A person who believes they are "above the law" does not deserve the privilege/responsibility of defending/enforcing law.
so let's play make-believe for a second, and say that there's a shortage of volunteers for our army in general, which brings back the draft.
in your opinion, someone who is otherwise fully capable and willing to serve their time in the army is to be passed by simply because they believe they're "above the law"?
in that case, i think a good chunk of america would become ineligible in one fell swoop. could just be my opinion, though.
i think you're trying to over-glorify the responsibility of enforcing the law (though honestly i've never in my personal lifetime seen the united states navy enforcing any law in their own country). while there is plenty to be envious of, there is some sense in what aeri just posted (as sad as that is).
consider every war america has been in, and war stories. were all of the enlisted clean cut, morally? were they all straight-arrow (so to speak), straight-shooting americans who embodied everything our nation stood for? obviously there were plenty of "bad apples" that were not fully in the right, if you want to be picky about it, but the very fact that they love, respect, and defend their country by putting their lives in danger is a huge item that i think you're missing, in exchange for "he hasn't followed every government rule completely so he shouldn't be able to join the army!"
i wish i knew (but am too lazy to learn/read) more about politics, so that i knew which kind of extremist view you have. cuz i have this funny feeling it's some bitterly strict way of life for you.
edit: also, i think it's worth mentioning (should've just mentioned this instead) the first days for america. if no one had thought themselves above the british empire, would any of us be here to defend our homes, today?
it's a bit of a different way to go, and no i'm not implying we should all start a country with nic as our president, but it is part of being an american (in my opinion) to have your own set of beliefs, and to follow through with them so long as they stand morally sound within yourself. if the army wouldn't accept him for using this site, i would say that's tough luck for the army. but that's just me.