Unsettling villagers

[Serabee]

I'm pretty sure his photo is him "on display" as such. Just being a statue.

That does make sense... but, then, he still has a furry texture? IDK, it's just weird

 

[Barney]

I came across Clay on a mystery island and nearly jumped out of my chair when he turned around to say hi. Terrifying.

Also, Zucker. He's truly gross with his cooked head, sauce hair and herby cheeks. Urgh.

 

[Peach_Jam]

Limberg and Barold come to mind

 

[Uffe]

Rodeo, Hopper, and Ruby because of their red eyes.

 

[Nunnafinga]

I know a lot of people hate the gorillas but they don't bother me.Rocket,though...like Hank Hill would say,"The girl just ain't right."I like her pink jumpsuit but that pointy helmet/cowl thing just throws everything off.It reminds me of those ugly helmets worn by the Gondorians in Lord of the Rings.I know she's supposed to be a "superhero" but couldn't she just wear an eye mask and have a normal gorilla head?Geez,I wouldn't even mind if she had a pink Mohawk,it would still be better than being a bullet head.

 

[Lotusblossom]

The angry mom kangas... the cemetary house dog... the old guy characters who hit on you.. the ape with his but out... someone said i think beardo.. marcels white face does get to me sometimes... all the octopuses i dont like their mouths... and luna and tom nook

 

[Dunquixote]

Jambette because of those lips.
Pietro because I don’t like clowns.
Keaton - his eyes; never liked him in NL and had issues getting him to move. He also said something jokingly about want to move in with me >.>
Naomi - those eyes and lips really bother me (also don’t like cow villagers in general).
Rocket and violet - it’s mostly due to me not liking their design.


There are some that kinda give me a “scary” or weird vibe, but that I think suits them and actually like it such as Roscoe when he gets mad and the whites of his eyes turn yellow (or just his normal look; the red eyes are kinda scary lol). I love Roscoe because of this strangely.

Coco gives off a pretty creepy vibe but I think it suits her and honestly think it makes her unique along with her appearance.

 

[FRANS_PLAYER]

OMG I just saw his photo. I love it Clay joins KK Slider in the ranks of naked AC characters.

My unsettling villager pick would be Beardo, especially Beardo in a crop top. Actually I think crop tops in general make any villager look unsettling.

Beardo used to be on my island before I kicked him out. Putting hair THERE wasn't their best design choice

 

[Hypno KK]

I actually thought people really liked Clay! I'm surprised that's not the case. I've been meaning to get him on my NL town and keep him there but now I just might get him on NH too.

My unsettling villager pick would be Beardo, especially Beardo in a crop top. Actually I think crop tops in general make any villager look unsettling.

Thanks I'll never sleep again

 

[Millysaurusrexjr]

Hopkins is a weirdo. At first glance you might think he could be a cute addition to your island, but as soon as he turns around...

 

[Bluebellie]

Dotty. Her eyes turn red. I don’t know if they still do in new horizon but they did in new leaf. Her regular eyes are black.



Edit: aww I’m seeing so many people don’t like Barold. He is so cute

 

[Orieii]

Barold. He looks like a pedophile.

Finally. Someone who understands

 

[Corrie]

Coco is creepy.
Same goes with Stitches. He's not as bad as Coco but he's just...eh. Something's weird.

 

[sudo]

Is no on gonna mention Tiffany? She sticks out to me as being incredibly sexualized from her lace stockings, maid uniform and heavy makeup. She really creeps me out whenever I see her.

 

[Enxssi]

Jitters looks like he’s on the run from a murderer, 0/10 would not recommend.

 

[Xara]

chow in population growing was legitimately terrifying and he still gives me the creeps lmaoo

edit: bro why is the image so large i’m literally sobbing

 

[Fraggle]

Pietro and it gets worse when you go in his house which is the stuff of nightmares with added “clown murderer” music.

Also Muffy, I find her staring eyes really unsettling!

 

[rawstberry]

bud. he looks suspicious. also barold, limberg and moose give me creeps.

chow looks straight up unsettling, especially in older games.

and while coco definitely creeps me out in a way i actually don't mind her at all? i even started to like her, she's cute in a way that other villagers i mentioned aren't.

 

[courtxh]

Probably a strange / uncommon choice, but I would say Peaches. She moved onto my island randomly in the beginning, and everytime I ran into her I just wanted to run away.

 

[Manon_Despoina]

Probably a strange / uncommon choice, but I would say Peaches. She moved onto my island randomly in the beginning, and everytime I ran into her I just wanted to run away.

Haha, I wanted to say Peaches as well! It's her eyes.. same goes for Stitches. I am also created out by Poetry, Coco (though I really like her backstory) and Sherb (uncanny valley to me).