-Apples-
Apple Imperialist
Don’t know if it counts as an unpopular opinion, but I kinda feel that the newer Pokémon species feel less like Pokémon and more like a new rivaling franchise that is trying to be as popular as Pokémon is. While I do acknowledge that every official Pokémon is a real Pokémon, but it feels very different in later generations.
In terms of how much a generation feels like Pokémon, Gen I is 100%, Gen II is 90%, Gen III is 80%, Gen IV is 65%, Gen V is 50%, Gen VI is 35%, Gen VII is 20%, and Gen VIII is merely 10%.
Also an unpopular opinion outside the genwunner circle, I can also see how uncreative some of the designs are. Even the earlier Pokémon based on inanimate objects, including Klinklang, Vanilluxe, and Garbodor, were done right. But starting 6th Generation, creativity becomes a problem. Pokémon based on inanimate objects are literally inanimate objects (key rings, flower wreaths, apples), while Pokémon based on animals are starting to become more like real animals than Pokémon. I can see why there are fewer new species every generation. Granted, there are a couple of species from Gen VI and later that are either creative, or feels like Pokémon (but not both), but there’s enough to prove this point.
In terms of how much a generation feels like Pokémon, Gen I is 100%, Gen II is 90%, Gen III is 80%, Gen IV is 65%, Gen V is 50%, Gen VI is 35%, Gen VII is 20%, and Gen VIII is merely 10%.
Also an unpopular opinion outside the genwunner circle, I can also see how uncreative some of the designs are. Even the earlier Pokémon based on inanimate objects, including Klinklang, Vanilluxe, and Garbodor, were done right. But starting 6th Generation, creativity becomes a problem. Pokémon based on inanimate objects are literally inanimate objects (key rings, flower wreaths, apples), while Pokémon based on animals are starting to become more like real animals than Pokémon. I can see why there are fewer new species every generation. Granted, there are a couple of species from Gen VI and later that are either creative, or feels like Pokémon (but not both), but there’s enough to prove this point.