Who are the best (and worst) duck villagers? 🦆

[Wolfieocelot]

Arghhh i hate when i cant fit all the villagers in the poll! But out of the 17 ducks, i chose the 14 most popular ones. Mention your favorite if they are not in the poll.

BEST: Ketchup. She is a cute tomato duck, what more could you ask for? She has my fave personality and is really unique
HONORABLE MENTIONS: Bill and Pompom. Bill is cute for a jock villager and Pompom's design matches her personality

WORST: Pate. At first, i thought she was a lazy villager, but shes actually a peppy. Also, her eyebrows make her look like shes always worried.

 

[Jam86]

best is bill, he is so simple, cute and i love him so much

worst, please forgive me... ketchup
i feel bad for hating her because so many people like her but i just can't stand her

 

[nightglow]

Molly. She is just super cute. Again I haven't had any of the duck villagers yet.
Others I hope to meet are Pompom, Quillson, Derwin, Ketchup, and Bill. I wanna see what is so special about Bill.
Worst is Gloria.

 

[nordskjev]

In my opinion - Gloria is best, I think she's pretty!
Worst is Scoot. I had him in ACNL and I wanted to get rid of him. It took him so long to move out of my town lol

 

[JemAC]

Molly is my favourite duck, she's really cute and while the normal personality isn't the most interesting I think it suits her and makes her even more loveable. I'm not usually a big fan of jocks but I do like Bill and I also think Drake is quite sweet as well for a lazy villager.

For me the worst ducks are Freckles, Quillson and Scoot, I've always wanted to like Freckles but I think her design is a little odd, same with Quillson, not sure whether it's the hair or if their colourings are a bit off. Also I'm not very keen on villagers who have default hats with their outfits as I never feel like I get a good enough idea on what the villager is like with them which puts me off Scoot.

 

[Snek]

BEST: Drake, Molly, and Bill

Drake was in my NL town and first duck villager. I really like his mallard duck theme.
Molly's design is very cute. I've never had her but hopefully one day.
Bill was also in my NL town at one point. He moved out when I was away from the game for awhile and I was pretty sad over it. Like the other two, his design is very well done.

WORST: Pate and Quillson

Oh the NL memories. I'm so glad villager move outs are easier this game. Bad history and terrible design for a peppy.

Quillson is...just bad. Bad overall design

 

[moonlights]

Best: Molly - she's the only duck I've had, although I invited Ketchup a few days ago so my opinion may change! Both I think are really cute, Molly is easily one of the cutest villagers in AC imo.

Worst: Quillson? I don't really have a problem with any of the other ducks, but judging off appearance, his is awful. I think it goes well with the fact he's a smug, but that makes me dislike him even more.

 

[VanitasFan26]

100% Molly is my favorite Duck of all time. She's a normal villager and really cute

Least favorite is Quillson he just doesn't look that appealing.

 

[Marshmallows]

Molly and Ketchup are the best.

Worst.... I don't strongly dislike any of them. Maybe Gloria, but she's unique, or Quillson. I actually wasn't familiar with Deena, Weber, or Mallary.

 

[WaileaNoRei]

I chose freckles, though I have not had her on my island yet, I just find her so so adorable, with her freckles and her crazy eyes

but I like a lot of the ducks:

I also find Pate really cute with her weird eyebrows and the bonus of her beautiful house exterior.

love Deena and Weber, though I wish their houses were not music rooms (I like houses that look like houses and Weber’s kind of just looks like someone filled it with as many instruments as would fit )

Drake is a villager I have recently come to like more, and all the snooty ducks are also cute and fun in their own ways, especially Miranda.

I like scoot, primarily as a potential sidekick/ buddy for Stinky, one of my favorite villagers.

I don’t think any of the ducks are terrible. I guess Derwin and ketchup are two I donMt have interest in having on my island. I thought I would really love Derwin, with his glasses and freckles but when I saw him in game I just didn’t like his look as much as expected. Ketchup is very cute, but I am not big on food villagers, plus I hate ketchup irl (yuck), so the name is a turn off. Quillson I would also like to like, but something about him turns me off a bit, if I am honest.

i don’t think any of them are the worst though. The ducks are cuties

 

[oranje]

I think my favorites are Bill, followed by Drake as a close second. I love their natural designs and that Drake reminds me of Daffy Duck. Bill has such a beautiful chocolate color!

I think my least favorites are Joey and Scoot. Joey looks like he's wearing a diaper and Scoot's swimming hat is ugly. Not a fan of either look.

 

[Etown20]

Molly and Ketchup are both great as others have mentioned, but I also want to give some love to Mallary and Pate who I think are underrated.

 

[bebebese]

Had Maelle and Miranda in different towns across different titles so I've gotta give a shoutout to my favourite snooty girls.

 

[ayeeprill]

i quite like Weber for some reason.

Maelle is a sweetie too.

 

[azurill]

I love the duck villagers. Joey is the best and I was so excited when he showed up at my campsite. Tied with Joey are Molly and Ketchup. I also have Ketchup on my island and will try to get Molly next time someone moves out.

 

[Nunnafinga]

I have a dozen duckies on my islands so I think it's safe to say that I like pretty much all of them.Joey is my favorite because I've had him the longest(in both New Horizons and new Leaf).I can see why Quillson is the worst to a lot of people being that he's a peculiar shade of green and looks like he's perpetually stoned but he's a smug so I like him no matter what.As for Scoot,I know his headwear looks like a pair of tidy whities,a volleyball cut in half or a strange jockstrap but it's actually a scooter helmet because his theme is that of a scooter rider.His catchphrase is "zip zoom" and of course,his name is Scoot.I wish he would the the dang thing off sometimes though.He wears other hats on top of his helmet and it just looks weird.

 

[Moonlight.]

honestly my favorite is scoot because of vinesauce, plus i love his shade of green

only one i don't like is quillson, his smug aura mocks me

 

[LadyDestani]

I love Scoot! I see a lot of people don't like him and I can understand that. I probably wouldn't have picked him out of all the ducks either, but he moved into my New Leaf town randomly and completely won me over. I tend to like the villagers who are very expressive and Scoot blew me away with his adorable expressions.

 

[toenuki]

scoot is the best, derwin the NERD is the worst

 

[JessieOfSeacowBay]

One problem for me is I largely don't like villagers with hair and almost all of the ducks have hair. Fortunately, Molly is super cute and doesn't have hair.