Top 15 Collectibles (2023 Version)

[That Marshal Fangirl]

A few threads similar to this exist, but they’re old and haven’t seen activity in a long time. They also had a limit of 10, which I think is too hard to narrow down personally. Considering all the new collectibles that came out since the last thread, I thought it would be a good idea to make a new one. For this version, including whole sets (or less) as “one” is fine, as long as the collectibles in the set are essentially color variants of each other (e.g., the Star Fragments). You may list less than 15 if you prefer, and honorable mentions if you want more are fine as well. I’ll start:

1. Butterfly Spirits:

2. Star Fragments:

3. Heart Glow Wand:

4. Galaxy Easter Egg:

5. Nightmare Easter Egg:

6. Disco Ball Easter Egg:

7. Aurora Easter Egg:

8. Dreamy Easter Egg:

9. Frost Easter Egg:

10. Pastel Disco Ball Easter Egg:

11. Crystals:

12. Lily of the Valley:

13. Planet Glow Wand:

14. Celeste Chick Plush:

15. Gradient Feathers:

(Don't have a Sweet Feather but I'd love to own one again someday)

Honorable Mentions:

*

**

* = A fantasy but I can still dream!

** = Impossible unless I get very, very lucky in a raffle, but I stare at it every time it's in a lineup

 

[Croconaw]

Hmm, I’m not that into collectibles so coming up with a top fifteen is difficult for me. However, a few collectibles that I do like the design of include the Aurora Sky, the Star Fragments, Glam Feather, Cool Feather, Mom’s Plush, Pokéball, Moon Ball, Lobo, and Lucky. The villager collectibles are just because I like the villagers.

 

[Xara]

i’m gonna need a “top 50 collectibles” thread to make narrowing it down not so hard. tried my best, though — i have so many favourites.

1. crescent-moon wand (i don’t think anything will ever top this for me ngl)

2. celeste chick plush

3. aurora egg

4. rainbow moon jellyfish

5. dino plush

6. bee plush

7. kitty plushes

8. angel wings potion

9. bluebird of happiness plush

10. kaleidoclover

11. aurora sky

12. rainbow star frag

13. snow bunny

14. moon ball

15. chocolate cake

some honourable mentions:

,

,

,

 

[S.J.]

This feels quire hard, especially to order the favourites from 1-15! I am probably, definitely, missing something.

1.

Crescent Moon Glow Wand
=2.

Glam Feather
=2.

Pink Love Potion
4. [ ] Sweet Feather
5.

Crystal set (particularly love the pink and green)
6.

Snowbunny
7.

Swamp Potion
8.

Celeste Chick Plush
9.

Bluebird of Happiness Plush
10.

Aurora Sky
11.

Spring Shamrock
12.

Spring Sakura
13. [ ] Holiday Lights
14.

Chocolate cake

I stopped at fourteen, but this is my best guess! Special mentions to the

Red Christmas Stocking and

Jingloid for seasonal collectibles.

 

[Millysaurusrexjr]

Difficult to rank these but I think this is how mine would go (using only collectibles that I have):

1.

Star Fragments.. My first really cool collectibles! Pretty and they go with almost anything!
2.

Shooting Star.. Was so proud to get one of these!
3.

Love Potion.. Same as above
4.

Gastly Egg.. I mean, come on! One of the best ever ghost Pokémon, now in egg form!
5.

Ice Cream Swirl.. Just adorable. Pairs well with bees.
6.

Bee Plush.. Just adorable. Pairs well with ice cream.
7.

Gyroids.. We need more of them. Staff please, if you are reading this, please make Squeakoid. I beg of you
8.

Junimo Egg.. This should probably be higher? I love Stardew Valley and never expected to see a Junimo on here!
9.

Shadow Kitty Plush.. A cat plush is a dream come true! Reminds me of my childhood pet cat, who was a grumpy black cat.
10.

Summer Shell.. I just love it. Wish I could have more. Wish I had tried harder to win a pink one!
11.

Mush Lamps.. They're so underrated.
12.

Crystals.. Shiny!
13.

Enchanted Bloom.. Ooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo
14.

