Mitzi will always be my number one, but I also have soft spots for Kiki since she always gives me ACWW nostalgia and for Tangy because of ACGC nostalgia.
I voted Mitzi. She is so sweet and I got her picture today! She was about to move out last week and I stopped her the day before she was in boxes because I decided that I wanted to keep her.
I voted Moe but it's a really hard decision. I have him, Rudy, and Ankha in my town right now and I love all three of them. Moe is so derpy but lovable, Rudy's a sweetheart, and Ankha's like a big sister to my player. Bob holds a special place in my heart because he was in my first ever Animal Crossing town back on the GameCube but I haven't run into him in New Leaf yet unfortunately. I also remember having Mitzi in the GC game but not in New Leaf, as well as several others but it would take forever to go through them all.
Also I totally thought Feylne was a girl until now...