I don't remember for my main town but none of them have stayed. They were all ugly villagers from what I know. I slightly remember Gruff but I'm not sure if he was one of my first 5.
Dang, you're lucky you remember, the only villager I remember in being my first five it Rudy, and (maybe) Chrissy? Could be Francine, but I know it was one of them.. Oh and Opal might be one too...
Basically Opal, Chrissy (or Francine), and DEFINITELY Rudy. That's all I remember.
The only ones I remember are Static and Kidd (and maybe Timbra). I mostly just cared about those two that I didn't really pay attention to my other villages
Wow I can't really remember anymore All I know is Fauna was one of them and Kid Cat might have been too (although he could have also been an early move in). The rest have all moved away so I'm not really sure. O'Hare might have also been one of them. I didn't have such a terrible line-up anyway