Overrated and Underrated villagers

[Lethalia]

Overrated: Diana, Julian, Stitches, Pietro, Merengue, Rosie

Underrated: My precious baby Celia, a beautiful white & lime green eagle with a sprinkle of lavender. She has a heart of gold and the cutest face. If you've never met her, you haven't lived life to the fullest yet.

 

[Trip]

Overrated: Marshal, Julian, Lolly, and Stitches.

Underrated: Kabuki

 

[Xara]

overrated: basically everyone on the tier 1 list..they're cute and all, but c'mon

underrated: kiki, goldie

 

[AccfSally]

Overrated: Marshal, Diana, Merengue, Beau, Whitney, Poppy, Most of the wolves, Stitches and Marina; They're cute, but not that cute or better than others.

Underrated: My baby Sally, Hazel, Chadder, O'Hare, Ken, Sheldon, Ricky, Cally, Caroline and etc..

 

[Altarium]

Overrated: LOLLY, Rosie, Chrissy, Francine, Merengue

Underrated: Poppy, Ozzie, Poncho, Tucker, Hamlet, Bonbon, Celia, Bianca, Flora, Octavian...

 

[Espionage]

Overrated: Bill
Underrated: Chester

 

[Lethalia]

Overrated: LOLLY, Rosie, Chrissy, Francine, Merengue

Underrated: Poppy, Ozzie, Poncho, Tucker, Hamlet, Bonbon, Celia, Bianca, Flora, Octavian...

CELIA. YES. CELIA. CELIA.

 

[SilkSpectre]

Underrated: Tiffany
Overrated: Lolly

 

[AccfSally]

Overrated: LOLLY, Rosie, Chrissy, Francine, Merengue

Underrated: Poppy, Ozzie, Poncho, Tucker, Hamlet, Bonbon, Celia, Bianca, Flora, Octavian...

Poppy isn't underrated.. she's more well loved than the other normal squirrels.
I have a love/hate relationship with her now because of her fans.

 

[Altarium]

Poppy isn't underrated.. she's more well loved than the other normal squirrels.
I have a love/hate relationship with her now because of her fans.

I mean she's certainly cuter than half the normals in tier 1 and 2, and she's stuck in 3.

 

[AccfSally]

I mean she's certainly cuter than half the normals in tier 1 and 2, and she's stuck in 3.

She's underrated because she dropped a tier..no offense but are you kidding me..

 

[mermaidvivian]

Overrated: Marshal, maybe? He's very cute, but something about him irritates me a bit. I just got Marina, and she's super sweet and nice, but I just don't LOVE her (Fauna took me a while to warm up to though, so the same might happen with her).

Underrated: Agent S (I love her little outfit), Mira, Merry (such a cute design and very fun), Deirdre (super cute house and a nice personality), Benjamin (a big-browed puppy :') PLUS his house is adorable)

 

[Altarium]

She's underrated because she dropped a tier..no offense but are you kidding me..

What I'm saying is she has potential to be more popular than Lolly and Fauna if people actually paid attention to her. That's why she's underrated...

 

[TheGreatBrain]

Over rated- Merangue, and all octopus.

Under rated- Vladimir, Pudge, Grizzly, Aurora, Hazel. etc, etc,etc.

 

[OrangeFilledVill]

Marshal is overrated. WAY too overrated.
Lucky is overrated.
Kody is underrated.
Truffles recieves thirty times more hate than the average hated villager.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Marshal is overrated. WAY too overrated.
Lucky is overrated.
Kody is underrated.
Truffles recieves thirty times more hate than the average hated villager.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Oops twice

 

[LadyRainb]

Chief is overrated
Jambette is underrated!!!

Rilla the gorilla is totally underrated. Most of the gorilla villagers are.
She is one of my favourite villagers!

 

[calamitybot]

pecan is so underrated!!!! she is adorable i love her so much... also her house looks really nice

 

[tiffanistarr]

Overrated: all the tier 1 and most of the tier 2 villagers that people go on and on about. When I first created my town I had Fauna who I guess is "tier 1", and I do adore her but there are so many other adorable normal villagers.

I wanted to see what all the hype was with the popular villagers so I scanned in Stitches, Tia, and had Freya move in and I don't get the hype.

In my second town it's a "Tier 1 Wasteland" Marshal, Maple, Blaire, and a few other really popular villagers and I get their appeal. They are freaking adorable but other than that? idk.

As far as underrated goes, my favorite Villager is Bones and I'm not sure how popular he is, but I think he's just so adorable. I've loved him since he was in my Gamecube town. Pietro, who I've never had but am currently trying to obtain is just amazing. Lobo doesn't get the credit he deserves. Shari should be queen of them all. There's tons of underrated villagers.

 

[Zane]

Gala and Boots are incredibly underrated in my humble onion. Chester too, although he has at least some popularity as far as I can recall. p: I've also become a big fan of Lily since I moved her to my town so I think she could get more love than she does!!

 

[supercataleena]

I feel Marshall is extremely overrated. Squirrels are not cute unless their name is Hazel, with her Frida Kahloesque like appeal.

A villager I feel is underrated is Mathilda..she has all the qualities I appreciate in a villager..
She is a mother, looks like Umbreon, and has purple! Amazing. Plus she takes all my amethyst customized modern furniture!!