ど.. The houses just always impressed me for some reason!
15.

Snow Angel Snowman.. Also very underrated! I thought the collaboration challenge was a really fun event, and the final snowman looks so cute. The epitome of Christmas!

Oh and honorable mentions go to: Oarfish, Red Christmas Stocking, Lily of the Valley

 

[Foreverfox]

1.) Enchanted Bloom -

2.) Nightmare egg -

3.) Galaxy egg -

4.) Disco egg -

5.)Aurora egg -

6.) Wisp egg -

7.) Opalescent crystal -

8.) Pearlescent crystal -

9.) Heart wand -

10.) Enchanted Butterfly wand -

11.) Love Ball -

12.) Celeste Chick plushie -

13.) Bluebird plushie -

14.) Angel Wings potion -

15.) Snow Bunny -

he’s cute, I love bun bun

Also favorite:

 

[jadetine]

This IS a tough call! I adore these lil pixels. ^_^
1. Crescent Moon Wand (totally 100% agree)

2. Shooting Star; (all I gotta say is that @Mick's idea for a space camp next summer better happen)

3. Aurora Sky

4. The Heart Wand:

5. Magical Fireworks

6. Star frags, including the rainbow one:

7. The Star Wand:

8. The Crystals

9. 2016 Bell Tree Fair Patch (can you tell I regret not being here in 2016 yet?)

10. Heart of the Forest (tysm for voting for me!)

11. Bell Tree Fair 2020 Patch

12. The Flower Wand:

13. Mush Lamps

14. The 2021WC Patch (go froggy chairs!)

15. Enchanted Bloom (the more I look at it, the more life is sapped from my body, but it's worth it)

So I guess the moral of the story is I'm a sucker for a dark background with something shiny / glowy.
I ran out of room, but the honorable mentions for me are
the houses:

and the animated pinwheel:

 

[MiniPocketWorld]

1. Icecream Swirl

2. Aurora Egg

3. Rafflesia

4. White Star Frag

5. Bluebird Plush

6. Chao Egg

7. Nightmare Egg

8. Fossil Egg

9. Bee Plush

10. Red Stocking

11. Lump of Coal

12. Dino Plush

13. Celeste Plush

14. Snowbunny

15. Spectral Preserves


Honorables:
Will o the Wisp Egg
Aurora Sky
Candy Canes
Purple Mittens
Crystals
Poptart Egg
Oarfish

Edited to add pictures.
Actually I forgot the Snowflake collectible existed. Like I knew about it being temporary one for like a ticket thing last year, but totally forgot about the permanent version. So you can pretend it was listed somewhere in here. Probably above the purple mittens.
Maybe I'll Update my list after the Christmas Event.

 

[-Mars-]

-

 

[Kattea]

1) Dreamy egg

- a pastel lover’s dream
2) Sweet feather

- same, just perfection
3-9) Plushies

- I’m a simple person; I see Laudine collectibles, I buy.
10) Angel wings potion

- the iridescence on this one?? It’s like bottled moonlight.
11) Love potion

- these are so rare, I’m just honoured to own one
12) Yule log

- so detailed, so festive
13) Enchanted butterfly wand

- someone sell it to me plz
14) Snow bunny

- the little EARS? I just want to hold it in my palm
15) Rose water potions

- love that we had to collaborate as a community to unlock these, such a warm memory

 

[skarmoury]

Yay I love these threads! I own or have owned majority of the collectibles, the one exception being the Aurora Egg.

