Overrated and Underrated villagers

[SpookyMemes]

everyone in my town is underrated except for Julian, merengue, maybe chief and coco

I have Cole, Samson, Portia, filbert, Wendy, and Shari and I love them ALLL

 

[Lemonsky]

I'm not completely sure about villagers' popularity but I think Charlise is rather underrated. It's such a shame since she's one of my favorites.

 

[softbuck]

i never see anything about rhonda! i love her so much shes my bff. also flora, i love her she embodies a lot of my likes (pink.)

 

[John Wick]

Overrated: Marshal, Marina, Stitches and most of the others at the top of the 'opinion list'.

Underrated: All the kangaroo's and everyone else at the bottom of the 'opinion list'.

 

[Mink777]

I'll just do some ol' best, worst, underrated, overrated for some species that I like.

Dogs-

Best- Walker/Biskit
Worst- Mac
Overrated- Lucky
Underrated- Bones

Birds-

Best- Jitters
Worst- Midge
Overrated- Twiggy
Underrated- Peck

Bear Cubs-

Best- Kody
Worst- Barold
Overrated- Stitches
Underrated- Vladimir

Squirrels-

Best- Filbert
Worst- Viche
Overrated- Marshal
Underrated- Sally

 

[kiwi-strawberry]

I think Wendy is especially underrated. I mean, she has a watermelon scarf and a space+fruit themed house but somehow she's in the lowest tier??? I got her when I first started my village, and have since refused to allow her to move out because I just love her so much. Olivia and Pancetti also need more love! I think Rosie is SUPER overrated though, I mean, she isn't even that cute? Kiki is way cuter in my opinion.

 

[Khaelis]

A few of my villagers I feel are underrated. Like Punchy, Peck and Jacques for instant. I don't see many people searching for them, let alone people giving them out.

As for overrated, definitely Coco and Marshall.

 

[Calli-Ink]

Overrated: Coco.... she's so creepy! Also kabuki, he isn't really all that cool/cute.

Underrated: Norma, Bree, and sprinkle... they're so cute. (If the reason is a color thing I'm color blind lol XD)

 

[mountaintear]

I think Coco is amazing; she's one of my favorite villagers of all time.

There are a lot of underrated villagers, but personally from my town, I feel the most underrated villagers are Nan, Marcel and Rodeo. People hate on Marcel and Rodeo but I think they're both unique and super cute

 

[John Wick]

I think Coco is amazing; she's one of my favorite villagers of all time.

There are a lot of underrated villagers, but personally from my town, I feel the most underrated villagers are Nan, Marcel and Rodeo. People hate on Marcel and Rodeo but I think they're both unique and super cute

I LOVE Rodeo!
I had him in WW.

Excellent design, with awesome red eyes. ^_^

 

[honeyblossom]

We all know Rosie is pretty overrated, yet we all accept that and love her anyways. I feel like there are so many villagers who are underrated. Most of the cubs don't get the love they deserve in lieu of Stitches. Squirrels don't exist unless it's Marshal or Pecan, despite the fact that there's quite a few cuties on the list. Don't talk to me about Coco. I mean, don't get me wrong, I love all of these little buddies, except you Coco, but, I'm going for my dreamer badge and after seeing the same like, 10 villagers over and over gets kind of boring.

 

[Flare]

Overrated Villagers

Diana
Julian
Merengue
Fauna
Beau
Ruby


Underrated

Rod
Bree
Sprinkle
Walker
Jay
Jambette
Butch
Lily
Lopez
Willow
Tex

 

[Loriii]

Overrated: Ankha

Underrated: Margie

 

[Maria of Moonlake]

Overrated:

Marshal. Why is him that overrated? Like, hes such a cutie but i dont know why he is so popular. People say that its because of its CUDDLY tail, but it's just like the other squirrels...

Stitches. He is so cute too, but why he is popular? Just because he sounds like a plushie?

Bluebear, Julian, Francine, Chrissy and Rosie: Just W H Y.

Underrated: All my dreamies (except ?toile and Stitches)

 

[Beanz]

UNDERATED:

BOONE. I love him but I honestly understand why he is unpopular. He looks like any other regular gorilla villager and there’s nothing really special about him except for him being a mandrill gorilla, but I still believe Boone deserves better. HE NEEDS LOVE TOO GUYS.

Coco: She’s not really underrated, in fact, I believe that she deserves to be unpopular. I’ll just put her on the list anyway. I had Coco in my first town and when I first met her I was so scared that I never came back to her house again (I’m not exaggerating.) Her eyeballs and mouth were so creepy.

Alfonso: He’s pretty cute in my opinion so idk why he’s so unpopular.

OVERRATED:

Ankha

Stitches

Zucker

 

[nekotown]

There aren't really any villagers I find overrated, but there are definitely some I find underrated. (I'm definitely not saying these villagers don't get any love, but I find they aren't mentioned quite as much).

-Kabuki. He's very fun to talk to, and I find his personality more... realistic(?) than pretty much anyone else's in the game. He's like the grumpy friend who always makes an exception for you since you two are so close. Also, I find his design to be quite unique and cool.
-Peanut. She's a very fun and engaging character, not to mention her design is adorable! I think it matches her character well.
-Static. He's very honest and gives good advice. He is wise beyond his years. (Although squirrel years are probably different lol). He also stays up quite late so that's fun for a night owl like me.
-Tabby. CRIMINALLY underrated. So many people call her "ugly" and to me it's simply not true. She is a cute kitty with a heart of gold.

 

[Onyx]

Overrated: merengue .. I don't think she's that cute .-.
Underrated: Chief! He's one of my faves Drake & Molly combo would be adorable too I'm gonna try to move them in next to each other eventually <3

 

[Bizhiins]

Overrated: hazel, Julian
Underrated: Katt, because she?s the sweetest and most adorable uchi villager I?ve ever met
Lolly, because I didnt really want her at first but she turned out to be such a sweetheart I can?t let her go

 

[Reckoner]

Overrated: Probably Marshal or Diana.
I can't see their appeal.
Underrated: Moe, Puck, and Rod.

 

[SmoochsPLH]

Overrated: Rosie. I agree she's cute, but I don't get the huge hype over her cause she's very plain looking to me. I don't hate her whatsoever, she's just not my aesthetic I guess would be a good word. That may just be me though.

Underrated: It may just be cause she's one of my big favs (and I may be wrong on her popularity), but Rhonda is a super cute rhino! I love her purple on pure white and goth/witchy vibes.