I need help deciding my normal villager!

[hopeworld]

Hi everyone! As the title suggests, I need help deciding which normal personality I will be keeping or inviting to my island. I personally don't enjoy interacting with normal villagers that much so I may only choose one from the list (although I do have two currently on my island)

My narrowed down options:

• Vesta - I really enjoy her design, although she doesn't fit well with my island theme
• Skye - Loved having her on my island with her constant singing, isn't the best for the theme and I already have two wolves
• Molly - Fits my theme well and overall cute
• Maple - Same as above
• Fauna - Love how her design is alike to a real deer but already have 2 other deer villagers
• Coco - She sends me adorable letters but I don't find myself wanting to talk to her much

If you have had any of these villagers on your island or have an opinion on who I should boot or invite, please let me know! Thanks!

 

[Karmahri]

Although I'm a big fan of skye and her soft voice, I think you can narrow down your list to just molly and maple based off of your thoughts already!! I'd go with maple because I think she's adorable and a cub with a name like maple~ like in maple syrup is a must for me

Good luck!

 

[Xara]

since you seemingly want a villager that matches your theme, i would go with either molly or maple ;;

 

[applesauc3]

Maple is definitely one of my favourite villagers she’s such a delight to see and interact with and she’s adorable!

 

[Vio1et]

I'd pick one of the ones that match your theme, since it seems like that's kinda what you're looking for. My personal favorite of the two is Molly, but Maple is adorable as well! I don't think you can go wrong with either one~

 

[jo_electric]

I don’t have any of them but Molly is adorable.

 

[Dude_Skillz]

Molly.
got her yesterday, her house, interior and exterior, is EXTREMELY adorable. her default clothes, a green blouse, looks perfect on her I'm debaiting even gifting her clothes. recommend her over Maple

 

[pup]

molly or maple! they're cute babies.

i've had all of them at one point and you really can't go wrong, but those were the only two in your list you didn't seem to have any hesitance about. i always really enjoy molly in particular because i don't love the ducks so she is always the only duck on my island. species variety makes a difference for me (having ended up with a bunch of wolves and deer at the beginning of the game, i've gotten sick of them). also she's so. stinkin. cute.

 

[Rosie977]

I think Skye just because I have her and love her... But, based on your reasoning, I would say either Maple or Molly! It's nice to have themed villagers, and you seem to really like them!

 

[Serabee]

Although I'm a big fan of skye and her soft voice, I think you can narrow down your list to just molly and maple based off of your thoughts already!! I'd go with maple because I think she's adorable and a cub with a name like maple~ like in maple syrup is a must for me

Good luck!

That's what I was thinking, too! And I personally am partial to Maple, since she was the first villager I ever met ☺

I admire you for being able to narrow it down so much, though. Normal villagers are hard because there are SO MANY cute ones!

 

[Boccages]

Olive is the best normal villager. Olive