i ask the people.

[toenuki]

I NEED TO THINK OF MY RESIDENTS I LITERALLY CANNOT CHOOSE ON MY OWN.

I want most of the newbies, muffy and all the octos, which leaves me with these undecided villagers

so i ask the people: who should get kicked out of this Possibly Dreamy List? maybe two?

Post automatically merged: May 25, 2020

like for example im not sure if i should keep nor want judy/sherb bc i love the newbies but like will they fit... maybe i should remove them both for now

 

[dragonair]

Sherb is honestly the most boring one to me. ; v ;

 

[Fye]

Judy's design is a bit much for me so I went with her, but I feel like I'd get used to it after a while. So no idea really. Good luck!

 

[peachmilke]

I just got Judy and she definitely gives off very shoujo anime/manga vibes to me! If you're into that you'll like her! Sherb seems cute, but simple so that's up to you if you like him or not -- idk you can always test run one and if you don't like em replace them

 

[pup]

RIP judy (i think she’s hilariously cute but not a villager i’d ever want).

to be honest tho i have never gotten all my dreamies and then felt 100% satisfied? you may find that you want to switch it up later anyway. sometimes getting surprised by a random move-in from a villager i’d never want has turned out well (ty clyde, you ugly boy). either way good luck!

 

[toenuki]

RIP judy (i think she’s hilariously cute but not a villager i’d ever want).

to be honest tho i have never gotten all my dreamies and then felt 100% satisfied? you may find that you want to switch it up later anyway. sometimes getting surprised by a random move-in from a villager i’d never want has turned out well (ty clyde, you ugly boy). either way good luck!

i need like a set list rn. i feel so scattered w this group of villagers i want judy but i also dont? sherb's kinda bland tho.

 

[mayortiffany]

I voted for Judy because I'm not the biggest fan of her design. Her eyes are a bit much for me and don't really match with the art style of the other villagers.

You may want to consider your dreamies and their personality type, hobby type, and species if you're looking for some variety. Those might matter to you more than aesthetics!

 

[pup]

i need like a set list rn. i feel so scattered w this group of villagers i want judy but i also dont? sherb's kinda bland tho.

totally fair! i always have a dreamie list but usually swap them out for new ones as i move along lol. having goals is helpful, but i also use amiibo so swapping is less permanent. if you don’t feel super strongly about them, there’s no harm in going island hopping and picking up someone just to try them out. or just flip a coin lmao. i find being told to do something and not wanting to do it usually helps me realize what i really want lol

 

[Fendi]

All four are very different from one another, but from my own personal preference, I would probably kick Judy out. I understand why some people see her as being cute, but I guess her design is not my cup of tea.

I have a soft spot for Sherb, and he's still one of my favourites, so I hope you keep him! But definitely up to you!

 

[Zane]

Ankha, I never liked her.

 

[sleepydreepy]

Sherb, I thought I liked him in the beginning but he's kinda weird

 

[UglyMonsterFace]

I think Judy is overly cute. It's just too much for me tbh, that's why I voted her off. But it's really up to you!

 

[Dwayne Johnson]

remove j u d y

 

[Clock]

Judy should go. I feel like her appearance does not match her personality.

 

[cicely]

Not the most popular option, but I voted for Sherb. I think there are so many good lazy villagers that he doesn't stand out at all to me
The rest of the villagers listed are cute and iconic

 

[jumpluff]

Scoot is so precious and unique... I also voted for Judy, she just doesn't seem to fit as well with your other villagers as the rest!

 

[Xara]

i’d personally boot judy ;;

 

[AustinS]

I would get rid of ankha personally the other 3 are far to precious for me to vote for!

 

[Chungus]

Judy's design with her anime twinkly eyes and pastel fur is off-putting to me. Ankha is a better snooty out of the two.