I don't remember what villagers I started out with in my older towns, but for my current town, Fabulae, I got Tia, Bam, Pancetti, Anicotti and Camofrog. All of them are gone, except for Tia and Bam. I initially wanted to move out Bam too. but he grew on me and is a stayer now.
I'm having a bit of a hard time remembering... I know there was Marcie, since she's the only one still in my town, but I just can't remember the rest! Well, there's Poncho but I forget if he was one of the originals or an early move in. Same with Erik, but I'm a bit more certain that he was a move in.
in my first town all i remember is poppy, marshal and chrissy (maybe they moved in rly early. they were the only villagers i cared about XD)
second town was chester, goose, eunice, bree and someone else ono
i can't remember at all DX is there a way to find out? Like sitting on the tree long enough? Though I'm pretty sure, Alfonso, Butch and Olaf were probably one of th first animals in my town.