Anyone else cant let go of villagers who arent dreamies!?

Jacques was my first camp site visitor and I hated him... but since then I warmed up to him and simply cannot not smile when he is around! I will not let him go, gosh, I even bought his amiibo to make sure I can have him in the future too!
 
i’ve had a lot of villagers grow on me but the main one is tammy - she was my starter uchi and she’s not my dreamie at all and i don’t plan on keeping her but i’ve honestly grown a bit attached to her and am not looking forward to the day when she moves out ;u;
 
Me with Sally, Alice, Charlise and Admiral >.< I also felt like that with Gabi but kicked her out anyway. Luckily I got her amiibo so if I ever want to I can just invite her back.
 
Apple and Muffy are not my dreamies at all, but I grew to like them and I'm still working away on getting their photos. I think down the line, I may find it easier to let them go once I do get their photos, but for the time being, I've connected with them in a way I didn't even imagine.
 
i'm gonna have a real hard time parting with zucker, all other popular and cute looking villagers i've had no problem saying good bye to but he's just so sweet, he just plops down in the most inconvenient places and it's so precious, i'm not super decided on my 10th villager atm so it may be him that stays
 
I kinda am getting attached with Ed lol! He's a cool guy and he seems really nice! And him and Julian kinda vibe together, they kinda look like brothers imo (both of them are blue horses lol) but will let him go tho once he asks
 
i usually feel more attached to the villagers i didn't hype myself up about getting and came on their own ahaha. bangle was never on my radar but she was one of my first random move-ins and she's still here! i'm waiting to get her picture, and then i think i'll let her go, but it'll be hard to say good bye. i never vibed w/ the peppies but she is such a sweet pea and now i am considering two peppies for the first time ever.

bc this game has so few new villagers and i'm not interested in any of them, i've already had all my "dreamies" multiple times over the years. i'm finding myself drawn to villagers i've never had now and that means they aren't as traditionally cute.
 
Pretty much anyone who moves onto my island will be doomed to be stuck there forever because of my strong attachment to them. I disliked Rocco at first, but now I don't mind him anymore so he's staying for quite a while.
 
This is me with Beau and Raymond right now. I really like the other 8 villagers on my island and I don't want them to leave, but these two are definitely two I can live without.

Solely because I like Sherb more than Beau and I had Beau in NL and the smugs are just meh for me. I'll probably let them both go eventually once I decide on some replacements, but it won't be until the far future.
 
I'm experiencing this with O'Hare and Bunnie.

O'Hare was my mandatory camper, and I was OK with it because he's pretty cool (in an unhip dad kind of way). But I wasn't super excited about him, either. Now, I never want to let him go! He has the absolute coolest house in the game, IMO, and his dumb dad jokes and lame flirting fit his appearance so well. I'll probably keep him permanently because I don't know of any other smugs I would rather have.

With Bunnie, she was a random camper who I wasn't planning on inviting, but she just happened to ask to replace Limburg (my least favorite villager at the time), so I said yes because she was cute and I wanted him gone. She's soooo sweet and her house is adorable and I just love her!

The only issue is that now I have three peppies, and my other two are permanent (Flora and Tangy). I really don't want three of the same personality permanently, you know? Plus, right now I don't have any crankies, sisterlies, OR normals, and I really need to re-balance that. I'll be so sad when I finally get Bunnie's photo and it's time to let her go!
 
Maybe if you can't let go of some of your current villagers, it means they're your potential dreamies.
It happened to me with Boyd for sure.
 
ME WITH BIFF! I CANT LET GO OF BIFF AND IDK WHY BUT HES MY LAST NON-DREAMIE PLOT AND I NEED TO PART WAYS SOON

I really thought I wrote this 😭 Biff was my starter jock and I was like, "he's not that bad but Genji is my go-to jock, so Biff will have to leave!"

...

I have no plans to let him move anymore. We're so close now and I have the highest friendship with him than any of my other villagers, including 3 of my acquired dreamies. Maybe someday after I get his picture, but I let Twiggy go (she was one of my 3 move-ins at the beginning) and I miss having her around. I don't want to make the same mistake with Biff!
 
I kept swearing I'd never let Klaus go because I really, really have grown to like him. But I've got 3 smugs now and it's too many and... and... it might be Klaus.

I just said goodbye to Boris, another villager I just loved having around, and it was HARD. I went into his house once, saw him in boxes, and then avoided that side of the island for the rest of the day. Felt like a coward but it was too sad.
 
I really want to reset my island and the only thing holding me back is having bob in a starter house
 
I feel that so hard for Bones! He is definitely not on my list but I'm surprised how attached to him I am! I think I'm going to get his amiibo so I can invite him back one day if he ever asks to leave!
 
I didn't like Agnes much at first, and she was my starter so her house is terrible, but I couldn't let her go and gradually I've grown to really like her. Now I'm trying to improve her house by giving her lots of antique furniture! Today she gave me my final reaction, so even more respect for her, haha.
 
Yes, Peirce! He was my first ever starter and he's still on my island with his starter house. I was gonna let him go but he's grown on me, and I think he and my island rep are buddies. Normally I don't like the jocks, but it also helps that I used to friends with him back in Wild World.
 
Back
Top