sure.
I literally cannot play Animal Crossing without Marshal omg I rage quit New Leaf cuz he moved out during my exam week (got him back later) and for New Horizons, I was fortunate enough to get his amiibo for free from a close friend. <3
Egbert. 110% he is staying on my island forever. I just love him so much and I was so thrilled when I found him on an island and got him to move in! I think I might keep Murphy too because I just love how he’s this cute little bear cub who’s got the personality of a grumpy old man lol.
I hate saying good bye to any villager (I recently let Colton move away when Sherb showed up in my campsite) but I think eventually I’ll be okay with eventually letting everybody else move away.
I hate saying good bye to any villager (I recently let Colton move away when Sherb showed up in my campsite) but I think eventually I’ll be okay with eventually letting everybody else move away.
Bea 
I never had her in the previous main games but when I started playing PC I met her and she's my perpetual visitor LOL. I knew I had to get her in NH as well and I'm dearly attached to her now, especially after fleshing out her backstory on my island.
I'm also becoming attached to Vivian even though she's my most recent villager. We haven't bonded that much but I'm so so glad I got to adopt her, her personality and house match her design sooo well.
I never had her in the previous main games but when I started playing PC I met her and she's my perpetual visitor LOL. I knew I had to get her in NH as well and I'm dearly attached to her now, especially after fleshing out her backstory on my island.I'm also becoming attached to Vivian even though she's my most recent villager. We haven't bonded that much but I'm so so glad I got to adopt her, her personality and house match her design sooo well.
Blood Eclipse
𖤐 ♱ 𖤐
Raymond: it took me so many gruelling months (real months) of fast fowarding time and using the campsite method trick. I had no other smug villagers on my island, and even like that Raymond would just refuse to visit. I spend a lot of tickets jumping from mystery island to mystery Island in hopes of finding him that way, but nope, didn't appear either. I was slightly considering buying him from someone for nmt, but most were going for 600 nmt and up. Big nope. Finally got him last month and was freaking out a bit. It's ridiculous I know, but still.
Dom: Dom is baby
Zucker: I have his amiibo, so I may kick him out for a bit to collect photos of other villagers, but he's coming back. Zucker is still my favorite takoyaki.
It's ridiculous I know, but still.Dom: Dom is baby
Zucker: I have his amiibo, so I may kick him out for a bit to collect photos of other villagers, but he's coming back. Zucker is still my favorite takoyaki.
niko@kamogawa
I am hungry for storage space!
So far, I have a total of nine permanent villagers residing in my island. I am only likely cycling Marina out in the future.
So far, she's adorable but I dislike her species.
So far, she's adorable but I dislike her species.
kid cat; he was my starter jock and while i initially wasn’t planning on keeping him permanently, i grew attached to him during the game’s first week and he’s been with me ever since. granted, i have toyed with the idea of letting him leave as i’m not too fond of the jock dialogue but honestly? i can’t imagine him not being on my island anymore; he can be an annoying fitness-obsessed kitty sometimes but at the end of the day, i still love him and would miss him terribly if he left c’:
zucker; this one definitely took me by surprise a bit. in new leaf, zucker was one of those villagers that i didn’t really care about; i never hated him but he definitely wasn’t one of my favourites aha. so when i found him while island hopping, i invited him because i knew he was pretty sought after and since the game was still fairly new, i wanted to make some bank aha. well again, my plan backfired when i grew attached to him, too; i’m not too sure what changed my mind about him but he’s honestly the sweetest lil man. i know all of the lazies are the same for the most part but zucker just radiates innocence and kindness and he’s just,, the best
beau; to say that i’m obsessed with beau would be an understatement. he was my absolute favourite in new leaf and the one villager that i couldn’t be without; granted, i have several favourite villagers but for the longest time, beau was my #1. when i was planning out my villagers before nh’s release, he was who i had picked to have as my permanent lazy but when i ran into zucker and grew attached to him, i thought he had taken over as my #1 and so i just figured that i wouldn’t be needing beau, after all. ,,,,,, spoiler alert; i was wrong lmao. i ran into beau one night while island hopping and immediately my heart went “!!!!!!!”. i knew that i wouldn’t be leaving without him and that i wouldn’t be able to let him leave once i had him so,, tldr; beau is still my #1 even after all these years and i would die for him :’)
margie; like zucker, this gal’s a new favourite of mine, too. the normals have been my favourite for ages now but margie was never really one that i cared about. however, when i saw her in gameplay footage during nh’s nintendo direct (?), i was blown away by how gorgeous she is and was ashamed that i hadn’t paid attention to her sooner. i’m not sure what it is about her but she’s so, so pretty and i can’t imagine not having her on my island now that i’ve grown to know and love her!
