What’s your favorite new Halloween collectible?

[You got mail!]

Of course there must be a thread for this haha they’re all sooo amazing but I especially love the old gameboy, Zipper T Balloon and the Crow Plush! Didn’t include the cursed lantern since you can’t buy it :p

 

[-Apples-]

Cotton candy always gets my win (unless if a hot dog or corn dog is in)

 

[oak]

Definitely the crow plush even though he's a little hard to see. That's okay though, I still love him

 

[himekirako]

hehe voted for pink cotton candy and booton mushroom!

 

[Oblivia]

I think the Ghastly Lantern is stunning and I also love the little Booton Shroom.

 

[LadyDestani]

I think the Ghastly Lantern is stunning and I also love the little Booton Shroom.

Same! Those were the two that got my votes. I love that all the community love for Booton was rewarded and he became a proper collectible.

 

[Nefarious]

Surely no one will ever guess which of the new collectibles is my favorite..

The Ghastly Lantern and Old Gameboy are super neat too!

 

[Roxxy]

Ghastly lantern is such a beautiful purple

 

[Xara]

Booton my BABY!!! he is definitely my favourite, and the collectible I'm most excited about!! I was so sad when I thought he was just a temporary collectible for mushroom season, so I'm so, so delighted that he's back; and permanently this time!! a full row of Bootons can finally be a reality.. everyone say thank you Mistreil
permanent badger shroom when....

I also love the ghastly lantern and the crow plush!! the lantern is so pretty, and I've been hoping we'd get some more bird plushies eventually, so I'm really excited about the crow!!

 

[Dunquixote]

My favorites are in this order: the old gameboy, crow, ghastly lantern, booton.

Old Gameboy: I just the gaming collectibles so much and the background; also the nostalgia!

The crow: I’m hoping to eventually make a lineup that is kinda P5 theme and I think this would be perfect because of Crow! I think it is adorable too; I could use more plushie collectibles.

Ghastly lantern: I love the colors & design and the background too.

Booton: I really love how one of the foraged mushrooms became an actual collectible. Booton was one of my favorites .

I honestly like them all! I’m tempted by the cotton candy because it makes me think of Chopper from One Piece. The cupcake (both the new and old one) tempt me too since the food collectibles are really cute and I don’t have any yet. The Zipper Bunny Balloon because it makes me think of the cursed Zipper images that always make me laugh.

 

[Suguri]

It's a tie between the booton mushroom and the pink cotton candy. I want to eat the cotton candy, and I'm glad one of the foraged mushrooms returned as a collectible!

 

[Yoshi155]

I think the best one is the Crow Plush! I love the plush collectibles and this one is no exception! It looks really cute!

 

[daisyflowers]

-

 

[Captain Jigglypuff]

Definitely the Ghastly Lantern and Old Gameboy.

 

[Briar]

My top three are the Old Gameboy, Crow Plush, and Edgourd! I have the other pumpkin collectibles, and I was hoping we'd get a new one this time, so I have to get Edgourd. I love crows, and I like the plush collectibles in general, so the Crow Plush is another must have for me. And for the Gameboy, I had a Gameboy when I was younger, and having console collectibles seems fun.

My full ranking would probably be:
Crow Plush > Old Gameboy > Edgourd > Ghastly Lanten > Pink Cotton Candy > Booton Mushroom > Zipper T. Balloon > Half-Eaten Cupcake

 

[Aerith]

The Crow Plush and Edgourd have my heart. Super excited for more birb and one pumpkin closer to having a full line-up

It's an S tier set of collectibles this year though, they're all fantastic (minus Zipper).

 

[Mistreil]

i'm glad you guys like the collectibles! i will give you some lore in exchange:

Spoiler: mistreil wth is with the disjointed collectible theming

since the carnival being reused had the concept of "gather[ing] leftover decorations and reuse them", i thought it'd be cute to make halloween-y collectibles related to events that happened this year! like repainting the LNY lantern, drawing zipper on a bunny balloon, and... idk an old gameboy seemed like a good choice for tbtwc.
booton is obvious

and a half-eaten cupcake seemed very sensical for this too. i also just think it's very funny, and so i subject you all to this.

i am partial towards the half-eaten cupcake, zipper balloon and.... everything else. lantern.

View attachment 591454

quite literally, yes! when we were playing hide and seek and you guys mentioned booton i was just sat there like (‾◡◝)

 

[MrBox]

Zipper T Balloon- hands down

 

[Yanrima~]

Mine ties between Zipper T. Balloon and Old Gameboy. In which the Old Gameboy goes perfectly together with the glitched Easter egg.
(Missingno collectible when?)

 

[Muna]

My favourite are Booton and Ghastly Lantern!