Who is the best (and worst) cow villager? 🐄

[piske]

I’m a fan of Tipper! I’d like to have her on my island actually, but I don’t like her new outfit, I want her rainbow tank back!

 

[princess.looking.for.frog]

My favourite has to be Patty because I had her in my wild world town back when I was like 6. So I don’t remember that many villagers from then, she is some of the few.
My least favourite is Naomi, I never really liked her and I think she looks a bit creepy.

 

[seliph]

my favourite cow was BELLE she was the perfect classic cow with big cute friendly eyes, bring her back. tipper is the closest thing we have and she's fine, but doesn't really cut it : (

none of the cows are really bad but i guess my least favourite would be norma, i just don't like the white pupils thing going on.

 

[corlee1289]

Naomi's colours are a little bit too extravagant and strains my colour palette.

I do quite like Tipper because she was my first ever cow villager I ever encountered. I remember she was on my town in New Leaf and am always opened to the idea of getting her back on my island if I ever get the chance to do so.

 

[oak]

Best: Tipper for sure
Worse: poor Patty, they made her so plain

 

[Snek]

Despite years passing and still only 4 cows, my tastes haven't changed.

BEST: Tipper. The black and white dairy cow who is the cow of all cows.

WORST: Naomi. The mess of all messes. What is she trying to prove? Somebody lied to her several times and told her that she was fly, hot and sexy and beautiful and she's nothing like that. She's nothing of the sort.

 

[rocketspruggs]

I love all of the cows, although Tipper has my vote.

I don't dislike any of them at all!

 

[Zinnia.]

Carrot's the best, but it's sad that she's another E-Card exclusive T-T
Patty, Norma and Tipper are kinda plain, so they're just ok. No strong opinions on Naomi either.

 

[KittenNoir]

I am not really a fan of the cow islanders.

 

[Mr.Fox]

Favorite is Norma…no specific reason, she just bothered me the least.

Least favorite is Naomi. Too hard on the eyes.

 

[Giddy]

I do like the look of Norma
Patty & Tipper are kinda meh, but I honestly can't remember if I ever had cows as villagers.
Ahh Naomi. If her eyes were a lil different, she would be viewed so differently.

Out of the cows we don't have anymore, the look of Carrot and Petunia look so cool. Carrot's design and colours actually suit her well.

 

[deana]

Best:
Tipper - I'm extra biased because she's on my island but I think Tipper is just the cutest, I love her little spots and her pink nose. Plus her name being a reference to cow tipping is hilarious.
Patty - I also really like Patty, her design is simple but she just looks really cute.

Worst:
Naomi - The red around her eyes is just kinda weird for me, and it also sorta clashes with the blue colour she is.

 

[BetsySundrop]

I picked Patty, as she's been on my island, and we got along. Patty's peppy personality is the one I get along with the best, so she's top cow. I have to be careful sometimes about choosing villagers, otherwise I'll end up on an island with just 4 types. It'd probably end up being-

5 peppy
3 jocks
1 lazy
1 cranky

Peppy villagers are obviously my favorite.

But - I recently got Norma on my island! She's normal personality type, and pretty nice. And all the pink is awesome. So, she'll probably end up my 2nd place. I've never had Tipper or Naomi though, so my top vote is my "for now" favorite.

 

[xlisapisa]

I love all the cow villagers, i don’t think there is any cow I dislike. my favorite out of the bunch would have to be tipper and norma though! If I had to pick a least favorite I would go with petunia from the og animal crossing, she was kinda of a b.

 

[Rio_]

My favourite is definitely Tipper! I just love that classic Holstien pattern so much! Sadly I've never had her, but I'm hoping to one day

I don't dislike any of the cows, but if I had to pick a least favourite it'd be Patty- solely because of her name...

 

[Briar]

My favorite cow is Tipper, although I like Norma and Patty as well.

My thoughts on each cow:
Tipper: I like her classic black and white Holstein Friesian appearance. Her eyes being closed isn't my favorite, but overall she's the best of the cows to me
Norma: I like her pink fur and blue hooves. She's cute
Patty: I don't like her eyes that much, but she has a nice neutral brown and tan color palette with golden hooves and horns
Naomi: I like her cyan coloring, but I'm not the biggest fan of her eyes or makeup

 

[Gabby]

I wish they'd bring the old cows back?! Belle, Bessie, and Petunia are all really cute! Of the new cows, Tipper is the best. She's got that classic cow look going on, we love a classic cow. A refined cow. A cow with style. A cow's cow, if you will.

Naomi looks like she's plotting something. I wouldn't drink her milk.

 

[.: Meri :.]

I think I like Norma the best! She's got a pretty cute design with nice colors, though I also like Tipper, who I had for a while in New Leaf! I think her old rainbow shirt suited her better though, although it may just be that I don't like Memphis patterns.

Worst is Naomi because I have no clue what's even going on with her eyes, and her colors are a little searing. Patty is quite cute, but her name is unfortunate whichever way you interpret the joke there.