Unsettling villagers

[N a t]

I don't like any of the villagers with facial hair really, except for the goats that have their little goat beards but those are not the same to me. I really dislike how Prince has like a shadow or a beard or something, I don't like Barold, and I don't like Beardo, or Gaston... I just don't find it appealing at all. Sorry if ya'll likem but they weird me out.

 

[Mu~]

Villagers with lipstick. Mira, Tia and Muffy would be flawless designs if they didn't have it T.T
Also like someone else mentioned before, villagers with facial hair.
Villagers with closed eyes like Tipper or Julian (who otherwise would be top designs too)
Pietro, coco, Chester, chow.
Villagers with helmets.
Villagers with wigs like Naomi or the snooty ducks.

 

[Bunnii]

Anyone with those "cute" anime eyes like Cookie, Judy and Chevre.

I have Chevre on my island right now and I thought I would really like her which is why I took her because her color scheme matches but every time I look at her eyes, omg

 

[Sweetley]

Gonna say Gretel here. I just met her the other day while doing island hopping and almost invited her to my island, as she looks adorable on the first look. However, there's something off about her that I kinda dislike. Probably the fact that the eyebrows almost have the same shape as her eyes which makes it look like as if she has 4 eyes the longer you look into her face...

 

[Hobowire]

Clyde... He looks like he's going to vomit and a bit diseased. I keep getting him on nook mile islands.

 

[Lothitine]

Jitters, Rodeo, and hopper look like they were sent from hell to make me stone for my sins.
They give me the chills 3:<

 

[Watchingthetreetops]

I don't like the way the tigers or adult bears look. I can't put my finger on it, they just weird me out

 

[MyLifeIsCake]

Peck. People can call Lucky a zombie all they want, but Peck to me is creepier because he lacks pupils and he's supposed to be a normal bird?

 

[Mu~]

I don't like the way the tigers or adult bears look. I can't put my finger on it, they just weird me out

Most of them aren't even tigers, they have spots instead of stripes

 

[Watchingthetreetops]

Most of them aren't even tigers, they have spots instead of stripes

There's one that's a lion that I like. that's about it

 

[Snek]

I may get a lot of hate for this but Judy and Dom creep me out. If a villager is too cute it disturbs me to no end. They go with other "creepy cute" villagers that sort are sort of unsettling for me...like Apple...oh those eyes...

 

[Kurb]

Literally only the clown villager.
Can’t remember his name right now.
Pietro?
I mean, nobody likes clowns. Like they’re already creepy enough, why add it to a kid’s game of all things? like if i was five and saw pietro i’d be kinda creeped out

 

[sleepydreepy]

the gorillas are threatening...they seem dangerous

 

[Mikaiah]

most of the gorillas...
their proportions are just... weird... to me

 

[loveclove]

This might be weird... But I used to find Papi the lazy horse really sweet and I like his design, so I got his amiibo. When he arrived I got really bothered by Hypno KK playing in his house that is all cute wooden block furniture, it's like he wants to attract you, feels like a kid room from horror movie turns out I'm considering letting him go

 

[MossBoss]

Graham gives me bad incel/stalker vibes. Made worse by his seeming obsession with Francine (they were both on my island until recently). Also made worse when I decided to give him a fedora and change his catchphrase to "milady".

 

[paleogamer11]

Here are some of mine:
Naomi, Truffles, Chow, Jitters, Sparro, Freckles, Velma, and Cashmere. Several of these are based around their eyes, Sparro looks like he has a goatee, Velma with a beard makes me uncomfortable, Truffles has a strange looking face, and Chow creeps me out, the little black dot, the shape of his mouth, and his picture quotes.

 

[saucySheep]

I have both Coco and Tammi.

Coco ... i got her bc it's funny to see her reactions which are basically nothing. and one time she sang lucky kk and it was adorable.
Tammi bc she is my favorite peppy, and the eyes, which many people find to be "unsettling" are actually adorbs and i love dem :0

 

[Nefarious]

Jitters looks like he had 10 cups of coffee and he’s about ready to snap. He looks so unhinge, though, I kind of like him for it...

 

[marea]

A number of them, Cole for example.