Omg ikr? XD I remember when Axel told me that he was thinking about moving, and I was like "wow yes yes
yes just move away from this town I won't miss you", and BAM it hit me. When I told Axel to move, he actually said that he was going to stay instead of moving because he wanted to "become better friends with me" and all that nonsense...so yeah, he's still in my town as far as I know (since it's been some days I played ACNL).
But here's what I usually do to make villagers move out: (and the letter one works out pretty awesome for me, it got some villagers that I didn't want in my town to move pretty fast I would say)
1. Whack them with any tools that you possibly can with
2. Start pushing them around town
3. Bury pitfall seeds (I love doing traps around them with pitfalls hehe) and push them to the cracks so they'll fall
4. Start to talk to them, but when they say "What's up? You wanna talk to me?" and stuff like that just say no repeatedly
5. Send them a hateful letter about how you hate them and how you want them to get out of your town asap, and give them rotten fruit along with it
6. When they ask for fruit, give them a rotten one
And...that's pretty much the list of what usually I do to unwanted villagers XD

. I don't really do all of the things listed to an unwanted villager though, just some. Hope you get Peggy out soon!
