Click Here to Get Help on Deciding Which Club Nintendo Elite Status Reward to Get!

[Holla]

I figured with the release of Club Nintendo's final set of Elite Status rewards that many of us are now having trouble on deciding which game to get. So, I made this thread! Just post your situation and what your thinking and someone else can help give you an opinion on what would be worth it and what wouldn't be.

Here's a brief look at all the possible rewards:

Below is an optional form that you can use if you'd like. Just to help you include all info that someone may need when helping you make a decision.

Status: (Gold or Platnuim)
Systems Owned: (3DS, Wii U or both)
Games You Already Have: (Out of the possible reward choices)
Other Info:

 

[Shimmer]

Wait I'm confused. How do you get platinum or gold status?

 

[LambdaDelta]

Wait I'm confused. How do you get platinum or gold status?

register 300 coins for gold, 600 coins for platinum. not sure for eu, but its something to do with stars

though its all ogre now

 

[Holla]

I'm personally considering one of the NES Remixes, or another AC:NL town (I only have one town right now that I'm bored of but don't have the heart to reset.) Any suggestions?

I have Platinum status and own both a Wii U and 3DS. I already own Mario Kart 7, Mario Party Island Tour and one copy of AC:NL.
I also don't have much interest in Mario Golf (seems like a simpler more boring version of Wii Sports Golf but with Mario characters and themes (correct me if I'm wrong though) or Yoshi's New Island (heard it's kinda meh). Plus I'm not a huge platformer person.

 

[Tinkalila]

How many coins do you get per game? I don't have mine registered, but I have a lot of games, I might do them all this weekend if it's gonna get my gold or platinum status.

 

[abby534534]

I am stuck between Mario Golf World Tour for 3ds and New Super Mario Bros. 2. It'll definitely be one of those 2 but I have no idea which yet.... I have the other platinum games offered for 3ds.

 

[pokedude729]

I'm trying to decide between the NES remixes, super star saga, and Mario Kart 7.

 

[strawberrywine]

Agh...I really want Mario Golf or another ACNL town, but my 3ds has weird things stuck inside the screen and the circle pad is really sticky and stiff no matter what I do (wd 40, etc) and I'm just not that sure if I want tropical freeze :x

 

[ElysiaCrossing]

1) thanks so much for posting the rewards! I saw something in the club nintendo marketplace but was confused as to what was going on. When I tried to get on club nintendo, it wouldn't work. >.<

2) How much does each game cost? and you just have to be a platinum or gold member to get the games, right?

 

[DarkDesertFox]

If I had to go back in time I would have registered all my codes from last year to this year. I didn't even order my Club Nintendo Platinum status reward last year because I forgot so it felt like a waste. This year I managed to make gold at least. My sister and I share an account so that narrows down my choices to a Wii U game. Yeah, I don't really see anything good for gold.

 

[Holla]

1) thanks so much for posting the rewards! I saw something in the club nintendo marketplace but was confused as to what was going on. When I tried to get on club nintendo, it wouldn't work. >.<

2) How much does each game cost? and you just have to be a platinum or gold member to get the games, right?

1) The site is overloaded right now so give it a few weeks or try to log on in the wee hours of the morning.

2) They don't cost anything, but yes you must have Gold or Platinum status and get get the choice of 1 reward. Gold members can choose from any games above with the G symbol, while Platinums can pick anything from above.

 

[ElysiaCrossing]

1) The site is overloaded right now so give it a few weeks or try to log on in the wee hours of the morning.

2) They don't cost anything, but yes you must have Gold or Platinum status and get get the choice of 1 reward. Gold members can choose from any games above with the G symbol, while Platinums can pick anything from above.

ah. ty :3

I just managed to get on. I think I'll get a third copy of acnl. ^.^

 

[Yoshisaur]

How many coins do you get per game? I don't have mine registered, but I have a lot of games, I might do them all this weekend if it's gonna get my gold or platinum status.

You can't register games anymore. Club Nintendo is closed except to redeem rewards.

 

[DaCoSim]

UGhhhhhhhh.... gonna be MarioGolf or another ACNL for me. I've got enough coins to get my kids 2 games as well. Gonna let them choose in the next few days.

 

[xanisha]

I have never really wanted a second acnl game but somehow I reached platinum and it would be a waste to not get it right?

 

[Yoshisaur]

I have never really wanted a second acnl game but somehow I reached platinum and it would be a waste to not get it right?

Unless you want one of the other games!

 

[bloomwaker]

I don't own my own personal WiiU (someday, but not now) and I have a lot of the 3DS rewards already.

Gods save me, I'm contemplating another AC:NL.

 

[kittenrobotarmy]

Status: Gold
Systems Owned: 3DS
Games You Already Have: ACNL, Legend of Zelda, LoZ: Oracle of Ages
Other Info: If I was Platinum, I would totally get MK7 but I need help since I only managed to reach Gold.

 

[pokedude729]

Status: Platinum
Systems Owned: Both
Games You Already Have: Galaxy 2, New Leaf, New Super Mario Bros 2, both Oracles, Zelda 1, and Metroid fusion
Other Info: I'm mainly trying to decide between Superstar Saga, Tropical freeze and Mario Kart 7. Maybe the NES remixes if you guys think they're good.

 

[Holla]

Status: Gold
Systems Owned: 3DS
Games You Already Have: ACNL, Legend of Zelda, LoZ: Oracle of Ages
Other Info: If I was Platinum, I would totally get MK7 but I need help since I only managed to reach Gold.

Maybe try to keep an eye out for someone who is platnium but only wants to redeem a gold prize? That way you could redeem what they want on yours and what you want on theirs and then you could swap codes? It's very risky though, and unlikely but it could happen.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Status: Platinum
Systems Owned: Both
Games You Already Have: Galaxy 2, New Leaf, New Super Mario Bros 2, both Oracles, Zelda 1, and Metroid fusion
Other Info: I'm mainly trying to decide between Superstar Saga, Tropical freeze and Mario Kart 7. Maybe the NES remixes if you guys think they're good.

If I were you I'd pick Mario Kart 7 it's an amazing game. Not as great as MK8, but still worth it and was easily the best Mario Kart before 8 came out. The final choice is up to you though. ^.^