Overrated and underrated villagers

[AidenTheGamer]

Honestly, I think Erik is overrated and Lyman is too underrated. What are some villagers all of you think are overrated and underrated?

 

[CR33P]

ANOTHER ONE OF THESE THREADS. PLEASE NO

 

[ethre]

I think Rosie is overrated. Seriously! Everyone wants her!!

Kitt is underrated.. she's a total sweetheart and is a dreamie of mine :3

 

[bigger34]

Over: Zucker
Under: Mitzi ;-;

 

[debinoresu]

overrated: jambette in the sense that shes so disliked shes overrated
underrated: marshal he needs to be liked even more screw tier one he must be tier infinite

 

[Leopardfire]

Overrated: Zucker, Beau, Marshal, Zell

Underrated: Gladys, Lobo, Willow, Peanut, Curlos

 

[monk]

overrated: horse and wolf villagers... sorry i just don't find them too cute or great looking
underrated: daisy or butch :x i can't believe how low they are on the tier list

 

[poliwag0]

cURLY IS SO UNDERRATED!!

 

[hanzy]

overrated: IMO Ankha is not that great ._. Also I've never really liked Marshal, his japanese name makes him seem cuter I think.
underrated: Portia and O'Hare! Come on, look at O'Hare's tiny little hat :3

 

[Esper]

wasnt there a thread just like this a few days ago??

 

[ripley4O77]

overrated: wolf villagers... sorry i just don't find them too cute or great looking

I agree with this part, most wolves are so boring looking and have nothing special about them except for maybe a colour palette swap.

As far as under rated go it depends what you mean, usually it means characters get more hate than they deserve (and not how well they are known like most people think) so the tier list doesn't matter in this regard. I think Rhonda and Jitters are generally disliked even though they're pretty awesome.

 

[Big Forum User]

Overrated: Marshal
Underrated: Ed

 

[MagicalCat590]

Francine is overrated, IMO. I have her in my town and I can't stand her. She reminds me of Hilly Holbrook from The Help.

 

[ethre]

edit: don't mind this post

 

[Coolio15]

Overrated: Erik, Muffy, Julian
Underrated: Soleil, Blanche, Egbert, and all of the tigers<3

 

[Hirisa]

Here's the summarized version of every one of these threads:

Underrated villagers: whoever I like.

Overrated villagers: whoever I don't like/whoever is popular.

 

[faerie]

Overrated: Marshal
Underrated:Bill

 

[Coolio15]

Here's the summarized version of every one of these threads:

Underrated villagers: whoever I like.

Overrated villagers: whoever I don't like/whoever is popular.

Basically. Honestly who cares if a villager is overrated or underrated! If you like them then that is aweosme for you, don't start hating or liking a villager just cause other people do too<3

 

[budewarmin]

I think those threats only create irritation, it's not nice to see others marking your dreamies as overrated. Just because I don't like strawberry cake I won't be starting threats talking about how overrated cheesecake is, it's ridiculous!

 

[Glaceon2000]

Overrated: Bam. (The only one I can think of at the moment, there's probably more.)
Underrated: Nibbles, Miranda.