1. 
   Shooting star - Utmost favorite collectible! Love how smooth the animation is. I'll never get over it.
2. 
   Snowflake - Christmas is my favorite holiday and I've never experienced snow, so this unmelting snowflake has a big place in my heart. It was my dream collectible since it first released in 2015, and I'm so happy I won one!
3. 
   Star Glow Wand - Ah, the coveted star wand. It's so beautiful and rare and shiny and ahhh.
4. 
   Heart Glow Wand - I am a sucker for hearts and the pink color and the glow-y appearance. It's so so so pretty.
5. 
   Forest of the Heart -Tbh, at first I wasn't a fan of this, but it quickly grew on me once I played around with it in lineups. The pale rainbow and the crystal shine are absolutely gorgeous!
6. 
   Love Potion - Valentines, what's not to love? My favorite potion, and I'm happy it's attached to good memories of the artwork I submitted for that contest.
7. 
   Ruby - I love Ruby and I love the blue background. I just adore the lineup I have with her in the middle of flower collectibles.
8. 
   Galaxy Egg -Won two galaxy eggs for each of the egg decorating contests, so it has a special place in my heart. It doesn't fit any of my lineups sadly, but as a solo collectible it's an easy favorite.
9. 
   Sweet Feather - Solos all your fave feathers!!! Like the galaxy egg, the sweet feather feels more beautiful alone (or at least with the cool feather!)
10. 
    Gold Trophy - Pee trophy? Pee trophy. Not the best trophy aesthetic-wise (silver trophy sweeps), but the honor of owning one is enough for it to land a spot in the top 10. :]

Here are my 5 runner-up collectibles!

Super love the spectral preserves, it's pretty even off-season.

Pretty. I wish I had one. I wish I had a whole lineup of these.

Also very pretty. I want a whole lineup of them too.

I'll never forget my favorite white egg. Poptart egg is always a nostalgic design.

Rebel Gnome's got my back!!!!!! You have no idea how hard I laughed seeing him for the first time. I know the little rebel homie got me.

 

[Sheep Villager]

I think I could've just skipped making a list and said anything with green or yellow on it but that's not as fun. The only ones that break that theme are collectibles with chaotic color patterns. and the pansies of course, but that one is a given.

1. 
   
   
   
   
   
2. 
   
   
3. 
   
   
   
4. 
5. 
   
   
6. 
   
   
7. 
   
   
   
8. 
   
   
9. 
   
   
10. 
    
    
    
11. 
12. 
    
    
13. 
    
    
14. 
    
    
15. 

 

[jadetine]

I think I could've just skipped making a list and said anything with green or yellow on it but that's not as fun. The only ones that break that theme are collectibles with chaotic color patterns. and the pansies of course, but that one is a given.

1. 
   
   
   
   
   
2. 
   
   
3. 
   
   
   
4. 
5. 
   
   
6. 
   
   
7. 
   
   
   
8. 
   
   
9. 
   
   
10. 
    
    
    
11. 
12. 
    
    
13. 
    
    
14. 
    
    
15. 

I just made the assumption you would value the sheep plush. Nope!
I am glad you shared these!

 

[Sheep Villager]

I just made the assumption you would value the sheep plush. Nope!
I am glad you shared these!

Oh no am I about to get evicted from having this username. /jk

I do actually like the sheep plush too, but it's just so pastel that I'm rarely able to actually use it! If I was allowed to give my sheep a little dye job it'd immediately skyrocket the collectible in to my top 10.

 

[LadyDestani]

This is always so difficult and it's even harder to narrow it down with all of the amazing new collectibles that keep being released. But allowing for sets and increasing it to 15 helps.

1. Enchanted Bloom!

2. Aurora Sky

3. Potion Set

They're all nice, but these are my top 5 in no particular order.
4. Star Fragments

Again I love them all, but these are in my top tier. I guess you can tell my favorite color schemes.
5. Moon Jellyfish

Among the first true ocean themed collectibles. I hope we see more in the future.
6. Lily of the Valley

7. Wands

These are the only two I own, but they are all beautiful.
8. Aurora Egg

My first favorite collectible. I still remember the thrill of obtaining it after a long search. It will always be precious to me.
9. Blue Mote of Flame

10. Dusty Scroll

11. Ancient Lantern

12. Key to Bell Tree Manor

13. Mushroom Lamps

14. Gradient Feathers

These are my top 2 and I'm grateful to own them both.
15. Tetris Grid

 

[.: Meri :.]

I'm gonna try to narrow my favorites down but... there's so many beautiful collectibles out there. ;w; I'm not sure if my order will be consistent from previous posts either, just because I'm being so indecisive about it eheh. I'm glad we're allowed to name whole sets, or I just wouldn't know what to do with myself ahahaha

1.