skye; i’m a lil sentimental about this baby. skye was my first camper back in new leaf and i immediately loved her; she’s honestly so gorgeous and it’s impossible to not adore her. however, like with beau, i thought that my love for her had lessened over the years and so i considered not having her for a bit. this post is basically me admitting to all of the times that i was wrong lmao and i was absolutely overjoyed when i ran into her during one of my island hopping sessions. now that i’ve had her for quite a while now, i feel silly for having ever considered not having her and if anything, i love her more now than i did in new leaf c’:
audie; this one still blows me away a bit lmao. i adored audie from the moment that i saw the first photo of her that circulated the internet for a bit prior to release; before, my eyes had been on sherb but that one screenshot was enough for my brain to go “
” for audie lmao. for the first few months, she was the one dreamie of mine that i was desperate for and to stick to the vow that i had made to myself, i refused to let myself buy or trade for her. so one morning, i booted up the game at like,, 6am and i was in a bit of a bad mood as i had accidentally deleted some work that i had done for school. i booted up the game and isabelle told me that i had a camper and my brain, as it always did, went “lol what if it’s audie?” ,,,, well, it was lmao. i stared at her in silence for like,, 10 minutes because i was so shocked to see her lmao. months later, i still adore her with all my heart and i’m still so grateful to the rng gods for putting her in my campsite, as it easily could’ve been any other peppy, but i’m so, so glad that it was her :’)
at the moment, all of my dreamies are ones that i intend on keeping permanently but these are just the ones that i’ve obtained so far! ;~;
zucker; this one definitely took me by surprise a bit. in new leaf, zucker was one of those villagers that i didn’t really care about; i never hated him but he definitely wasn’t one of my favourites aha. so when i found him while island hopping, i invited him because i knew he was pretty sought after and since the game was still fairly new, i wanted to make some bank aha. well again, my plan backfired when i grew attached to him, too; i’m not too sure what changed my mind about him but he’s honestly the sweetest lil man. i know all of the lazies are the same for the most part but zucker just radiates innocence and kindness and he’s just,, the best
beau; to say that i’m obsessed with beau would be an understatement. he was my absolute favourite in new leaf and the one villager that i couldn’t be without; granted, i have several favourite villagers but for the longest time, beau was my #1. when i was planning out my villagers before nh’s release, he was who i had picked to have as my permanent lazy but when i ran into zucker and grew attached to him, i thought he had taken over as my #1 and so i just figured that i wouldn’t be needing beau, after all. ,,,,,, spoiler alert; i was wrong lmao. i ran into beau one night while island hopping and immediately my heart went “!!!!!!!”. i knew that i wouldn’t be leaving without him and that i wouldn’t be able to let him leave once i had him so,, tldr; beau is still my #1 even after all these years and i would die for him :’)
margie; like zucker, this gal’s a new favourite of mine, too. the normals have been my favourite for ages now but margie was never really one that i cared about. however, when i saw her in gameplay footage during nh’s nintendo direct (?), i was blown away by how gorgeous she is and was ashamed that i hadn’t paid attention to her sooner. i’m not sure what it is about her but she’s so, so pretty and i can’t imagine not having her on my island now that i’ve grown to know and love her!
skye; i’m a lil sentimental about this baby. skye was my first camper back in new leaf and i immediately loved her; she’s honestly so gorgeous and it’s impossible to not adore her. however, like with beau, i thought that my love for her had lessened over the years and so i considered not having her for a bit. this post is basically me admitting to all of the times that i was wrong lmao and i was absolutely overjoyed when i ran into her during one of my island hopping sessions. now that i’ve had her for quite a while now, i feel silly for having ever considered not having her and if anything, i love her more now than i did in new leaf c’:
audie; this one still blows me away a bit lmao. i adored audie from the moment that i saw the first photo of her that circulated the internet for a bit prior to release; before, my eyes had been on sherb but that one screenshot was enough for my brain to go “
” for audie lmao. for the first few months, she was the one dreamie of mine that i was desperate for and to stick to the vow that i had made to myself, i refused to let myself buy or trade for her. so one morning, i booted up the game at like,, 6am and i was in a bit of a bad mood as i had accidentally deleted some work that i had done for school. i booted up the game and isabelle told me that i had a camper and my brain, as it always did, went “lol what if it’s audie?” ,,,, well, it was lmao. i stared at her in silence for like,, 10 minutes because i was so shocked to see her lmao. months later, i still adore her with all my heart and i’m still so grateful to the rng gods for putting her in my campsite, as it easily could’ve been any other peppy, but i’m so, so glad that it was her :’)at the moment, all of my dreamies are ones that i intend on keeping permanently but these are just the ones that i’ve obtained so far! ;~;
I could never get rid of Ike, Tank, Judy, or Beardo. The rest I do really really like but could see myself possibly letting go if I got the urge to see some new neighbours.
