The Best (and worst) bird villagers and why? 🐦

Best villager?

  • Anchovy

    Votes: 11 11.7%
  • Admiral

    Votes: 3 3.2%
  • Jacques

    Votes: 15 16.0%
  • Jay

    Votes: 12 12.8%
  • Midge

    Votes: 30 31.9%
  • Jacob

    Votes: 7 7.4%
  • Piper

    Votes: 26 27.7%
  • Sparro

    Votes: 9 9.6%
  • Peck

    Votes: 5 5.3%
  • Twiggy

    Votes: 16 17.0%
  • Robin

    Votes: 15 16.0%
  • Jitters

    Votes: 5 5.3%
  • Lucha

    Votes: 3 3.2%

  • Total voters
    94

Wolfieocelot

Member
Joined
Oct 14, 2020
Posts
38
Bells
283
Sautéed Mushrooms
0
Spores
0
Ok, so this thread is a little different from my other threads. This thread will still have a poll, but only for your favorite villager. You can now share your least favorite villager as well 🙃

DISCLAIMER: Birds are different from eagles, penguins, ducks, and ostriches. Pls dont get confused

BEST: Piper. She looks really cool and reminds me of daisy duck. Not to mention she has my favorite personality, peppy.

WORST: Anchovy. Probably because he wants to look derpy, but he kinda took it too far...
 
Best: Midge. She looks really cute and so is her house.

Worst: Lucha. I detest lucha, and his silly little mask with his beady little eyes. Everyday I beg the animal crossing god of rng to keep him away from me and my villagers, I will NOT sit here and wait for him to burn down my house and eat my crops.
 
I voted for Peck because I've always thought he looked really cool. Piper would be a close second, though.

I don't really have a least favorite. I think all of them are cute in their own way.
 
I love Piper sooo much. I had both her and Robin in the Gamecube game, so there's some nostalgia there, but I just think their designs are fantastic. I also love how Piper has a bit of a gothic vibe, but is a Peppy despite that. Hoping to move her on my island some day.

I don't really have a least favorite truthfully. Maybe Jacob or Midge? I don't dislike them though.
 
Jacques came to my island from the void and I thought I'd move him out right away but then I loved him and kept him until I received his photo. He's got a great design and his house is cool, like a DJ's place. Piper has the cityscape wall in her house and is a nice combo of peppy enthusiasm and coolness.
 
I like Midge, Piper, and Jay best! Midge is adorable, Piper is classy, and Jay is just a classic villager.

Worst is a tossup between Twiggy and Jitters. Twiggy annoyed me in Wild World and Jitters is just...ugh.
 
Absolute best is Twiggy. 💕 She was my first peppy and she's still on my island... I love her coloring and her personality is completely opposite her angry face. Midge is pretty cute, too.

Worst.... maybe Lucha or Jacob.
 
Lucha was actually the first smug I found imitating/making fun of snooty villagers, so he's good in my books.

Worst...easily Jacob...he lives in a garbage dump.
 
Anchovy! I feel like he's the type of bird who would have a super impressive record collection.
 
my vote went to midge! i might be a bit biased as the normal villagers are my favourite aha but she’s such a pretty gal and i like her a lot! piper is also pretty great, too; she was my starter peppy and she was really nice to have around!

anchovy, robin and jay are the worst birds by far - no idea what my problem is but they honestly irk me so bad lmao. 🥴
 
best is my boy jacques, he is so groovy ♡

worst is lucha, but only because he is not a jock, why is he smug?????
 
Midge and Piper are cute. Jay is okay. Jitters...uhhh...Jitters looks like HE’S SEEN THINGS. Bad things. Very very bad things.
 
I absolutely adore Anchovy and Piper a lot, mainly because of their design.

As for the rest of the birds, I don't care for them that much, there are overall fine/acceptable.
 
Robin is my favourite bird, her design uses both my favourite colour and favourite personality (blue and snooty) and I really like robins in general so I'm often drawn to her when it comes to the bird villagers (though her design doesn't overly resemble a robin but she has the right name). I did also vote for Midge and Admiral too as I think Midge has a very pretty design and Admiral always reminds me a little bit of a character from a film I watched a lot when I was young, Chicken Run, obviously he's a bird and not a chicken but there was an old cranky chicken in the film that I always think of when I see Admiral - if they ever did a sequel called Bird Run then he'd be a great character for it.

My least favourite is Peck, I'd never realised how much I disliked him until I ran into him while island hopping recently and he freaked me out, his eyes are just too creepy for me.
 
My favorites are anchovy and sparro. I am not generally a fan of the birds, but these are two I would consider inviting to my island. I dinner have any deep reason, just think they are very cute.

least favorite is Jacques, I generally don’t like the animals that have the soul patch/ goatee because i associate it with a specific unpleasant personality, and Jacques’ design especially just rubs me the wrong way.
 
AAtbzwQ (1).jpg

Jitters is my favorite bird.He popped up in one of old New Leaf cycling towns and I really liked his color scheme and although he's a jock he was on the milder side of that personality.
 
Jacques is my favorite bird, hands down. He has a great design (smug is a great personality for him since he looks like an struggling artist type), and a great interior (DJ themed). I also really like Piper and Sparro for their more natural looking designs. I think a lot of the birds are very cute and I wish more people gave them a chance.

I think the only design I don't like is Jacob's just because I have no idea what's going on there. Why those clashing colors? Why the teeny eyes? Why the very long eyebrows? It's a bit of a mess.
 
They are all best birbs. All birbs are good birbs.
Picking Twiggy as best of the best, for being the closest to a 'tiel and also sharing my birthday.
 
Back
Top