Smug Villager Tier List
- Thread starter ayeeprill
- Start date
spawnpoint
IT'S TV TIME!
O'Hare in d tier? This is a disgrace jk, kinda
S & A tiers are villager that i think look cool and fit with my island's theme. Henry has always been my dream smug because he is small, a frog, and cute. i thought Colton looked cool but it wasn't until i saw a comic of him that my opinion of him changed for the better. i will only consider settling with S tier villagers, though.
B tier contain villagers i like the design of, but don't really fit in with my island theme. C tier contain villagers that im kinda meh about; theyre interesting to look at but i think i'd get bored of them quickly.
D tier villagers don't fit with my island theme and i would only keep them for their picture then i'd quickly get rid of them.
Aromatisse
(๑˘︶˘๑)
That was easy. Marshal <3.
spawnpoint
IT'S TV TIME!
Why is O'Hare in no
Minimasher
Senior Member
spawnpoint
IT'S TV TIME!
patchworkbunny
Senior Member
I thought there were more nice smugs until I did this, but I kinda understand why everyone is after the same few now.
My smug list!
...To be honest, I don't think any of these are all that unique
I'm not the type to like things just 'cause they're popular, but I with the smug villagers, I really do see the appeal in the most popular ones and I have to agree!
Halloqueen
Just a dreamer who dreams of better days.
More or less in order, with those on the left being the favorites of the tier they're in and going in descending order as the lines progress to the right.
S Tier: Pietro has one of my absolute favorite designs in the series, I love Hans' abominable snowman/yeti coloration, and Jacques has the best design of all of the Bird species villagers as far as I'm concerned.
A Tier: I really love this bunch too, just a little less. This is less stable in the order; I feel like Leopold, Lionel, Beardo, and Chops could move around, depending on the day.
B Tier: A mix of good and so-so. Klaus, Kyle, Hippeux, Shep, Keaton, Lopez, Tex, and Raymond are some that I like just a little bit less than those in A tier. Ken and O'Hare got into B because I like them just a tiny bit more than those in C.
C Tier: Colton and Ed are all right, the rest are fairly forgettable.
D Tier: Save for Marshal being the first in ranking in this tier, I feel like everyone else in this tier can swap around. They're all fairly bland to me.
paleogamer11
Senior Member
Here is my tier list. I like most smug villagers and I will give an explanation for each tier:
S- Eugene is my smug dream villager; I like how cool he looks. Hans is the best gorilla, and I like his yeti basis. Henry, Kyle, Lopez, Tex, and Zell all resemble real-life animals (an American bullfrog, an African wild dog, a Thomson's gazelle, and African penguin, and a blackbuck or oryx respectively) which helps them stand out, which I love. Jacques is my favorite bird villager, and I like his beanie and French-based origin. Ken is a cool ninja chicken, and I like how his name can involve his species. Lucha is a wrestler/luchador, and he reminds me of Hawlucha, one of my favorite Pokemon. And finally, O'Hare is excellent. I picture him as an Irish bunny tourist, with his stereotypical tourist shirt and reddish-orange tuft of hair on his head.
A- Chadder is a good example of the smug personality, with his tuxedo. I also like his cheese theme, though to me, he look a little mischievous. Colton is a good-looking horse and I like his house interior. Curlos is underrated, and I like his name pun, which suits him. Graham is adorable; I like his glasses and he was the first hamster that I got to know of. Julian stands out because he resembles a unicorn, though I find his eyes a bit problematic. Keaton is colorful and unique (to me he resembles a blue and yellow macaw). Kidd is cool-looking, Lionel is a good lion that looks like a wise gentleman, Marshal is cute and a parody video helped me like him (he's extremely popular, which makes me a bit biased towards. In addition, I think there are better squirrels in my opinion.), Olaf is interesting and I found him on a mystery island, and though he seems to be a knockoff (he looks like a matador to me), I like how he has legwear, Phil resembles a pheasant, which makes him stand out, though he's an ostrich, which have a different morphology than pheasants, Pietro is colorful and funny-looking, though he can creepy to others, Quillson is underrated and I really like how he stands out (he looks a bit ugly, but in a good way), Raymond is a cool business cat that I'd like more if he weren't extremely popular, and I like Shep's basis, though I do wish that I could see what his eyes look like.
B- Both Huck and Leopold are fine in my opinion. Huck looks a bit strange and I wish Leopold never had the jock personality (I think there need to be more non-jock lions), but I will appreciate both of them for being smug villagers that appeared before New Leaf (the game that introduced the personality).
C- Beardo is a lit problematic, but I will appreciate him for having his species in his name and resembling a gentleman, Ed's eyes are problematic, and before becoming smug, he was a jock which I do not think made any sense for him (lazy would have been a better placeholder personality), and Hippeux is strange. He has hair on his head that I don't think makes him good, and his skin color doesn't help him. Also, the fact that his real name isn't that but something else (Gary is his real name, this is confirmed in PC) makes him almost bad enough for me to dislike. The good things about him are that the name he goes by has an "x" in it, the fact that he both has an uncommon personality and an uncommon species, and that he is currently the only hippo to be introduced after the Japanese-exclusive Dobutsu no Mori e+. In short, he almost made it to D tier, which consist of the villagers I dislike.
D- Chops is arrogant and ugly. I was forced to have him on my island and it took me so long to kick him out. Klaus I wouldn't have disliked if not for how creepy he may be. Though his origin is a good one, his permanent angry/depressed face doesn't help him at all. And Rodney is a short and ugly mess. The tuft of pink hair on him contrasts greatly with his blue fur, his tired eyes don't look great, and he doesn't look gentleman-like at all aside from his catchphrase. He is easily the worst smug villager and one of, if not, the worst villagers ever created.
Last edited:
sleepydreepy
legendary egg
