MOLLY OR KETHUP

[Nunnafinga]

I say get both.I have these two and I couldn't choose between them.

 

[azurill]

I choose both. I have ketchup on my second island and will eventually have Molly as well. I like them both equally.

Secret 3rd option. Joey! jk all of the duck villagers are cute. I could never pick just one.

I have Joey on my second island. I love all the ducks. My second island might end up being all ducks.

 

[Xara]

not me literally sighing in relief when i saw that “both” was an option LOL. they’re adorable and i honestly love them both. ^^

 

[JemAC]

I voted for Molly as she's really cute, despite having a plain design, and is one of my favourite villagers in the game. Ketchup has a cool design and I don't dislike her but there are a number of peppy villagers I prefer so I never really consider her.

 

[Moonlight.]

while i prefer molly, i voted for both. they're super cute and if you can have both of them on your island then go for it!

 

[peachycrossing9]

I have them both on my island currently (will be kicking soon though), and I think they are both super cute and I really couldn't choose who i like better. It's kind of funny though, because on my island they really don't like each other.