Overrated and Underrated villagers

[Jessy_Azran]

There are a lot of popular villagers on this website. But I think some receive too much credit for nothing, like Julian the Unicorn. Sure, he's a unicorn. But he's UGLY! I mean, there could be a girl unicorn instead of HIM. But there are some that don't get a lot of attention that I really like. For example, I like Mint. But I barely hear ANYTHING about her on this website. Personally, I think she's cute.

Now, what's your opinion? What villagers do you think are to overrated, or you think need more praise?

I don't particularly like the smug and snooty personalities, but some are actually alright. I actually am not too fond of Julian either, but none of the characters I've seen so far is ugly. Pancetti isn't ugly, but she's rude and inappropriate clothing choices. I love all the animals that are green, it's my favourite colour, Mint is so CUTE!!!!!


I basically like every personality except smug and snooty, but the list of favourites do include some. I will also include my least favourites. If I forget any villager, or add to the list, I will post on my blog entry since I will lose a lot of TBT editing this post.


Here are my favourite villagers so far (alphabetically):

Admiral.
Ally.
Baabara.
Beau.
Biskit.
Carmen.
Canberra.
Coco.
Erik.
Fauna.
Flurry.
Frobert.
Joey.
Kiki.
Klaus.
Lily.
Lobo.
Maple.
Merengue.
Mint.
Monique.
Opal.
Simon.
Skye.
Tammi.
Tangy.
Winnie.
​

My least favourite so far (alphabetically):

Diana.
Julian.
Pancetti.
Ricky.
Velma.
​

 

[pmmm !]

overrated: julian. he used to be one of my favourite villagers, but now i don't really care for him.
underrated: benjamin! when he first moved in i wanted him to leave, but after talking to him so much, i really can't imagine my town without him!

 

[daisyflowers]

overrated: julian. he used to be one of my favourite villagers, but now i don't really care for him.
underrated: benjamin! when he first moved in i wanted him to leave, but after talking to him so much, i really can't imagine my town without him!

yess! i agree- i really want benjamin in my town, also i sort of think marshall is fairly overrated too.

 

[buny]

i don't believe in the term "overrated", everyone has their personal preferences, and it's all just opinions. But i think some villagers are a little overlooked probably cause a lot of people haven't noticed them, like Annalise, Chester, Gala, Fang, Molly, Cheri, etc

 

[heyimsobored]

For being overrated, marshal for sure. I don't get it. He looks like any other squirrel villager to me. As for underrated, I would say Axel. I had him in an old town of mine and I ended up really liking him

 

[moonbyu]

overrated: stitches!
yeah, i just never got the appeal of him. yeah, he's a teddy, but's that's about it.
underrated: renee!
i don't like many rhino villiagers, but after many failed attempts of trying to make her leave, i kinda started to like her.

 

[Ojo46]

Overrated: Never got the hype around Marshall. He's not bad, but I think there are better villagers out there.

Underrated: Two of my starting villagers: Broccolo and Cally! I love both of them so much and they're such sweeties! <3

 

[CJODell62]

Underrated villagers: Quite a lot actually, including a few from the first town I ever made. Avery, Bertha, Bree, Clyde, Coach, Elvis, Katt, Maelle, etc. The list goes on and on.

 

[Sweetley]

Overrated: Julian. He may be a unique character because he's the only "unicorn" villager the game
has to offer at this point, but overall I personally find him not that great. Not to mention that his
eyes are just pretty creepy.

Underrated: The superhero villagers (Kid Cat, Big Top, Agent S and Rocket). They are so unique
from they design and the idea behind them and yet they don't get the attention they deserve,
which is kinda shame.

 

[xhyloh]

Gala is SO underrated imo!! She's one of the cutest villagers in the game!

 

[Mutti]

Marshal is defiantly overrated, i remember back in 2013 fan groups were selling him for millions of bells! Crazy!

 

[Catharina]

Umm Yeah marshal is overrated but i think he is cute tho
underrated: caroline

 

[HistoryH22]

Overrated: Marshal. I understand the appeal, but he's not for me.
Underrated: Big Top and Samson. They are certainly not the most popular villagers, but Ive absolutely enjoyed having them in my town. Big Top's design is particularly cool.

 

[Lavamaize]

Underated: Willow, Teddy, June

Overrated: Goldie, Jay

 

[Fwogee]

overrated: Marshall, Julian, Bob
Marshall is very cute but i don't understand the hype, Julian is probably popular because he's the only unicorn, and Bob again is very cute but idk i've never been that into him

Underrated: Wart Jr. !!!! Gayle, Bangle, Rolf, Greta !

 

[Emolga59]

Katt is really overrated for my opinion and literally no one talks about Gloria.

 

[BluebearL]

No such thing as an overrated animal crossing villager! Underrated: hazel. She?s so cute I don?t understand why people can?t see past the unibrow

 

[AlyssaAC]

No such thing as an overrated animal crossing villager! Underrated: hazel. She’s so cute I don’t understand why people can’t see past the unibrow

Omg! I totally agree! There is definitely no such thing as an overrated villager and Hazel is one of my favorite villagers, so I too can't see why people don't like her because of her unibrow. I think it makes her really cool and she is very underrated.

 

[BluebearL]

Yes she’s one of my current favourites (though I have many because they are all awesome) never letting her go lol

 

[A_Pug]

Overrated-
Cookie. She kinda creeps me out.
Diana. She's got a nice design, but she was pretty mean when I had her in my town.

Underrated-
Naomi. She's really sweet, I remember being so touched when she gave me medicine for my bee stings for the first time.
Pippy. She's really cute and energetic.
Portia. She's very elegant.
Boomer. He's a pilot penguin who fulfilled his dream of flying.