Peppy Villager Tier List

[Watchingthetreetops]

do you have a masterpost for all the made tiers for different types of villagers? I'd like to do a little thing in my own journal thread and I'm having issues making the teir thing myself lol

 

[hakutaku]

S tier is for absolute icons only.

 

[Fye]

This one was a bit harder since I'm not really into peppy villagers but at the same time their designs are really cute! Most of the bunnies made it to S and A, and of course our brand new peppy wolf made it too! I've never had Flora but I've seen her on a few islands and she's so cute and suits the island theme really well. I love the designs of the ostriches in general and wish I had room for some on my island!

 

[Kristenn]

I needed to show some love for my queen Nibbles

 

[Pandemonium]

Peppies are probably my least favorite personality type.

 

[Seelie]

Ruby and Cookie are just so absolutely precious -- Cookie has those big eyes, and I'm super into Ruby's moon rabbit backstory! I have a feeling that Tangy, Ketchup, and Dotty could make S tier if I had them around my island for a bit, too.

 

[Skandranon]

 

[MadisonBristol]

Disappointed everybody is ranking my girl Anabelle so low.

 

[DaisyFan]

There are some of my faves, but Carmen is and will always be my #1 favorite peppy villager, hands down.

 

[Xara]

tangy was literally the first villager that i met and i had the nerve to put her in B tier-

Spoiler: may 2020 list

 

[Dunquixote]

View attachment 280242

Puddles was one of my favorites in NL but I had to bump her down a tier since she seemed a bit different from how I remembered her as in NL.

Here is my updated list:

There is significantly a lot less in the D tier for once lol. The two anteaters, horses and Piper and Ketchup are big iffys there. I really like the anteater’s colors and the concept behind Ketchup is nice. Piper looks much better when I visited her on my friend‘s island. The two horses I’m neutral about; they’re not the best or worst of the horses (in my opinion).

I knew I liked the rabbits and squirrels but I never really saw how many of them that I liked lol. Sprinkles and Bluebear would’ve been higher but I didn’t click with them when I had both of them plus Merry. I do love their designs though.

 

[heaven.]

Peppy villager are so fun and cute. I don't have anything against any of them, except for Victoria.

 

[Wolfieocelot]

I LOVE peppy villagers, but one of them ( truffles) are just....ugh

 

[deana]

I quite like peppy villagers so I rated a lot of them pretty highly. I had also considered banishing Truffles to an even lower tier but I was too lazy to add one

 

[R00T]

I'm not crazy into the peppy villagers. My girl Tabby is one of my original 3 move ins, she's unexpectedly grown on me and I can't see myself ever getting rid of her. I had Rosie, Ruby, and Ketchup in New Leaf, I like them but I want to have different villagers in this game

 

[ripley4O77]

Not sure about that C category, I felt... merciful.

 

[visibleghost]

I have had all S tier villagers at some point and therefore have a special bond to them, on top of them being cute. I love tangy so much and Wendy is adorable. I currently have Bonbon and am not looking to get rid of her any time soon. Puddles is the only peppy frog so of course I have had her, I like her a lot too.
A tier are ones I would accept having, I have had Rosie, Pomon, Dotty and Peanut on that list if I remember correctly.
B tier are cute but not my exact cup of tea.
C are ones I would want to get off my island if I had them.
D are the ones I would be desperate to get off my island the minute they set foot on it. Sorry, Truffles, you had to go...