Mafia The Franchise Wars- Town & TP Win!

[Seroja]

also @zendel if i remember correctly i didn't address the ayaya issue at all mainly because i didn't really have a stance on it so meh seroja just replaced in i dont think her not addressing it is weird

^^^^^

 

[KermitTea]

okay got it..and one more question if you dont mind..when Dolby died, why didnt Kat die too? I thought Kat said she is third party....am i missing something here or is Kat not really third party? or she has different role..maybe I should ask Kat..

as I said earlier, if Dolby dies from any other means, Kat's role becomes a survivor, meaning that she wins if she survives till endgame.

tldr: she was unlyncher and her goal was to lynch Dolby, now that Dolby died through other means, her role turned into survivor, so she just has to survive till endgame

 

[moonford]

Also it doesn't matter if it's been beaten to death, at least I posted my thoughts right? That's what you asked for.

- - - Post Merge - - -

^^^^^

Already responded to it.

 

[Kirbystarship]

bianca asking all these Newbie questions makes me think they are town still.

 

[KermitTea]

True, but you didn't feel uncomfortable around Cleb right? I mean what had Cleb posted up until that point would make you feel wary? He pressured Ayaya (main thing he did, bless him), role played as that pervert Jared and made general convo. Nothing scummy or anything that would make me feel uncomfortable nor should it have made anyone wary of him. His behaviour was townie af and he flipped green soo.

i was wary of cleb only because kat and dolby were confirmed nonmaf and it would be weird if none of those 3 players were maf but eh guess the roles were actually random

- - - Post Merge - - -

but yes his behavior was fine

wary only because of supposed game balance

 

[moonford]

bianca asking all these Newbie questions makes me think they are town still.

Yeah, if she were scum she would be coached and directed in the scum chat most likely.

This is her first game that wasn't a role play type of mafia game.

 

[Seroja]

Also it doesn't matter if it's been beaten to death, at least I posted my thoughts right? That's what you asked for.

- - - Post Merge - - -



Already responded to it.

Saw it. Also I like your responses so far so you're on null now. Yeah I appreciate it nonetheless, thanks Zendel.

 

[moonford]

i was wary of cleb only because kat and dolby were confirmed nonmaf and it would be weird if none of those 3 players were maf but eh guess the roles were actually random

- - - Post Merge - - -

but yes his behavior was fine

wary only because of supposed game balance

Hence why you aren't on the same boat as Seroja to me.

 

[N e s s]

Soo are you going to scum read Evan now because he still thinks Kit and Seroja are scummy?

It's not like somebody hasn't claimed as an investigation role to clear their partner before, right?

That was before Kit said she was JoaT and not the cop. The fact that you called an (at the time) uncounter claimed investigative role scum pinged me as scummy.

I saw amazonevan19's reads post, but considering I'm heavily townleaning him he's not in the same boat as you. It is possible that Kit and Seroja are scum together, but the idea of it doesn't fit into how Kit plays as scum. I KNOW how kit plays as scum, when she's scum she stays under the radar, not make a daring play such a claim investigative to "save" her scum partner. The very idea of claiming JoaT to save a partner is a dumb play that would only confirm both players as scum if one died.

 

[moonford]

That was before Kit said she was JoaT and not the cop. The fact that you called an (at the time) uncounter claimed investigative role scum pinged me as scummy.

I saw amazonevan19's reads post, but considering I'm heavily townleaning him he's not in the same boat as you. It is possible that Kit and Seroja are scum together, but the idea of it doesn't fit into how Kit plays as scum. I KNOW how kit plays as scum, when she's scum she stays under the radar, not make a daring play such a claim investigative to "save" her scum partner. The very idea of claiming JoaT to save a partner is a dumb play that would only confirm both players as scum if one died.

I've never played with Kit before and she claimed JoaT after I posted that (I thought she was cop so your last sentence didn't apply at the time), I was keeping an open mind because Seroja is my top scum lean right now and like you said it is a possibility so that's why I even said that in the first place.

We should be looking at all the possibilities especially if an unexpected result like that came out.

 

[Seroja]

FireNinja, if you are what you claim you are, please write a reads list or something.

Btw guys, if we mislynch today, it's very dangerous. Scum seems to have a lot of KP.

 

[N e s s]

And before you straw man me by saying "doesn't mean Seroja isn't GF!" Then you should understand that I still haven't cleared Seroja. She is still suspicious to me.

 

[Kirbystarship]

This thread is moving very quickly.

If we have a vig, I feel like 5 blue roles would be a lot. Cop, joat, vig, doc, and vet for a 15 player game.

 

[Seroja]

This thread is moving very quickly.

If we have a vig, I feel like 5 blue roles would be a lot. Cop, joat, vig, doc, and vet for a 15 player game.

you'd be surprised actually.

 

[moonford]

And before you straw man me by saying "doesn't mean Seroja isn't GF!" Then you should understand that I still haven't cleared Seroja. She is still suspicious to me.

I've mentioned that before you've even mentioned this and so have a few others.

- - - Post Merge - - -

What is FireNinja's experience on mafia?

- - - Post Merge - - -

Why has everyone went quiet? I'm scared, everybody okay? Has something crazy happened on the news? Has Godzilla attacked? Idk....

 

[Kirbystarship]

I think mafia has 2kp and strongman counts as a kill but not part of Kp, so 3 kills. Strongarm on Dolby kill Cleb and Kermittea. 3 kills if Strongarm goes through both lives.

 

[moonford]

I think mafia has 2kp and strongman counts as a kill but not part of Kp, so 3 kills. Strongarm on Dolby kill Cleb and Kermittea. 3 kills if Strongarm goes through both lives.

In the Steven Universe game, Strong Man was an additional kill.

 

[amazonevan19]

Why has everyone went quiet? I'm scared, everybody okay? Has something crazy happened on the news? Has Godzilla attacked? Idk....

I'm writing a longish post, don't worry I'm here

 

[Kirbystarship]

In the Steven Universe game, Strong Man was an additional kill.

I think there will be less kills on Night 2.

 

[f11]

lol I don't trusts Karen's save that much but I'll save that for later. Fun is an instalynch though.