Tia or Skye? Who to keep?

[Koala92]

I’m having such a hard time deciding, and I’ve seen other people ask for similar advice. Skye is one of my original five villagers, so I’m pretty attached to her, but Tia was a dreamie I wish I could keep them both, but I can’t have three normals on my island. Kicking Aurora is not an option lol

 

[xSuperMario64x]

Skye is amazing, def keep her <3


Ngl I wouldn't mind having her in my town at some point...

 

[Dormire]

Tia just because OG villagers have awful interiors. If you do want Skye, you might need to get her as a new villager to get her actual interior. (Unless she was the mandatory campsite villager). Besides, Tia is your dreamie.

 

[Altarium]

Skye is amazing, she's my favorite normal <3 I have her in the default interior too but the light blue wallpaper actually kind of fits her, I've been gifting her wooden furniture in white (the table and the bed with blue sheets, just like her actual house) and furniture of the cute set in light blue and her house is starting to look decent!

 

[brockbrock]

Tia is my favorite villager of all time, so I'm not biased or anything. Pick Tia.

 

[moon_child]

I like the wolves so Skye for me but that’s my bias talking. I personally am not fond of big villagers. I like em small and cute except for cats and wolves.

 

[Shinjukuwu]

Both are so adorable!! I do prefer Skye, but in this case I'd let Skye go, as her house isn't her original, and hopefully you can get her again. Tia is one of your dreamies so would be a shame to let her go when she will have her original house!

 

[bam94-]

I voted Skye, although if she was one of your first 5, her interior will be the default boring one. So now I'm thinking I should've voted Tia!

Edit: Just saw that I could change my vote.

 

[BalloonFight]

Hard choice but I'd vote Tia. Mainly due to Skye having the starter house. Plus you mentioned that Tia was an actual dreamie of yours.

 

[Bugs]

I never realised Skye was so popular, I've ended up with her amiibo card for some reason.

Personally I prefer Tia cause she's an adorable teapot

 

[Mairmalade]

Do you have a certain theme going for your island where house exterior would matter? That may help with your decision.

I'm a bit biased because wolves are my favorite species in Animal Crossing, but I've no doubts that Skye would be a great friend to you!

 

[Xara]

they’re both adorable but i vote to keep skye - i might be biased, though, since she’s one of my favourites lol