I'm on the same boat, I really like all my villager atm... but I have 3 cranky villagers and 3 smug villagers .-. I might let go of Apollo eventually, but I'm very reluctant on it. I almost feel like getting another game, but I don't think it's worth it t.t
8/10 are for sure atm. I kinda wanna rotate Flurry and Merengue bc I have their amiibos, but I don't really want them at the same time unless they increase the islander limit bc that's one too many normals as I also have Marina. I also am not sure if I wanna keep Fuchsia and get Renee instead, I'm waiting to see if she grows on me.
definitely: Maple, Audie, Octavian, Zucker, Marina, Punchy
probably: Marshal, Flurry
will let move out but I still love him: Rasher (he was an accidental random move-in, and I want to choose this time)
don’t know yet (moving in tomorrow): Judy
7 of my villagers are permanent; Rosie, Elvis, Marshal, Sprocket, Stitches, Dom, Bob. My other villagers are Melba, Fauna and Flora. Not 100% sure about them, plus I reaaally want Lily and Judy and I like meeting new villagers.
Perma staying forever in my island:
Marshal, Stitches, Ruby, Raymond,Rosie,Olivia.
50/50
Judy, Bob,Static,Poppy.
I wanna get rid of Bob but he's the latest villager that moved in so unless I have an amiibo or campsite villager he aint going.
I want to get Coco, Diana and Sylvana at some point, just to test them out.
Only 1/10, and that’s because I traded for Willow and she is my all time absolute favourite. Everyone else is replaceable :3 No but seriously, I like to change up my villager roster from time to time to keep my town feeling fresh. Plus is love meeting villagers I’ve never seen before - even the unconventionally ugly ones.
9 right now. Lucky, Coco, Agnes, Zell, Ruby, Pecan, Raddle, Rasher, and Rodeo. Sadly Tia is a bit like Sherb and Ankha were. Her house is just too colorful/bright to fit in.
8/10 rn i guess. Intend to move out Julian and Sprocket at some point but rest will stay. Not sure about Croque as for cranky yet but I do like him yes.
Three: Curt, Merry and Alice are permanent.
There's also another three that are kinda permanent, two that I like but not yet sold on them and two that I don't care for.
Right now, nine of them will likely stay indefinitely. There were a couple that I planned on moving out at some point, but I’ve grown too attached to them, so now I’ll probably keep them. I do have a few too many personality overlaps, which is a little unfortunate, but I think I would miss all of my current villagers if I let any of them move.
I can’t decide who my last villager should be. It’s going to be either a smug or a cranky, as those are the two personalities I’m missing, but I have to pick one, and I’m not sure which one to go for.
Right now, three. Savannah, Camofrog, and Rocco. The other are separated into “I like him/her, so they can stay for a while” and “give me your damn pic so you can move on!”