For Hyrule that would have to be Fauna, Sally and Kid Cat. I don't care how much they ask to leave.
They.are.not.going.to.leave.my.side.under.any.cirumstances.
Tee-Hee
Currently all my villagers are staying as I only just achieved my goal. But eventually I'll let some go, I'm thinking having a year of deer.
Staying forever: Zell, Bruce, Fauna, Diana. <3 ~ the same 4 I had in my previous town too.
Eventually can leave: Fuchsia, Lopez, Bam,
Might give up only after the above 3 have left and if I have someone I want more: Erik, Beau and Deirdre.
Right now my villagers are:
Sydney
Olivia
Stitches
Colton
Ed
Gwen
Bangle
Sly
Agnes
Camofrog
I never ever want to lose Stitches again ;___; and I'm obviously planning to keep the rest of my dreamies for as long as I can. The only one I would ever really consider giving up is Sydney because there are so many normal villagers I'd like to have, but I find the personality to be a bit too bland to ever want more than one. I'm not anywhere close to ready to give her up, but she's one that I eventually will let go.
Never Ever Leaving...Bones, Cookie, Daisy, Goldie, Shep
Will Sacrifice for other Dreamies... Stitches
On the Fence...Diana, Pashmina
Please Leave...Rizzo
In my first town, Zingzang, I'm never letting Rolf and Phoebe go. In my second town, Leafyway, I'm never letting Rolf and Phoebe go. (I know, I know, what the heck is wrong with me!? )
he will never leave and if he does i will hunt him down and force him back into my town and if he doesn't budge i will slap him with a sea bass i am being utterly serious
(I just added my own post in the Favorite Villager thread so it feels like I'm repeating myself, but....) Vesta, Roscoe, Julian and Pietro. If I had my way, Frita and Pippy wouldn't have been allowed to leave my town as well.
As for my other villagers? I'm still secretly hoping that Carmen would finally move out. I haven't warmed to the others yet, as I've only had most of them for less than a week. Stitches... I might be willing to let Stitches go. I love that dude, but I haven't been as attached to him as I am with my favorite villagers. If he asks, maybe I'll let him leave. I guess.