The official Animal Crossing: New Horizons guide revealed the relationship between Flick and C.J.

I understand what you're saying here, but I just briefly want to push back slightly. I've brought up the idea several times in this thread that it's possible the word "partner" was chosen intentionally by a queer person or people on the NOA localization team (I've also already stated this being true wouldn't negate the nature of the queerbaiting in the dialogue, so I won't get into that again).

The reason that I float that possiblity, though, is because I know queer people who work at Nintendo. I don't think any of them work in localization, but the reason I bring that up is simply because...queer people work at Nintendo. Do I know for sure that there are queer people on the NOA localization team? No, I don't (and even if I did, I can only guess at their motivations for their work). But I'd say it's at least fairly likely, statistically speaking, that there's at least some queer presence on the localization team (as I've pointed out in past posts here, other queer vernacular that made it into NH seems to indicate this). My only point here is that it's certainly not impossible for there to be multiple reasons for this particular language choice, and I certainly don't think it's far-fetched to ponder whether the choice itself was made by a queer person, for whatever reason. Queer people? In my Nintendo franchise? It's more likely than you think!

Respectfully, I am also a writer, as well as a narrative designer, and I don't really know that I'd go so far as to say the word "partner" fits CJ's personality necessarily? It's the job of a good writer/narrative designer/localizer to take into account not just what feels "real" but also precisely what you said -- how the audience will interpret the dialogue you write. If the player can't interpret your dialogue or if they're given too much room to interpret when you don't want them to, well...you probably need to rewrite or risk that they won't get very far in the game, which is why game writers/narrative designers need to be very precise in their language choices. This may just be a creative/vernacular difference, but if I were writing a character for a game who's supposed to be a young, cool streamer in the year 2020, if I meant "friend" I'd probably use "friend", or "buddy", or "bud". If I meant business partner I'd say business partner. If I meant roommate I'd say roommate. But I'd only make those choices if I didn't want to invite interpretation of the word "partner", knowing as I do that it has many potential connotations depending on who's reading it, and I want to be as precise as possible.

Since I'm now on my phone and don't wish for this to be drawn on more when we simply won't change our minds,

I again don't say it's impossible. To me, personally, saying what you're saying is giving someone out there credit for word choice that I myself might have considered with no indication or thought for the fanbase.

I don't write in English so that may be why that is the case, but I really just don't see it that way and there's not much that will change it for me, and I don't intend to try and take that thought from you.

I'm glad we could have a structured discussion though! Thank you for your points, even if it didn't change my mind.

Hope to see you around on less heated topics. )
 
I did not expect people to make this topic such a heated question. All I can say is that neither side is wrong nor right, because it is pretty subtle and therefore there's definitely space for some own character stories.

I personally never saw them as partners simply because they seem so young in my eyes, but if someone does I don't mind it. Animal Crossing leaves a lot to the player's own imagination.

Edit: I also want to mention that Nintendo has had gay options in their games recently. For example Fire Emblem: Three Houses has option to form same sex relationships and they even increased the amount of gay partners in the previous DLC.
 
EWE08MQVcAMZjSe
people keep saying "kEeP rElAtIoNsHiPs OuT oF a KiDs GaMe" like theres literally going to be a wedding event lmao if we want flick and cj to be boyfriends we can think of them as boyfriends
 
Back
Top