Thinking of replacing Audie.. What cat should i choose?

[spawnpoint]

Just like the first time I got Audie I'm really not feeling any sort of attachment to her at all so I'm probably just gonna sell her. I'm planning on replacing her with a cat. Problem is I just can't decide which one. My villagee list is in my sig for reference (except Tangy is Audie, just didn't update it) Here's my reasoning for each down below:

Kiki: She was a starter in nh and she grew on me a lot. One of my favorite female villagers now. I have her in my second town currently so if she gets chosen I can easily bring her back over to the main one. I could also fit her in my garden/cafe area somewhere maybe.

Kid Cat: Saw some fan art of him and Lolly being siblings and honestly it's just so cute ;^; I also had him in an old nl town and I loved him there so much. I honestly don't know where he would fit in my town though..

Kabuki: Bought him from a lovely user here for 1 mil igb and he's currently in my 2nd town. I really want to bring him over to my main one but that would mean 3 crankies and 3 smugs so idk.. I do love both of those personalities tho. Also had Kabuki in an old nl town so.i have nostalgia for him too. He could easily fit in my main area with Snake.

Bob: I had him in an old nl town so nostalgia. Saw some cute videos of him which made me miss him and he could easily fit in the park area with Sherb.

So which one should I choose? Help..

 

[Uffe]

Go for Kiki. I like how her eyes stand out.

 

[Xara]

i vote for kid cat! he’s on my island rn and he’s adorable

 

[Arckaniel]

I'd go with Kiki!
Kiki because I'm more biased towards her lol as she was part of my original dreamie line up for NH (was replaced with Lolly tho as she was a random move in and unexpectedly fell in love with her, I would also have Kiki in my town but that would mean 3 normal [as I am planning on having Lily as well] so unfortunately decided not to have Kiki in the final line up for my island) plus for gender variety sake as I am noticing you have more male ones than females, and she was originally your starter anyways so that'll be cool to bring her back to where she truly belong...

 

[moon_child]

Kiki because I don’t see her often in island tours so I think she’s a refreshing sight to see.

 

[TaylaJade]

Kiki is so underrated! Wish I could make room for her on my island. But you're right, Bob and Sherb would get on well together (I would also recommend Punchy if you haven't considered him)

 

[Sweetley]

I voted for Kiki. She's cute and I think she would make a good replacement for Audie.

 

[icecreamcheese]

1. based on what u wrote + personal taste i would choose bob
2.based on what u wrote only - kiki/bob

i dont like kiki so much she feels abit boring for my taste also my friend had her in his island and he really didnt like her.
kabuki is great but u have too much cranky as u said
kid cat is really cool but u dont think u can fit him in.
bob is really cool and cute so i voted for him.

 

[Rosch]

I'd go with Bob/Kiki because, as you've said, they both fit thematically in your island. But I am more biased towards Bob.

 

[Magus]

Kiki and Kabuki are my favorite cats ☺
Concerning your choice I think you should go for Kiki. You already have a lot of males and crankies so Kiki would be refreshing for your island.

 

[Dewasa]

"Kiki do you love me?"

 

[daisyy]

bob is probably my favorite cat out of the bunch but i think kiki would be a great replacement for audie as well.
(also how can you replace audie kidding!)

 

[greenvoldemort]

kiki is gorgeous i would love to have her, and she would make a great edition to your island!

 

[Ananas Dragon]

Just like the first time I got Audie I'm really not feeling any sort of attachment to her at all so I'm probably just gonna sell her. I'm planning on replacing her with a cat. Problem is I just can't decide which one. My villagee list is in my sig for reference (except Tangy is Audie, just didn't update it) Here's my reasoning for each down below:

Kiki: She was a starter in nh and she grew on me a lot. One of my favorite female villagers now. I have her in my second town currently so if she gets chosen I can easily bring her back over to the main one. I could also fit her in my garden/cafe area somewhere maybe.

Kid Cat: Saw some fan art of him and Lolly being siblings and honestly it's just so cute ;^; I also had him in an old nl town and I loved him there so much. I honestly don't know where he would fit in my town though..

Kabuki: Bought him from a lovely user here for 1 mil igb and he's currently in my 2nd town. I really want to bring him over to my main one but that would mean 3 crankies and 3 smugs so idk.. I do love both of those personalities tho. Also had Kabuki in an old nl town so.i have nostalgia for him too. He could easily fit in my main area with Snake.

Bob: I had him in an old nl town so nostalgia. Saw some cute videos of him which made me miss him and he could easily fit in the park area with Sherb.

So which one should I choose? Help..

Bob bob bob bob bob bob bob bob bob

did i mention bob?

 

[Blueskyy]

Kiki is my favorite out of those. The reason I like her because if she is outside at night, her round green eyes glow at night.

 

[Aliya]

Kiki is so adorable! I absolutely love her.

 

[Romaki]

I think Bob is the best, but all cat villagers are fantastic.

 

[thatveryawkwardmayor]

Kiki because shes forever bae im sorry i just love her so much ;-:

 

[Alicia]

I'd say Kiki, she's adorable. I really like Kabuki too.
Had him in new leaf, might try to have him on my island at some point.

 

[Mayor Moon]

"Kiki do you love me?"

please refrain