Enchanted Bloom - Still beyond thrilled I managed to earn this one. It's so incredibly beautiful, I just don't have the words.
2.

Frost Easter Egg - Such a gorgeous shade of blue!! Love the subtle snowflake pattern too.
3.

Special Snowflake - It's pretty and wintry and I love the contrast. I'll keep dreaming for one someday
4.

Aurora Easter Egg - Pairs beautifully with both the Frost Egg and Aurora Sky imo, and it's always been a dream of mine to see the aurora someday. ^^
5.

Rosewater Potions - I love basically all the potions, but these top my list. The blue is so mysterious (and I will forever associate blue roses with Code: Realize now), and the warm pink with the touch of green is just
6.

Swamp Potion - It's a gorgeous, vibrant green and I love the nature-y vibes.
7.

Shooting Star - Like seriously how pretty is this, hello?? Stars are beautiful and this just feels so magical.
8.

Gradient Feathers - I just can't get over how pretty these colors are. ;v;
9.

Basic Feathers - Again, the colors!! These work so well with so many different lineups and aesthetics too.
10.

Aurora Sky - Have I mentioned that I love aurora borealis yet?
11.

Star Fragments - They're pretty, they're colorful, they're versatile...
12.

Crystals - They're so shiny and I love the color gradients!
13.

Lily of the Valley - One of my favorite flowers IRL! I love how this one is framed, and I think it works really well with the dark green background.
14.

Key Lime Pie - I just totally fell in love with how the colors work together, and it's so cute! It's got such a nice shade of spring green.
15.

Yule Log - Also very cute, and I love the cozy winter holiday vibes!

Honorable mentions: Galaxy Egg

, Moon Ball

, Spring Sakura

, Zen Easter Egg

, pretty much all the birthstones and flowers

 

[digimon]

proceeds to list almost every collectible ever i ranked them by sets ? kinda? and for some of them that have variations, i just put the ones that i like c:

1)

wand set ToT
2)

THE G.O.A.T
3)

so beautiful and they go with so many things, i love them sm
4)

also versatile and i love the gradients on them
5)

seeing this set grow over the years to almost having enough for a full lineup it's saur good!
6)

has a fond place in my heart! i remember working really hard to earn one during tbtwc ;u;
7)

i wish there were more added to this set because they go so well with the tetris grid + star frags
8)

goes great with the star fragments
9)

i love that these two were released together, they're so perfect
10)

bunny besties 4lyfe
11)

my favourite plush collectibles!
12)

THE DETAILS! it's such a beautiful collectible, i can't
13)

the gradients on these are so so pretty!
14)

these two are the first collectibles that i was really excited to get
15)

my favourite patches

honorable mentions: (the animated ones make me sob tbh)

 

[seliph]

1.

flea
2.

flea
3.

flea
4.

flea
5.

flea
6.

flea
7.

flea
8.

flea
9.

flea
10.

flea
11.

flea
12.

flea
13.

flea
14.

flea
15.

flea

 

[Mimi Cheems]

1.

For me, it is the Angel Wings Potion. The BEST TBT collectible.

2.

This has sentimental value to me. Nightmares gave me Lobo years ago and I will always try to keep him in my lineups! ;v;

3.

DREAMY EGG MY BELOVED!!!!!! I've loved this collectible for YEAAAAAAAARS!

4.

Poooooooke...

5.

Where my fellow Sanrio ladies and theydies and gentlemen and everyone else at?

6.

It's a PASTEL DISCO BALL. Need I repeat myself?!

7.

Much love to the GOAT and OG lover of Popsicles, @Miharu .. Team Popsicle forever in my heart.

8.

I like ice cream. This one in particular looks tasty..

9.

Matryoshka Doll because I am part Russian and have always been fascinated by their culture with lullabies, the language, and the like.

10.

I love the Bee Plush.. but I just... HAVE YOU SEEN MY SON?!?!!??!!?!?

11.

The only reason you're not higher up is because you're near IMPOSSIBLE to get! -_____-

12.

SAME REASON AS #11...

13.

Dare I say it a third time...

14.

My fascination with angels...... heh, uh...

15.

Spring Sakura

 

[Jacob]

I like to party!