Alright, so we're looking at 5 mafia, 2-4 mermaids (there at least has to be two in my read on the situation, having been a similar role in a past game), and a usual town mixed with green and blue. But apparently, people have treasure. I know it wouldn't be smart to out your treasure but I don't have any and didn't even realize that something like that was in this game, so I'm just curious as to whether or not other people have some. Of course, it'd make sense on their part not to let me know. Either way, I believe that we've got a treasure hoarding side-game going on in this game.
A few reads. I want to do everybody by night but I'll get to the first few alphabetically.
Alice
>People who only post to give facts (cough Alice cough)
Freaking this. I get a bad vibe from Alice for this reason, because she avoided being too subjective when we were scum together in Portal (other than her jumping on the town putting town up for lynches bandwagons, if that makes sense). Instead she would sort of clarify what's going on and remain objective. I'm not going to say that her playstyle this game is exactly the same as it was in Portal, far from it, but there's something about the content of her posts so far that makes me want to keep an eye on her.
Alise
As Oath pointed out, Alise just gave a simple one liner apparently because they saw that I made a huge post and a huge post means that everyone is going to lynch Oath apparently. She was just like 'wow good post, gg oath'.
Ashtot
I'm not exactly super suspicious of him right now because he was one of the few people to pass my reaction test with flying colors, actually reading into it unlike other people. I think Yui has some really weak reasons for suspecting him and half of it just has to do with Ashtot having a big ego.
Cariad
I haven't seen too much effort from her in previous games so I don't expect much from her this game. I know part of it has to do with timezone, but other people who live across the world from me put effort into the game (Minties for example). Jellofish is on the same boat as Cariad here. For now I don't get any big scum reads from either of them, because Jellofish usually says even less when they are scum, but that's also weak reasoning on my part. I'll keep an eye on them but even if they could be mafia, I don't think they're the most dangerous one alive at the moment and if they are it will become a little more apparent later on like it does with Jellofish.
Cory
I'm voting for Superpenguin because he has been acting strangely this game.
Oh snap daddy is showing who rules the house.
Cory clearly didn't even read my post when he made that one in reaction to my case against Oath. He might as well have posted a popcorn gif and left it at that. He's not putting much effort into the game and his jumping on the SP bandwagon is just makes me feel a little more confident about that thought. He's being lazy. At the same time, I still think he's coming back from sort of being shunned by the tbt mafia community and might not be like he used to be because of that, but for now I don't get any scum reads.
C R Y S T A L
Just can't get a great read yet. Kind of aggressive towards the beginning of day one and like others have pointed out, going after easier lynch targets. Despite that, I'm not sure about them being town or mafia yet. Aside from IRC there aren't many past games to go off when it comes to Crystal having been scum.
Dolby
Not a huge read on him like always. He was reading into the situation between Oath and Sataric and actually made a post with a minimal amount of effort, but he's flying under the radar like always. He's acted this way as town before, so if anything I'll read into some of his past games later on if he's ever been mafia in one of them.
Karen
Seems town to me at the moment because they're just trying to figure out the game and are clearly reading what's going on unlike other members of town. Also a voice of reason tbh.
Karla
I was thinking that he could be scum earlier in the game, but those vibes are sort of going away with their increased activity today, which finally brings a much needed voice of reason to this town that...tbh needs it. I want to believe both you and Ryan in this case, but I also wonder why you wouldn't get a notification about being roleblocked. You criticize me for seeing it as only one way, but tbh the roleblock situation is either one thing or the other: ryan telling the truth or ryan lying. If he's lying, I honestly think that he
is being directed by a scum-mate in quicktopic, because Ryan trying to pull a complicated lie just isn't him at all. However, I found it funny that you responded with
Good post dad, nothing to add to that.
I still don't buy that. There's plenty to pick apart in my post because there are a couple of hypocritical points on my part, although my reads on Oath's behavior still have merit, I'd argue. And you just seem like the kind of person who would actually attempt to.
I'll make more soon but I'm tired. To put it short while there's still time, the people who are highest up on my suspect list are alise, Alice, and Oath.