aaaa I have LOVED Peewee since Wild World, he’s still in my top 3
Post automatically merged:
aaaa I have LOVED Peewee since Wild World, he’s still in my top 3
KittenNoir
🖤 Meow 🖤
I will never kick out Muffy I wanted her so bad in New Leaf and never got the chance to get her 
But I was able to get her on here from a lovely user I also was able to get the cute Pietro from an other lovely user too. I do not know if I will ever kick out Buck as I tend to keep one day 1 villager
But I was able to get her on here from a lovely user I also was able to get the cute Pietro from an other lovely user too. I do not know if I will ever kick out Buck as I tend to keep one day 1 villager
That’s hard! I really like all my villagers and it has taken me up until now to find my dreamies in mistery islands. I don’t TT so it takes a long time. Anyway, I’d say I’d be willing to let go just a couple of them. I have Raymond, he was my first campsite villager, and I really like him, but at the same time I’d like to go on and look for Marshall, because I love the squirrels. Still, I couldn’t find the guts to let him go. Also, Molly. Took me forever to get her on island tour. I had her since April and I love her so much, she is so cute but I’d like to get a new normal(I have 3 already so I can’t get four, it would be too much 
). I’m sure I won’t let go Lolly, Poppy, Whitney, Chief and Bam for any reasons. I had Chrissy moving out a week ago, after 6 months of having her on my island and I have found Bunnie as a replacement and I think she is here to stay for a long time. I’d be happy to kick out cherry cause I hate the uchis and their design(I like realistic villagers mostly) and when that will happen I think I’ll go on and look for Julia.
). I’m sure I won’t let go Lolly, Poppy, Whitney, Chief and Bam for any reasons. I had Chrissy moving out a week ago, after 6 months of having her on my island and I have found Bunnie as a replacement and I think she is here to stay for a long time. I’d be happy to kick out cherry cause I hate the uchis and their design(I like realistic villagers mostly) and when that will happen I think I’ll go on and look for Julia.
banjokaboom
Resident Rep of Bear Isle
Um...
Let's see...
On my island I have Fang, Murphy, Chief, Lucky, Bluebear, Eloise, Ursala, Cole, Winnie, and Roald.
Of them, I will never kick out... Fang, Murphy, Chief, Lucky, Bluebear, Eloise, Ursala, Cole, Winnie, or Roald.
If I had to pick one, it would be Winnie, but she's my wife's favorite so she will never leave.
Let's see...
On my island I have Fang, Murphy, Chief, Lucky, Bluebear, Eloise, Ursala, Cole, Winnie, and Roald.
Of them, I will never kick out... Fang, Murphy, Chief, Lucky, Bluebear, Eloise, Ursala, Cole, Winnie, or Roald.
If I had to pick one, it would be Winnie, but she's my wife's favorite so she will never leave.
I don't think there are any! At least none of my current villagers.
I have: Audie, June, Plucky, Leopold (leaving tomorrow), Savannah, Norma, Ellie, Lopez, Claude and Portia.
Plucky and Audie have been with me since the beginning. Audie used to be my favourite but honestly I'm ready for her to leave the island and for a new peppy to come in. I like rotating villagers in and out and I think I'll get bored if I ever have the same villagers for a loooong time.
Portia is my current favourite (and apart from Lopez the newest arrival). I don't really care for any of the normals and it's honestly time for some of them to leave, lol! That being said, I can never ignore one of the villagers. I like getting to know them all and working on my relationships with them. I have some dreamies, like Erik and Coco, but I don't know if I'll ever get them and once I do, I don't know if I'll still want to keep them forever! It's just not really my playstyle.
I have: Audie, June, Plucky, Leopold (leaving tomorrow), Savannah, Norma, Ellie, Lopez, Claude and Portia.
Plucky and Audie have been with me since the beginning. Audie used to be my favourite but honestly I'm ready for her to leave the island and for a new peppy to come in. I like rotating villagers in and out and I think I'll get bored if I ever have the same villagers for a loooong time.
Portia is my current favourite (and apart from Lopez the newest arrival). I don't really care for any of the normals and it's honestly time for some of them to leave, lol! That being said, I can never ignore one of the villagers. I like getting to know them all and working on my relationships with them. I have some dreamies, like Erik and Coco, but I don't know if I'll ever get them and once I do, I don't know if I'll still want to keep them forever! It's just not really my playstyle.
Similar threads
