• TBT's 2026 New Year's Party has started! Join us from now until January 11th in eight fun New Year's activities. Earn currency to spend on collectibles and raffle tickets. Get started in The Bulletin Board event thread. Happy New Year!

What is your favorite Halloween candy?

DaCoSim

🩵#1 Filbert Fan🩵
Joined
Sep 3, 2013
Posts
11,771
Bells
188
Countdown Coins
0
Lucky Tickets
0
Holiday Candy Cane 2025
Holiday Candy Cane 2024
Holiday Candy Cane 2023
Holiday Candy Cane 2022
Holiday Candy Cane 2021
Holiday Candy Cane 2020
Holiday Candy Cane 2019
Holiday Candy Cane 2018
Holiday Candy Cane 2017
Holiday Candy Cane 2016
Baby Ruth’s were always my fav to get in my bag. And cherry tootsie pops!
 
Chocolate

Basically I don't like taffy or gummies. But chewy candy is fine like Skittles or Tootsie rolls.
 
Molasse candies and caramels but it's not something I would get in my bag. I liked gummies too.
 
In terms of trick-or-treating candy, as long as my treats weren't opened or tampered with in any way, I didn't really care what I got! I have a lot of chocolates and candies that I like, so I always got treats I liked more than treats I didn't!

I was always especially happy whenever I got original skittles, rockets (smarties in the US) and hershey's cookies 'n' creme bars, though! The occasional bags of chips were also a nice break from all the sweetness, and I'd never complain about getting a rice krispie square or a bag of fruit snacks! The very rare times I got a full-sized candy were great as well!!
 
Reese's 🧡 And most other chocolate, but Reese's has always been my number one fave and makes me think of Halloween a lot of the time
 
As a vegetarian, I’m happy with anything without gelatin 😂 I remember when I used to trick or treat, I could only end up eating about a third of what I was given
 
Even as a kid I was always picky about chocolates or weird, chocolate-like candies. For example, I avoided Tootsie Rolls and Whoppers. And I also never liked anything with nuts or coconut. I traded those away to my little cousins for stuff I do like, such as Reese's cups, Sour Patch and Dum Dum lollipops.

I love taffy, gummies, Skittles, Starburst, and the occasional Smarties 😋 I was crazy about Fun Dip and pixie stix. But my all-time faves were the Hubba Bubba sour goo lol
 
anything sour, really, but sour patch kids for sure. the tiny three musketeers are my 2nd fav.
 
I always go for either Reese's (the pumpkin ones if I can!) or Sour Patch Kids.
Nothing else will ever beat them.
 
i look forward to the reese's shapes (pumpkins and bats) coming back every halloween. something about the ratio of peanut butter to chocolate is so yummy! it's so much better than the og reese's cups
 
Back
Top