you must make a monospecies island with all eight personality types

[angelcat621]

I already have an all cat island lol.
Katt, Kid Cat, Mitzi, Bob, Merry,
Raymond, Ankha, Tom, Lolly, Punchy

 

[Stella-Io]

I would say deer, cause they widely vary in terms of looks, such as Shino having more devilish upright red horns then Erik having grand antlers, Bam's more antelope small black skinny horns, Diana's lack of horns, ect...

 

[azurill]

Omg sprinkle, hopper, roald, wade, Tex aurora!!!! Luv them alllll. My oldest stepson, Gavin, had an all penguin town in new leaf!!!

Yea I love them all too. That’s awesome that he was able to get a full penguin town. I wanted one in new leaf but never got it. I now have all but Wade’s Amiibo cards. So it will be easy to have all penguin villagers now. I just want to get the photos of my current villagers on that island first.

 

[Nunnafinga]

I just made this 100% koala island with all eight personality types.Cool,huh?

 

[lasagne_of_death]

View attachment 600867
I just made this 100% koala island with all eight personality types.Cool,huh?

I only know 2 of these (Yuka and Melba, I think), congrats! Who's the definitely-really-there koala?

 

[Nunnafinga]

I only know 2 of these (Yuka and Melba, I think), congrats! Who's the definitely-really-there koala?

That's Huggy,the only peppy koala in any Animal Crossing game.I was hoping they'd bring her back for New Horizons since there's a ton of normal and ucherly koalas but not one peppy koala in the game.

 

[DaCoSim]

View attachment 600867
I just made this 100% koala island with all eight personality types.Cool,huh?

Where’s Sydney?!?! lol I love Sydney

 

[Alolan_Apples]

I would mostly have penguins. One of my towns in ACNL had only penguins. I don’t mind doing that again.

 

[Nunnafinga]

Where’s Sydney?!?! lol I love Sydney

I found this other pic from the same photo session.Yep,there's good ol' Sydney right where she's supposed to be.

 

[Yanrima~]

between the species, it's a tie between cats, penguins, and squirrels when it comes to mono-species island. Wish they have a cranky duck already as I actually wanted an all-duck village. So penguins or cats will do for now.

 

[Dim]

Normal: Kiki
Lazy: Bob
Peppy: Tangy
Jock: Kid Cat
Snooty: Purrl
Cranky: Tom
Sisterly: Katt
Smug: Raymond

I wasn't going to choose cat at first only because I never want Raymond on my island, but then again I don't like most of the smug designs in general. I would LOVE to have wolf more than any other species, but they didn't bring back Wolf Link and they freaking changed Dobie from lazy to cranky >_>

 

[Robi]

Penguin. I have an all penguin town in new leaf. Plus penguins have all the personalities. If only I could live in an all penguin town irl...

 

[S.J.]

It was a hard choice between pig and penguin! I started with the pigs, then moved onto the penguins, ultimately choosing the penguins, but I was happy with both!

Pigs
Not a lot of options to choose from with the piglets, but I wanted my girl Agnes! Most happy to have Agnes, Peggy, Maggie, Pancetti, and Hugh.

Sisterly: Agnes
Peppy: Peggy
Normal: Maggie
Snooty: Pancetti
Jock: Cobb
Lazy: Hugh
Smug: Chops
Cranky: Boris

Penguins
There is only one cranky, one normal, one sisterly, one smug, and one peppy. That being said, I am really happy with having Sprinkle and Puck! Really cute!

Sisterly: Flo
Peppy: Sprinkle
Normal: Aurora
Snooty: Friga
Jock: Roald
Lazy: Puck
Smug: Tex
Cranky: Hopper

 

[Sheando]

My three favorite species are anteaters, sheep, and dogs, so I’m going to have to go with dogs.

Cranky: Frett
Peppy: Cookie
Smug: Shep
Sisterly: Cherry
Jock: Mac
Normal: Goldie, Bea
Snooty: Portia
Lazy: Bones, Benjamin

 

[TrippyKitten]

I'm working on a mostly all-cat island currently, all but one villager will be cats. Partially because I don't want Raymond (he's cute, but doesn't fit) and I think it'd be cute just to have one rando blending in lol

Peppy: Tangy & Rosie
Cranky: Tom
Jock: Stinky
Lazy: Punchy
Snooty: Purrl
Smug: Raymond (if I were doing all cats lol)
Normal: Lolly & Kiki
Sisterly: Katt

 

[daffodilcrossing]

I’d go for cats, because there are options for a lot of the personality types. But I also love dogs and deer so I could easily do a monospecies with all eight personality types of any of those 3 types of animals

 

[Hedgehugs]

already did this with the squirrels when the game first came out haha but let me see if I remember everyone from memory;

hazel
poppy
sheldon
marshal
sally
cally
pecan
static
filbert
aaand...

uh...

Agent S! i don't know how I almost forgot about her since she was one of my favorites. i miss her so much sometimes haha.

 

[Croconaw]

Easily. I’ll choose DOGS.

 

[Ravenkitty22]

I had a hard time choosing between frogs, cats, and penguins but ultimately went with frogs for the poll. Here’s my choices.

Frogs:
Jock: Ribbot
Lazy: Jeremiah
Cranky: Wart Jr.
Smug: Henry
Peppy: Puddles
Normal: Lily
Snooty: Gigi (only option)
Sisterly: Diva (only option)
Extras: Drift and Raddle

Cats:
Jock: Kid Cat
Lazy: Punchy
Cranky: Tom
Smug: Raymond
Peppy: Felicity
Normal: Lolly
Snooty: Olivia
Sisterly: Katt
Extras: Kiki and Ankha

Penguins:
Jock: Roald
Lazy: Puck
Cranky: Hopper
Smug: Tex
Peppy: Sprinkle
Normal: Aurora
Snooty: Gwen
Sisterly: Flo
Extras: Boomer and Wade

 

[Robi]

My three favorite species are anteaters, sheep, and dogs, so I’m going to have to go with dogs.

Cranky: Frett
Peppy: Cookie
Smug: Shep
Sisterly: Cherry
Jock: Mac
Normal: Goldie, Bea
Snooty: Portia
Lazy: Bones, Benjamin

Ooh anteaters, I haven't seen an anteater villager in a while. I should try and get one on my island