Serious question: Dom or Sherb? Why?

[saucySheep]

er-uhm-uhh-
sherbheh.

 

[Le Ham]

Have never had either of them, but between the two Dom just appeals to me more. He seems more unique and flavorful, and his facial expressions are true art as far as I'm concerned. Sherb just feels like your average blue lazy and Filbert already holds that place in my heart.

 

[Yaelin]

I have both of them on my island and I love them... I’m an only child, so I see them as my younger siblings. Dom who is into sports but somewhat the geeky one and Sherb being the lazy middle. I enjoy their interactions with one another, cause of their personalities. I chose Sherb in the poll though because I have had him the longest on my island. I guess I can say it was love at first when I found him on one of the mystery islands. Dom visited later via campsite as I didn’t have another Jock that replaced Mott when he left. xD

 

[xlisapisa]

I have neither of them on my island but they both cute in their own ways. If I absolutely had to choose one to like more than the other I guess I’d go with Dom. I personally like the sheep species more than I like the goats, which was the basis of my decision. I’m not very fond of jocks though, but I guess the way Dom looks less jock-ish makes it for his personality trait.

 

[Nefarious]

I have had neither and I don't have a particular strong opinion on both. I like them equally for different reasons. I voted for Sherb though because he's always a "sweater weather" kind of guy and I can relate.

Out of all the new villagers though, I only believe in Cyd supremacy.

 

[Lavamaize]

Sherb! He's one of my favorite villagers on my island! In addition, he also has a great house interior and exterior!

 

[_Rainy_]

I prefer Dom his stupid facial expressions are the best, I too also live in a tie dye sweater most of the time so it’s relatable. Also this face he’s making is relatable.

 

[Dunquixote]

I prefer Dom his stupid facial expressions are the best, I too also live in a tie dye sweater most of the time so it’s relatable. Also this face he’s making is relatable.
View attachment 325357

Oh man. I may now have to let him come back to my island if I find him again (and i may need to change my vote). Though I don’t have enough room; my two spots I’m cycling were for Ankha and Marshal or Lolly. >< That face is too much for me lol. Sherb and Dom both have grown on me so much; I thought i clicked more with Sherb but now I am having my doubts after seeing this picture lol.

 

[Lynnatchii]

Sherb! He's baby, he's cute, he's blue, and suits his personality! When it comes to dom..I don't really like him. I thought he was a lazy and it turns out his a jock. I don't like his eye it just doesn't fit him.

 

[Mr_Persona]

Sherb because Dom is a little creepy. Dom is looking deeply in your soul!

 

[Seastar]

I have both of them. How do I choose one? I can't.

 

[Xara]

i honestly,, don’t like dom at all lmao. i don’t know what it is about him but i find him so irritating like whenever i see him go “” i immediately just wanna lmao

however, i think sherb is adorable!! i’ve personally never had him on my island but he’s so cute! he gets bonus points for being lazy as that’s my second favourite personality aha - he’s just the sweetest lil guy and i love his design! he’s definitely one of the cutest goats + lazies imo c’:

 

[WaileaNoRei]

I like dom better, I think, though I’ve never been in a position to invite him to my island, so not sure if I came across him on a mystery island I would like him enough to invite, or invite him from the campsite. But I like his kind of crazy eyes and goofy expression and his rainbow shirt. I like that he is a jock with the play hobby too. He just looks more fun to me, plus I love how cuddly the sheep look. Also, his Japanese name is Chachamaru, which is pretty fantastic.

sherb is... alright. I don’t dislike him and think he’s cute enough. I actually had him in my campsite the day after i’d just been island hopping for a lazy. I might have invited him, just to try him out, but I had just gotten my favorite lazy (Cole) and so at the time I just couldn’t get excited about him. In general I find him a bit too plain/bland - my taste seems to run a bit more toward the loveable weirdos,

Of course, I thought that fauna would be boring looking (though in her case I liked her more than expected as soon as I saw her) and ended up loving her, so maybe one day sherb will change my mind.

 

[Fye]

I'm not that into either of them but do think they're pretty cute and with their pastel color schemes I can see why they're popular in the animal crossing community. I'd personally go with Dom cause his colors are sweet and those eyes are both cute and hilarious. And I find it both really funny and so sad that he's a jock type. He could have been a perfect lazy or an adorable smug (though in that case he would be too similar to marshal). But I'm also biased towards sheep in general - they look so squish-able!

 

[CrankyCupcake]

Sherb is cute. Dom is unpredictable.

Explanation: Sherb looks cute, acts cute, is cute. Dom doesn't look like a jock, acts like a jock, is jock-lite. Also, his hobby is play, not fitness.

I have both of them on my island. They're adorable. But I think Dom's personality is just a little more complex than Sherb, so he's more interesting. Those facial expressions? Love them.

Last thing. Dom is an evil genius such a prankster!

 

[peachycrossing9]

I have had them both on my island in the past.

I voted for Sherb though, because hes lazy which is my favourite personality. Jock's are the actual worst, so I couldn't handle having Dom on my island for too long. But he is super cute, and I love his huge eyes. If he wasn't a jock I would like him a lot more I think.

Sherb is such a baby and I love his design. His house is also really cute. Don't care for Dom's house much though. (Sorry Dom )

 

[Jas]

honestly, these two and audie are my three favourites out of all the new villagers so it's a TRICKY question - they're both c u t e. after seeing them both in person, i would have to say dom!

 

[BalloonFight]

Definitely Sherb for me. I think he's cuter and he makes sense for his personality. Dom, while fairly cute, is literally the least jock villager ever imo

 

[_Rainy_]

i honestly,, don’t like dom at all lmao. i don’t know what it is about him but i find him so irritating like whenever i see him go “” i immediately just wanna lmao

however, i think sherb is adorable!! i’ve personally never had him on my island but he’s so cute! he gets bonus points for being lazy as that’s my second favourite personality aha - he’s just the sweetest lil guy and i love his design! he’s definitely one of the cutest goats + lazies imo c’:

This made me laugh

 

[KazooSquirrel]

Sherb.

Because his name is Sherb. It's just fun to say, so having him around will be great. Every time you see him and think "Hi Sherb!" You will smile because his name is fun. :3