Most overrated/ underrated villagers

[flowercrownfoxy]

Who do you think are the most overrated and underrated villagers?
My opinion:
Overrated-Lolly (i dont hate her or anything)
Underrated-Moe (how do you not love Moe?)

 

[Dae Min]

Marshall is extremely popular, but I can see why

And Beardo is underrated despite how many people love him on here xD

 

[pocky]

Gayle is extremely underrated. She is not a dreamy of mine or anything, but when I first saw her design I for sure thought she was going to be one of the most popular villagers in the community. Yet I hardly see her around and whenever I end up getting her in my cycling towns I ended up having to void her cause nobody ever wants her.

I don't get it. What's not to love about a pink, heart themed alligator?!

 

[flowercrownfoxy]

I like Marshal, but i agree!

- - - Post Merge - - -

I love Gayle!

 

[pocky]

I like Marshal as well People complain about him being 'bland' but I really don't think that there is anything bland about an albino squirrel. Seeing one of those in real life would be pretty amazing!

I don't know, I just really love the villagers that look like actual animals. Gimmicky villagers are just as cool though

 

[flowercrownfoxy]

I love his eyes! So Adorable

 

[Khaelis]

Kyle, Skye and Bangle. I do not know why they are not Tier 1. All of them are adorable.

Kyle and Skye are the only wolf villagers that are not Cranky or Snooty. That makes them super unique.

Sure, there's Dobie and Tarou, but Dobie was an Island villager in Animal Crossing Population Growing and Tarou was Japanese exclusive to Dōbutsu no Mori e+. I wish Tarou was in ACNL. He's PURPLE! ;~;

 

[tumut]

Overrated: Beau, Whitney- There are so many more interesting lazy villagers than Beau, he has a really bland design. I think Whitney is kind of ugly, I know they were going for a pretty white wolf, but they really didn't hit it.

Underrated: Cube, Agnes, Avery- Cube's x's for eyes are adorable, Agnes has an epic color scheme, and Avery is a really awesome grey desert eagle.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Kyle, Skye and Bangle. I do not know why they are not Tier 1. All of them are adorable.

Kyle and Skye are the only wolf villagers that are not Cranky or Snooty. That makes them super unique.

Sure, there's Dobie and Tarou, but Dobie was an Island villager in Animal Crossing Population Growing and Tarou was Japanese exclusive to Dōbutsu no Mori e+. I wish Tarou was in ACNL. He's PURPLE! ;~;

Well Skye was in tier one at one point.

 

[Fairytale]

I looked at the tier list and saw a few villagers in tier 1 who used to be in lower tiers. I am surprised.. Anyway:
I have a few: Zucker, okay I get why people might like him. He is an octopus, but the stick in his head is just weird? I have no idea how he made it to the top 3. Diana, I don't think she's kind, and she looks selfish. Nah. Beau, he is 'the best' according to the tier list. What? He's a lazy deer, I liked him at first but he is so boring after a week. Meh..

Filbert is so underrated. He is soooo adorable, he has cute eyes and pink blush cheeks! He is cuter than Marshal for sure! Most of my favorite villagers are tier 4. (Filbert, Peanut, Rod, Bluebear, Aurora, Pecan, Apple, Carmen) all of them are freakin' cute so yeah. Peanut is almost in tier 3 c:

 

[Fairytale]

oops, nvm! dubble post

 

[hemming1996]

Marshal is overrated but he's so cute you'd understand why. As for underrated Id say Ruby shes gotten more popular recently but I dont understand why she isn't more popular...

 

[mabadpe]

Merengue, everyone seems to want/have her! (I'm personally not much for the pink stuff) And Stiches, really surprised me cause I thought he was quite ugly

Walker, I thought for sure he was really popular cause he is so adorable, fell in love with him at first sight : D

 

[RainbowPanda]

Overrated: Molly. SHE'S A BROWN DUCK. To me she wouldn't look out of place in tier 4-5 ^v^'
Underrated: PINKY! She's one of my dreamies because I love Pandas- and she's a pink panda! What's she doing in tier 5? O_O

 

[peppy villager]

I had Beau in my town for a while and I can say I definitely think he is overrated. I formed no attachment to him whatsoever. Lol.

I think Flora is underrated! She is so dang cute and colorful!

 

[PlasmaPower]

Hey look, another overrated villager thread exists!

 

[amethystttt]

Peanut. She just creeps me out. Those beady eyes..... Way to overrated. I feel like all of the tigers are very underrated, especially Rowan.

 

[kikiiii]

shari is wayy too underrated. when i first got her in my town as a random move in i totally thought she would be some popular villager until i saw the tier list. she'll always be my favorite uchi!

 

[Astro Cake]

I think Beau is overrated, he's bland in my opinion.

 

[PlasmaPower]

Peanut. She just creeps me out. Those beady eyes..... Way to overrated. I feel like all of the tigers are very underrated, especially Rowan.

You're overrated.

I agree with the tigers being underrated to an extent.

 

[StrawberryCream]

I think Marshal's overrated. He's cute and all but he's quite bland. There are squirrels that are much better than him.
I definitely think Midge is underrated, she's one of the cutest normals.